{ "status": "reviewed_candidate", "metadata_scope_notes": [ { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-PLINY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Read the heading, translation statement, complete section 70 and footer. The web version credits Rackham (1952) with alterations and changes some place-name spellings. The preceding 53 peoples concern Old Latium, not a Stabiae population total. The existing note records the April 29/30 calendar-rendering difference; retain year-level 89 BCE and the authoring hold.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-CICERO-II", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Read the heading, translation credit, complete section 20, both displayed translator footnotes and footer. Blakiston (1894) is explicitly credited. The orator distinguishes some indebted Sullan settlers and nearby poorer farmers; this national context does not establish an Arretium parcel, headcount or completed removal.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-CICERO-III", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Read the heading, translation credit, complete section 14, all four displayed translator footnotes and footer. Cicero identifies P. Furius among Sulla’s Faesulae settlers. The passage does not enumerate all settlers or establish a settlement foundation date; the family hold remains.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-GRANIUS", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "Read introduction, contents, Book 35 opening and complete Telamon paragraph, the Book 36 page-35 paragraph, and footer. The translation uses Criniti sentence numbering and Flemisch page numbering. The fragment #35 reaches red page 35 at Faesulae in Book 36; the Telamon passage spans red pages 16–17 in Book 35. Propose #16 as the nearest preceding observed anchor. Missing and supplied text retain their notation; no exact manuscript or printing has been checked.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-MEMNON", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "Read Greek header, introductory lines, complete chapter 12.1–6 and footer; read the English companion introduction and complete chapter 12.1–6, and the full short information page. The selected URL is Greek text transmitted through Photius. The English companion says its translation uses Jacoby FGrH 434; do not transfer an unverified exact edition or unnamed translator to the Greek record. This is a bounded textual comparison, not a critical-edition collation or renewed Astakos acceptance.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-CHRONOLOGY", "records": [ 5 ], "note": "Read the chronology header, entry 6 and footer, and full How to use this site. This modern event/reference compilation cites Pliny for Stabiae; it is not a second independent ancient attestation. Modern references confirm dates according to the site’s account. Linked CAH, event-symbol explanations and other entries’ source works were not read. Preserve the inactive and historical occurrence scopes.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-DATE-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ], "note": "Rackham 1952 and Blakiston 1894 are dates in translation credits; 63 BCE dates the speeches. Copyright 2025 is separate from chronology year 89 BCE. Bare numeric footer dates are recorded as displayed, without assigning publication or revision semantics. No edition publisher, DOI, ISBN or manuscript reading is inferred.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-SITE-LIMITS", "records": [ 3, 4, 5 ], "note": "The full notation key and How to use page were read. The site says its new translations have not undergone scholarly review and may contain mistakes. Preserve that disclosure as the site’s account. The material inspected supplied no funding or conflict statement; this does not establish absence of funding or conflict.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-DECODING", "records": [ 0, 5 ], "note": "Two initial derived texts used UTF-8 replacement despite declared ISO-8859-1. New derived texts use the declared charset. Original raw bytes, initial text and original retrieval receipts remain unchanged; TEXT_DECODING binds both versions. No new network request was needed for this repair.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_attalus_access_20260910", "id": "ATTALUS-ACCESS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ], "note": "Six original and four follow-up HTML requests returned 200 and are terminal. Reading was bounded as recorded per source, not complete inspection of all speeches, books or chronology entries. No PDF, page image, physical volume, external archive or remote backup was inspected or completed. Thirty-two private original and derived files are hash-bound.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain this source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-FORNARA-EDITION", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The second edition is 1983, distinct from the 1977 first edition, the 2007 fourteenth printing and the platform’s 2010 digital date. Fornara is editor and translator of a source collection, not the author of its ancient testimonia. The existing pp.25–26 locator was not reached.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-CAMPBELL-ROLE", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Gwyn Campbell is the book author; the African Studies Series board is not a book editor list. The full title includes The Rise and Fall of an Island Empire. Publisher summary claims remain attributed interpretations, not new atlas adjudication.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-PERKINS-EDITION", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Original access ISBN corresponds to the 2004 first edition. Princeton explicitly labels the edition and author. Its ISSN field contains cloth/paper ISBNs; use their demonstrated ISBN roles. The 2014 edition’s DOI CBO9781139162227 and different ISBNs must not be assigned to this 2004 source.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-OSTLER-SCOPE", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "The full title identifies a Plains Sioux study. Its preview cannot by itself verify every nation, route, bison-economy claim or homesteading mechanism in the broader Great Plains case. Series editors and acknowledged translation assistance are not book authors or book-wide translator credits.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-HUGUENOTS-MISMATCH", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "The recorded Huguenots title is the Brill 2011 edited volume. The Cambridge asset ISBN 9781107076259 identifies Phil Orchard’s A Right to Flee (2014), as demonstrated by its companion frontmatter. The exact original excerpt body was not obtained. Preserve the old URL as erroneous provenance and propose a publisher link matching the title. Do not merge Orchard’s book into Trim’s title identity or count two URLs as independent corroboration.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-HUGUENOTS-CONTENTS", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "Trim is editor of the book and author of specific chapters. Publisher contents list the introduction at pp.1–42; this is a lead, not verified support for the event’s complete 1685–1715 narrative. The volume is an edited collection, not a single-author monograph. A chapter DOI and book-review DOI are not the whole-book DOI.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-DATES-IDENTIFIERS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "Citation/copyright years use explicit publication fields; search engine Published/Crawled labels are not publication dates. Four book/edition DOI assignments remain unverified. Fornara’s DOI is explicit in the publisher product record; no resolver success is claimed. ISBN digits retain the printed binding/version roles.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-ACCESS-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "Five original direct captures timed out, with no source bodies. Web retrieval delivered Ostler frontmatter, selected Orchard PDF text and Princeton metadata; other evidence is publisher-indexed text. Both Orchard screenshot attempts failed. Browser inspection could not continue because the Mac was locked. No new repeated permission/unlock request was sent while independent work remained.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-FUNDING-READING", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "The initial opened Ostler acknowledgments disclose University of Oregon support, Oregon Humanities Center fellowships, National Endowment for the Humanities support and the Stanley B. Greenfield fund; its initial raw response was not persisted, so this is a labelled observation, not a new field backed by saved source bytes. No exhaustive funding/conflict review of any work occurred. Complete books, case passages, page images, underlying ancient sources and remote backup are unverified.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-PRESERVATION", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "The five stable IDs, original labels/URLs, 20 occurrences, five citations and two current cases are preserved. Metadata improvements and the wrong-link repair do not admit a case, change scores/holds/dates/routes, or establish refugee origin. Publication application remains separate.", "status": "retained_scope_limit", "disposition": "Carry the stated preview, identity, source-access or attribution limit; no historical acceptance change." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-MUCHINOV", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Printed pp. 84–93 were read. Pages 85–88 connect Caucasian arrivals, the 1862–1867 interval, frontier districts, village placement and land allocation; p. 91 covers local provisioning burdens. Vilayet totals cannot be assigned to either tract or added to later arrivals. Later departure after 1877 is separate. The article combines official and other historical sources; reported misconduct and integration judgments remain attributed. Those underlying sources were not newly inspected.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-TURGUT", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Printed pp. 25–27 and 38–42 support a bounded reading of the author’s origin hypothesis, Carian locality list and waqf institutions. Hypothesized elite genealogy is not a demonstrated refugee cohort or dated population transfer. The long recorded label is a research log spanning several works; only this PDF’s identity is reconciled. Grant’s captive-transaction evidence is a separate work, not evidence supplied by this article. The Menteşe authoring hold remains.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-KARATAS", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Printed pp. 90, 94–96 and 114–115 connect forced Caucasian migration, collective Uzunyayla settlement, land categories and local conflict. Nearly 3,000 households is provincial; 318 households/2,201 people are an unsettled remainder, not additive totals. The reported 1864 milestone does not prove a complete village register. Administrative allegations and the author’s general evaluations are attributed, not independently established. Underlying archival documents were not newly opened.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-PETKOVA", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "Printed pp. 25–30 and 36–37 identify a study of settlement and taxation in eastern Upper Thrace, especially Eskihisar zağra. It supports a regional sedentarization discussion, not by itself every claim in the broad 1352–1600 Balkan sürgün bundle. General migration pressures do not establish a specific fleeing settler cohort. The older gapscan verdict already recognized Petkova and requested correction; its warning did not reach the frozen label. No new historical admission is inferred.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-DATES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Publication years are secure. Muchinov’s issue says September 2016; platform details say September 30 and generated citations September 1. Turgut is printed XLIX (2017), with platform March 16 versus citation March 1. Karataş is printed Kış/Winter 2013 versus platform June 1; platform submission July 2014 is not a credible replacement publication date. Petkova is printed December 2019; platform publication December 27 versus citations December 1, and PDF acceptance December 27 versus platform December 28. Preserve labelled observations; no single exact day is adopted.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-TITLE-AND-CREDIT", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Printed titles and author bylines control. Karataş’s printed title says Sırasında, while the platform says Sonrasında; its running header says Karakaş while the title-page and platform agree on Karataş. These are recorded discrepancies, not a second author. Petkova’s printed subtitle and space before Yörüks are retained. Embedded Murat Topçu, Bozturke and production filenames are not article authors; the platform’s publisher fields are not automatically institutional credits.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-IDENTIFIERS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Two DOI strings are explicit on their original publisher records. No resolver or registry call is claimed. The other two records supply IZ links, which are not DOIs; DOI assignment remains unverified. Printed XLIX, issue 36 and Year 2 retain their roles rather than being silently converted to platform volume/issue duplicates. Muchinov’s English body is not relabelled Turkish from a conflicting platform primary-language field.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Turgut’s first-page footnote thanks VAKAR for material and moral contributions. The other inspected identity regions show affiliations but no source-specific funding or competing-interest declaration was observed. A full extracted-text keyword scan supplements bounded reading and is not exhaustive disclosure verification. Historical treasury support and refugee assistance are not research funding. No absence of funding/conflicts or independent source neutrality is asserted.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-ACCESS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Four direct original requests failed in address lookup. Browser PDF downloads and four linked publisher records succeeded; eight standalone first/last images were inspected. PDFium text exists for all pages, but only listed pages were read. Karataş triggers pypdf object warnings, while PDFium successfully reads and renders it. No source bytes were repaired. Private local evidence is preserved; no public archive, remote copy or publication application is verified.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_dergipark_20260910", "id": "DERGIPARK-FLIGHT", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "The Circassian sources connect origin pressure with Ottoman settlement and remain useful for the existing incoming-flight work. State strategies and displaced households are distinct actors, and destination burdens remain visible. This metadata pass does not assign an additional flag, a legal refugee status, new coordinates or scores. Turgut’s hypothesis and Petkova’s general migration discussion do not independently close a new cohort-specific flag.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the recorded source role and reading boundary. No new case, score, legal status or flight-origin decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-MORIOKA-DATE", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The guide credits TSUSHIMA as writer and KONNO and ITO as translators. Copyright is 2023; the exhibition ran 7 October 2023–21 January 2024. Replace the source note’s 2025 bibliographic year in a later successor. The image illustrator and 2022 map source are separate credits.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "348b42699c0c036c52cd8af186013efc007a773cb9fa211f0637a519036fd31e", "3ef02559ac431016e55004b5e1b340c438abce75014f0a20196f4b5878b0a900" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-MORIOKA-SCOPE", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "All four guide pages were read. Its archaeology account describes local continuity, limited planned state settlements and indirect rule; the loss of excavation materials in the 1999 fire limits the record. Mid-ninth-century famine-related flight is not evidence of incoming colonizers fleeing their origins. No historical score, new flight assignment or whole-region population replacement follows.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "348b42699c0c036c52cd8af186013efc007a773cb9fa211f0637a519036fd31e" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-AKITA", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The original Japanese title has 発掘; deposited metadata has 発堀. Keep both roles explicit. The English abstract supports a 733 Dewa no saku foundation and mixed residents; parasite evidence is described as a possibility of a continental visitor, not proof of a migrant population. Read original PDF pages 1, 2, 10 and 11 only. Institutional affiliation is not a funding declaration.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "3ef02559ac431016e55004b5e1b340c438abce75014f0a20196f4b5878b0a900", "e6d81a528b03680fb7d6adf103f5aa193b5aacffc6683094af05e57aab71f3ee" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-IDE", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Publication, receipt/acceptance and online availability are separate dates; receipt and acceptance are both 25 September 2004 as reported. The English abstract supports bounded regional exchange and changing material culture, not a population share or the labor assignment of the 725 cohort. Read PDF pages 1, 2, 19 and 20 only; the awkward source English is not a new translation.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "81c600cce518a7965aace43993f71dd0a9217220f4a820c2c0f146380fae7da9" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-TOKUTAN", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "The government record distinguishes the 811 relocation proposal from completion in 814. Its 1969 designation date does not date the online record. Garbled characters in the displayed Japanese description are retained rather than silently reconstructed. These facts do not change the accepted event endpoint or geometry.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "a583241219402334c5c2d423acf83d30eec956ab1f8b10b8549f7e403aa417f1" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-GRANT-ROLES", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "KAKENHI 15K02987 is a project record with named principal/co-investigators and a separately linked five-page final report. Portal publication/modification, project period and report as-of 15 June 2018 are different dates. Total, direct and indirect awards are project amounts, not personal payments. Collaborators are not automatically article authors; peer-review indicators apply to listed products individually.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "3ef02559ac431016e55004b5e1b340c438abce75014f0a20196f4b5878b0a900", "5ead6a965f22d0caade8516bda7be4be91d415e1f02571e5d18aba65cc470891" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-GRANT-METHODS", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "All five final-report pages were read. Delayed approval and budget reduction narrowed the planned nationwide study to eight named prefectures around Kanto. Long-flue hearths and pottery are imperfect indicators; some local production and ordinary material culture limit ethnic inference. Figure 1 is rice allowances, not people. The report cannot assign an occupation or outcome to the particular 725 cohort.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "0450895780fcd50ca9fa2b58e68c338005c3233ae177c15083f36aebb61da3ad", "3ef02559ac431016e55004b5e1b340c438abce75014f0a20196f4b5878b0a900" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-GRANT-OUTPUT-DISCREPANCIES", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "Two linked output citations disagree between project record and report: the 2017 Shinano article’s page range and the 2015 Yamanashi journal volume. Leave these product-level differences open until the original articles are inspected; do not change the checked project identity or assert all listed output counts match.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "0450895780fcd50ca9fa2b58e68c338005c3233ae177c15083f36aebb61da3ad", "5ead6a965f22d0caade8516bda7be4be91d415e1f02571e5d18aba65cc470891" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-GEOSHAPE", "records": [ 5, 6 ], "note": "These are two individual place records. The 1990 and 1987 dates and ISBNs belong to the reference volumes, and DOI 10.20676/00000456 identifies the dataset. The website content is CC BY 4.0; this does not license the paid JapanKnowledge volumes. Record-specific dates stay unknown. Coordinate precision is explicitly under improvement and supplies no verified ancient boundary.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "88698f77afa3b31cc96bfd1ec08d4dc82cb51f2c9fd0349a8c917d7ecbdf6a42", "e1c70c0ed3bfe100c9a427a5b50175f8a99d22cb7bc08409c1bb533e5dec79b8" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-FRIDAY-IDENTITY", "records": [ 7 ], "note": "The working public PDF confirms Friday, Winter 1997, volume 23 issue 1, pages 1–24, and Society for Japanese Studies as the original print publisher. Preserve the earlier DOI record’s first-page-only deposit and University of California Press as deposited metadata; the newly read original supplies a later preferred-citation refinement. No stable identity is merged. The 2021 download stamp and Vienna host do not date or publish the article.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "b5852b64b71c749daeaa35ab4e2a25304ed6792acb4c15408562d67a4220e3e8", "c2a3cf7d6d8e16ce32d19dfe12b5209c777ad29c5f90b20ee24d9dccbf891c7e" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-FRIDAY-PASSAGES", "records": [ 7 ], "note": "Read the wrapper and printed pages 1, 6, 7, 22, 23 and 24. Printed page 7 note 15 identifies the 725 intercalary-month entry and 782 fushu sent from Mutsu to Iyo, Izumi and other provinces; it does not allocate the total between destinations. Printed page 1 acknowledges Japan Foundation and Social Science Research Council support; the University of Georgia line on page 24 is an affiliation. Friday’s chronicle bridge remains attributed to Friday; no original chronicle was newly read.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "c2a3cf7d6d8e16ce32d19dfe12b5209c777ad29c5f90b20ee24d9dccbf891c7e" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-IBERIA-INDEX", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The page is Selected Sources: Iberia within the Internet Medieval Sourcebook, not the Chronicle of 754 itself. Its specific link names Aymenn Jawad Al-Tamimi as translator/analyst of the Mozarabic Chronicle and describes that text as a contemporary Latin-language source. The adjacent Byzantine-Arabic Chronicle is a different entry. The existing Iberia note uses Fordham as an identification aid, not independent corroboration of conquest claims.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-EINHARD-ROLES", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Einhard is the historical author; Samuel Epes Turner is the named translator of the reported New York, Harper & Brothers 1880 edition. The note describes a 1960 University of Michigan reprint with prefatory material by Sidney Painter; it does not make Painter the translator. The print editions and Latin manuscript/critical text were not inspected.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-EINHARD-PASSAGE", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Section 7, Saxon War, reports removal of ten thousand people described as living by the Elbe and settlement with wives and children in scattered groups in Gaul and Germany; [804] is bracketed in this English presentation. The source-attributed number is not an independently checked census or a count of complete households. This passage does not establish the Obodrite land grant, later reversal or c.811 return in the broader event. Those depend on the event’s other sources.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-APPIAN-CREDITS", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Appian is the ancient author; Oliver J. Thatcher is the source-anthology editor; J. S. Arkenberg is credited with scanning. The host credits page identifies Jerome S. Arkenberg as a contributing editor for scanning/input, but the typed field retains the local initials. No translator is named on the selected page. Do not inherit Horace White from the distinct Perseus or LacusCurtius editions.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-APPIAN-LOCATOR", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The Fordham paragraph under [For 122–121 B.C.] corresponds to Appian Civil Wars 1.24 in the preserved LacusCurtius source. Both contain six thousand colonists, recruitment from Italy, town/boundary layout and repeal conflict. This is a passage-location comparison of the same ancient account, not independent historical corroboration or proof of exact translation/edition identity. The Fordham footer literal I: I-3 is retained as reported, not read as the entire modern section range.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-APPIAN-LIMITS", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The existing Junonia citation is already correctly specific; no replacement is required. Neither six thousand households nor equal 200-iugera lots nor a computed footprint follows from Appian. The law’s later protection, transfers and institutional-duration qualifications remain assigned to Kim and legal evidence. No modern resident-removal finding, recruitment route or change of start date follows from the page’s editorial date caption.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-DATES-HOST", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "The common site creation 26 January 1996 and latest revision 28 August 2026 are template/design dates. They are not publication dates of every selected page. Einhard’s document notice separately gives August 1996 and January 1999; Appian’s notice gives May 1998. Print-source years 1880 and 1907 have distinct roles. Fordham provides web/server support; the page explicitly calls IHSP independent of Fordham and does not make the university publisher of the ancient or medieval text.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-PERSPECTIVE-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "Einhard’s preface claims personal knowledge, court friendship and an obligation to commemorate Charlemagne; his Saxon-war language is overtly partisan. Appian’s transmitted rhetoric concerning slaves, wealth and political factions remains attributed to the text. Host support and contributor credits are disclosed; no exhaustive funding, conflicts or neutrality audit is claimed. Modern electronic-use notices remain distinct from the age of an underlying translation. Raw source evidence remains private.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_fordham_20260910", "id": "FD-PRESERVATION", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "All three IDs, original labels/URLs and nine occurrences remain. The index has no current citation or case; Einhard binds a release event but no current registry citation. Appian binds the existing Junonia citation/case. Reading these passages for source identity and locators does not reopen accepted scientific or authoring decisions, create a hold, or assign flight origin.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve source identity, attribution, reading bounds and historical acceptance; no new case or score decision." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-IDENTITY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The headline, byline and publication name establish the separate Edna Namara news article. Preserve the older title with its parenthetical publication name and the stable ID as provenance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-DATES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Displayed publication date is 21 March 2022; embedded publication timestamp agrees. Embedded modification is 10 April 2022. No visible change log or earlier-byte comparison establishes the substance of that modification. Relative last August is read in the 2022 reporting context, not as a fresh legal development." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-CREDITS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Edna Namara is credited as reporter and photographer; the article says she translated some interviews from Rufumbira. It also names six editorial roles. These are publisher credits, not proof of independently audited editorial practice, current employment, or accuracy of unseen original interviews." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-COURT", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The article reports an August court victory and a direction to provide land/compensation, but also an appeal, counsel’s expectations of delay, a wildlife-authority response and an implementation warning. Treat these as March 2022 reporting, not an inspected judgment/order, a current appeal outcome or evidence that restitution was completed." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-COUNTS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "About 200 describes the Rokeri settlement at reporting time, about 6,700 describes Uganda’s Batwa, and more than 200,000 concerns several countries and displacement causes. None is a verified 1991 Bwindi/Mgahinga or Echuya eviction cohort. Ancient-origin and gorilla-population claims were not independently researched or imported into the atlas." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-ECHUYA", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The story mentions three protected areas together and reports Serutokyi’s Echuya connection. This does not establish a common eviction instrument/date or resolve the separately retained Echuya source question." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-TESTIMONY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Speakers’ accounts, wishes for cultural access and the claim that most do not seek permanent return retain speaker and reporting-time attribution. They do not establish a representative preference survey, consent to eviction or completed return. Photographic captions were read; photographs/graphic were not independently inspected here." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-FUNDING", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Forest Peoples Programme is described as funding the organization’s legal representation, not funding this article. Advocacy organizations, government spokesperson, counsel and community representatives retain their distinct roles. No article funding/conflict disclosure, republishing license or exhaustive institutional audit is asserted." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-FLIGHT", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The comparison with refugees describes displaced Batwa’s hardship; it is not proof that incoming colonizers or conservation authorities were fleeing. No incoming-flight flag is assigned." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-JUDGMENT-LEADS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "A search of the judiciary-associated ULII catalogue returned two similarly titled entries dated 19 August 2021, with conflicting petition-year/citation metadata: UGCC 25 / petition 3 of 2013 and UGCC 22 / petition 3 of 2011. These are leads for a separate primary-document comparison, not accepted judgment identity, duplicate detection or legal holding. No judgment PDF was opened in this article pass." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-ACIEN-IDENTITY", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The two stable access IDs identify the same Acién article through its PDF and landing-page routes. Title, author, 20(1), 1999, DOI and 47–64 agree across preserved PDF and publisher-indexed metadata. Preserve both IDs and occurrences; a second access route is not independent historical evidence.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-ACIEN-DATES", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Publisher-indexed publication date is 30 June 1999. The opening footnote describes a 1993 colloquium and retained text with later citation updates. Embedded PDF creation in 2010, modification in 2019 and the landing copyright 2019 are separate digital/document notices, not alternate article publication dates.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-ACIEN-SCOPE", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The opening acknowledges sparse archaeological dating before the ninth century and limits its main geography to southern al-Andalus, especially eastern Andalusia, with conqueror discussion mainly about detectable Arab groups. The closing abstract proposes two successive eighth-century configurations and a later Syrian/rural phase. These are attributed regional interpretations, not exact population shares or a peninsula-wide measure; the existing later-phase exclusion remains.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-ACIEN-NOTICES", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The PDF and publisher-indexed page name CSIC and report CC BY 4.0. Acién is affiliated with Universidad de Málaga; the opening footnote names the Universidad de Alcalá de Henares, Casa de Velázquez and Instituto de Cooperación con el Mundo Árabe as 1993 colloquium organizers. This is institutional context, not a comprehensive funding statement or neutrality finding.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-KONIG-IDENTITY", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "König’s English article is Transmediterranean History 2(1), 2020, PDF pp.1–11, with DOI 10.18148/tmh/2020.2.1.24. Publisher-indexed article metadata reports 15 June 2020 and lists Arabic, English and German downloads. The English PDF’s embedded 2023 creation date is not treated as a revised publication date or independently established translation-release date.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-KONIG-SOURCE", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The source block explicitly credits Daniel G. König for the treaty translation from al-ʿUḏrī, edited by ʿAbd al-ʿAzīz al-Ahwānī, Madrid 1965, pp.4–5. This is a cited edition as reported by the article, not a newly inspected Arabic edition or an original 713 manuscript. The article’s listed variants and modern translations are separate textual transmissions, not independent surviving original treaties.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-KONIG-PROTECTIONS", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The translated treaty on pp.1–2 protects people, wives/children, churches and religion conditionally and specifies tribute, including a reduced slave amount. It does not expressly guarantee property or establish a newly imported conquest labor population. The older source note’s property phrase was already narrowed in the current event and successor source register; no new correction is needed.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_iberia_journals_20260910", "id": "IJ-ACCESS-LIMITS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "Two preserved official PDFs match their prior capture receipts and the receipt manifest’s sealed hash. Today’s Acién landing/PDF requests failed; publisher-indexed metadata remained available. König’s original PDF was delivered by the web tool while its DOI open failed. No new PDF byte capture, browser route, whole-article reading, exhaustive disclosure audit, original Arabic-edition inspection or public/remote application is claimed.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Preserve exact metadata, access identities, source intermediaries and existing temporal/property qualifications." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-ARTICLE-DATES", "records": [ 1, 2, 3, 5 ], "note": "Both articles were issued on 31 March 2000 in volume 84. The 1 April 2016 catalogue release and 2023 repository version display are different dates; no textual revision is inferred.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "f7ab62c9f55524307915e78241a6f87e718b9f2fd8db52c53cf304a122b86eae", "fe9412fe3a04905d514747d8a791bdf4d49b05fab6889db5de8571968547e8b9" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-PAIRED-ACCESS", "records": [ 1, 2, 3, 5 ], "note": "The paired catalogue and PDF links identify the same two articles. Preserve four stable access identities and their original occurrences. Japanese, kana and English name forms are source-supplied; the English titles are not new translations.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "f7ab62c9f55524307915e78241a6f87e718b9f2fd8db52c53cf304a122b86eae", "fe9412fe3a04905d514747d8a791bdf4d49b05fab6889db5de8571968547e8b9" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-CREDITS", "records": [ 1, 2, 3, 5 ], "note": "The inspected terminal pages name university affiliations and museum research-cooperator roles. These are not funding declarations. No publication-specific grant or competing-interest statement was found in the eight inspected pages; no claim is made about the full articles or project funding.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "98817b7085f414b8861ef8a9a8c1f906d8dae762cf776c2faefdf32c93730be9" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-KUMAGAI", "records": [ 3, 5 ], "note": "Kumagai’s English abstract on printed page 90 (PDF page 30) proposes a relationship between the 720 revolt and Taga construction, and reports tax, military, county and immigrant measures. Its tentative causal language remains attributed. It is not a unique removal census or evidence of complete local expulsion.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "98817b7085f414b8861ef8a9a8c1f906d8dae762cf776c2faefdf32c93730be9", "f7ab62c9f55524307915e78241a6f87e718b9f2fd8db52c53cf304a122b86eae" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-TAKEHIRO", "records": [ 1, 2 ], "note": "Takehiro’s English abstract on printed page 115 (PDF page 25) describes changing classifications and incomplete incorporation. It does not provide the 782-person transfer count; the frozen event cites Friday separately for that figure. No new score, legal status or removal total follows from metadata acceptance.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "98817b7085f414b8861ef8a9a8c1f906d8dae762cf776c2faefdf32c93730be9", "fe9412fe3a04905d514747d8a791bdf4d49b05fab6889db5de8571968547e8b9" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-SITE-SCOPE", "records": [ 0, 4, 6, 7 ], "note": "The four links are individual site records with report-catalogue links. Coordinate pairs are site pointers used in the saved authoring note; they do not prove an ancient boundary, route, household origin or extent of displacement. No map coordinate is changed.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "0dc3f3e5592345d8b506445cefb6c58dc2e8053c4a081e62c7eef8cffd816192", "3cd10904f8d8e4327c02aca0b775ef61c97eab92fa7a713886b3c6d65da1279c", "46f27edb43f82dc2f76297dda80443efb336abf6bf81c045dc49d573c543ed89", "ffb51aba9fcdeedcc2a9710795ba94ab55e2d2b5d7b15368015b7fe215e149aa" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-AKITA-RECORD", "records": [ 6 ], "note": "The Akita record is explicitly the 122nd investigation. Its summary discusses the 121st, 122nd and 123rd investigations; preserve that narrower record identity instead of presenting it as the full castle history or report.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "3cd10904f8d8e4327c02aca0b775ef61c97eab92fa7a713886b3c6d65da1279c" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_japan_institutions_20260911", "id": "JP-ISAWA-ACCESS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The original Isawa URL now supplies an empty application shell and the ordinary browser stayed blank. Its indexed representation and linked report catalogue identify the source. The linked 1991 report describes several site entries; that report date and its named writers do not date or author the map record. A fresh current record body remains unverified.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "46f27edb43f82dc2f76297dda80443efb336abf6bf81c045dc49d573c543ed89", "6a3f1d186e65ba58434e92c3f0c91fcc6dff30bb6fbb71a0df489029bb86b87d", "f69d04dd4f0739a7d81703efb2abd616f156f94013ee77952f72117cf665783d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-ACCESS-PAIR", "records": [ 0, 3 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Stable and content/seq access records identify the same Ortega chapter; preserve both work IDs, all three occurrences and original URLs. Chapter 19 and viewer sequence 7 are different locator types.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-ORTEGA-CONTAINER", "records": [ 0, 3 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The JSTOR full container display spells Post-Roman lberia with lowercase l. The prepared container uses the verified short Crossref title The Visigothic Kingdom. No unsupported spelling correction, editor list or chapter reinterpretation is supplied. Printed range 375–392 and viewer count 20 retain separate roles.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-DATE-ROLES", "records": [ 2, 4, 6, 7, 9 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Olivelle ©2023 and January 2024 publisher/registry dates; Cosa ©1987 and Legacy edition 2017; Cape December 1992 issue and February 2007 online date; Asylia ©1996 and registry chapter date September 2023 retain their observed roles. Registry labels do not alone prove an edition chronology.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-ASHOKA-EXTENT", "records": [ 2 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Yale hardcover 408 pages and ebook 320 pages are separate products. JSTOR also lists 320 but its index is numbered 341–356; exact ebook extent remains open. Contents confirm the existing Ruler 18–59, Deepening the Faith 101–113 and Preaching Dharma 188–210 locators only, not the historical claims citing them.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-COSA-CREDIT", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The title-page BY line credits McCann, Bourgeois, Gazda, Oleson and Will. Crossref labels the record edited-book and lists only McCann as author. Preserve both attributed observations; the preface signature Director and Editor, Cosa Port Excavations does not establish a sole whole-volume editor.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-COSA-LIMITS", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Complete preface inspected: collaborative archaeology/science/engineering project with institutional, foundation and private support. Manuscript completed December 1982, with material through June 1984 in footnotes; the 2017 reprint is not evidence of research updated to 2017. Telamon p. 22/note 54 was not newly read in this metadata pass; the prior expressly probabilistic source-note qualification remains.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-CHAPTER-ACCESS", "records": [ 7, 8 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Nicomedia and Western Anatolia DOI/access routes lead to parent books in the browser. Their exact chapter entries and opening snippets were inspected; full chapters were not. Rigsby and Woudhuizen are recorded as container authors, not inferred separate chapter bylines from absent Crossref authors.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-PRIOR-HISTORY", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "All prior case and source-note qualifications remain. Metadata and abstracts do not newly establish a Sullan Telamon destruction, exact Ashokan counts/chronology or destinations, continuous Astakos destruction-transfer, a comprehensive Iberian property map, Hittite deportee totals or new Akosombo findings. No historical rating, geometry or admission is changed.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-DOI-COSA-LIMIT", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Seven registry identities were inspected and six DOI destinations matched metadata. Cosa DOI browser body matching remains partial because only a shortened title and cookie dialog were visible. Registry and distributor preview agree on identity; no full landing-body pass is claimed.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_jstor_20260910", "id": "JS-MIESCHER-FORMATS", "records": [ 9 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "IUP gives two eBook ISBNs without subformat labels; both remain eBook identifiers without a guessed PDF/EPUB assignment. The contents list acknowledgments; that section and full book were not read.", "disposition": "Retain this source-specific limit. Metadata preparation does not supply new historical verification or make an adequate short citation defective." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-IDENTITY", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Both retained access IDs identify Nicolas Landry’s source study, printed pp.48–64 of volume 86. The older generic Acadian-settlement label is not the actual article title. The printed Saint-Pierre-et-Miquelon spelling controls the landing page’s collapsed Pierreet form; original labels/URLs remain as provenance.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-DATES", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The printed issue is Fall 2017 and embedded citation_date is 2017. The landing page displays publication on 22 July 2019 and supplies a 2019 citation, while DC.Date.issued says 23 July 2019. The one-day discrepancy is preserved without an inferred cause or canonical release instant. PDF creation on 29 April 2019, page modification metadata and the Érudit wrapper generation date are separate technical notices.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-DOI-PUBLISHER", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The publisher-distributor’s indexed Érudit cover explicitly gives DOI 10.7202/1062474ar, Cape Breton University Press, print ISSN 1718-1259, digital ISSN 1927-9264, and rights reserved to Nicolas Landry in 2019. The journal history confirms Cape Breton production from 2006 and a later move to Mount Allison in December 2020; the current institutional home is not backdated to this issue.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-SOURCE-DESIGN", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Landry reports examining 43 personal files in the Ministry’s series E and explicitly says these cover more than 43 individuals, especially families. The files concern petitioners seeking royal assistance and other claims. They are not a complete deportee census, household roster, property-loss inventory or neutral sample of every refugee.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-1778-LOCUS", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Printed p.57 describes supplies for ships carrying Miquelon inhabitants to France after the 1778 conquest. Printed p.61 n.23 identifies Saint-Pierre/Miquelon inhabitants sent back to France and receiving subsistence at Cherbourg during 1778–1779. Laroche’s 11,332-livre losses and some other losses discussed on p.57 belong to 1758; they are not reassigned to the 1778 operation.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-RETURN-LOCUS", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Printed p.57 says the Ross/Herpin family wished to re-establish itself at Saint-Pierre in 1783 and describes a family of fourteen. This is a particular intention, not a complete actual-return count or census. The current 1778 case already defines the endpoint as restoration and permitted return, preserving this limit.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-DATE-CONFLICT", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Printed p.48 and the landing abstract give 1791 for the second conquest. The current second case explicitly discloses that statement and keeps 1793 based on its other accepted sources. Those other works are not newly opened or re-verified in this metadata review; their existing decision is preserved.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-FLIGHT-SCOPE", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The article follows refugees from French colonial communities, with prior flight, residence and proposed re-establishment across distinct periods. This does not establish a flight motive for the British actors in the two current removal cases or justify an automatic incoming-flight flag. Footnote 24 and p.64 point to Mouhot’s separate 2012 Acadian migration study; that work is not opened or newly accepted here.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_landry_20260910", "id": "LD-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The article page identifies Landry’s Université de Moncton affiliation and author biography. The journal describes its articles/reports as refereed and assigns responsibility for contributions to their authors; this is a journal self-description, not inspected peer-review records or proof of neutrality. Original PDF and landing both returned HTTP200. The Érudit direct PDF attempt returned an anti-bot challenge, and the Crossref web URL was rejected as unsafe/non-retryable; neither was bypassed or relabelled successful. Four PDF pages, the landing and listed web-result portions were inspected; the full article, original archives and exhaustive funding/conflict history were not.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct dates, source identity, precise locators and existing case qualifications. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-PLUTARCH-ROUTES", "records": [ 0, 3 ], "note": "Both original Plutarch routes succeed. The page headed 1.14.3 contains the section-3 passage within the chapter-14 page after whitespace normalization. Retain distinct access records and original locators; no required URL correction is established. The comparison does not certify the entire work or edition.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-PLUTARCH-SCOPE", "records": [ 0, 3 ], "note": "The translated section attributes restoration of Aeginetans, Melians and Scionaeans to Lysander after Athenian departure. Dates in the displayed numbered notes remain translator/editorial apparatus, not newly verified independent evidence or a chronology revision. The full chapter and its notes were read, but the cited Xenophon cross-references were not.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-HERODOTUS-523", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Herodotus 5.23 describes Megabazos bringing Paionians across the straits to Sardis and then a discussion of Histiaios. The current label also says custody at Sardis; this reading does not separately establish its legal or institutional form. Retain the source label and existing event judgment pending any substantive passage-support review.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-HERODOTUS-598", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "Herodotus 5.98 depicts a partial flight and return: some Paionians remained. The active record also names Histories 5.14–17 and Badian on the Ionian revolt. Only 5.98 and this translation metadata were read in this packet; the bundled works and chronology are not re-certified. Existing family-hold, inactive and current-case scopes remain distinct.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-SALLUST", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Catiline’s War 37.9 describes proscribed parents, property loss and curtailed rights within Sallust’s account of subsequent political discontent. The chapter’s adverse descriptions of the commons are the ancient narrator’s rhetoric, not neutral classifications adopted here. The selected chapter does not itself quantify the earlier proscriptions or establish every descendant’s later action.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-DIO", "records": [ 5 ], "note": "Dio 53.25.4–5 describes sale of those of military age, a twenty-year non-liberation condition and allocation of the best land to some Pretorians, with Augusta Praetoria later. Preserve these population and sequence limits. No broader enslavement total, coordinate, event date or statistical cell is adjudicated by this metadata pass.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-EDITION-DATES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ], "note": "Macaulay is identified with a two-volume 1890 edition; Rolfe with a 1921 printing; Cary with the nine-volume 1914–1927 series. These are edition roles, not ancient work dates or web publication dates. Perrin’s exact printing/year is absent on the inspected page and remains explicitly unknown for both access records. No print publisher, individual Dio volume year, ISBN, DOI, pagination or manuscript witness is inferred.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_lexundria_20260910", "id": "LEX-DISCLOSURE-ACCESS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5 ], "note": "Ten direct HTML requests succeeded and are terminal; all six translated sections and four work-information pages were read as text. No PDF, physical book, page image, external archive or remote backup was inspected or completed. The pages consulted supplied no funding or conflict disclosure; absence is not proof of no funding or conflict. Linked illustrations and other site pages were not assessed.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-APPIAN", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Fragments 1a–1c report a general Volscian war involving Roman colonies and the Coriolanus tradition. The inspected passage does not name Circeii or give a Circeian expulsion, destination or land outcome. Suda and Constantine excerpt labels, modern chronological numbering and Jona Lendering’s notes remain distinct from Horace White’s translation. The earlier Circeii note already states these limits.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-PHILOSTRATUS", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Sections 1.23–24 are a later literary account of the Eretrian community, framed through dreams, Damis and reported local testimony. The 780 captured, about 400 men and perhaps ten women figures retain their attribution and qualifiers; they are not accepted as a contemporary census or an exact journey death toll. The text also reports prior flight from Eretria. Do not convert the passage into a new legal-status, total-deportation or incoming-colonizer-flight classification.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-PERIOCHAE", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The selected page covers summaries 51–55. Section 53.1 reports Appius Claudius’s subjugation of the Salassians; its displayed bracketed 143 date is separate from the translated clause. This does not itself document Eporedia’s foundation, land parcels, expelled numbers or the whole 143/140–100 sequence. The frozen event cites a broader bundle and already distinguishes the chronology question. Other summaries’ population and battle numbers do not migrate into this event.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-EPITOME", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Livy is identified as the author of the underlying history, not silently credited as the maker of the Periochae. The explanatory page distinguishes maker/epitomator, reports differences in sequence and missing summaries, and calls Lendering’s translation rather free. Andrew Smith is thanked for suggested improvements, not named as co-translator. The maker and underlying Latin edition remain unverified. The page’s speculative explanation for summary shortening is not adopted.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-LANGUAGE", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "The displayed bodies are English translations. The site’s Greek labels for Appian/Philostratus and Latin label for Livy refer to the ancient source language. No Greek or Latin critical text was inspected in this pass.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-DATES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "Page creation years 2005, 1998 and 2009 and explicit modification dates in 2020 are website dates. Conybeare 1912 is a credited Loeb translation year. The Horace White printing/year is not supplied. Modern page dates, ancient narrative chronology, copyright range and access date remain separate.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-LOCATORS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "Three original URLs and seven occurrences remain distinct. The Periochae HTML contains span id 53.1 immediately beside the Salassian clause; a more specific label/fragment is offered, not required. No browser jump or highlight behavior was tested. Appian’s displayed 1.c is the passage referred to conventionally as 1c in the note.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-SITE", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "About describes Livius as written/maintained by Jona Lendering since 1996 and not for profit, with reuse conditions and exceptions. FAQ solicits financial support. These are the site’s statements; no independent funding audit, donor list, complete rights review or competing-interest determination was performed. No blanket no-funding claim is made.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livius_20260910", "id": "LIVIUS-ACCESS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2 ], "note": "Ten HTML requests are terminal; thirty private source/derived files are bound. Reading is limited as stated per record. About, FAQ, Appian Histories text, Philostratus introduction, Livy stub and Periochae explanatory text were read in full. The substantive Livy biography was only searched/read around the lead. Images, graphs, visual table colors, physical books, complete ancient works, external archives and remote backup remain uninspected or incomplete.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded textual observation and stated reading limit; no new historical or publication disposition." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-ALSTOLA-EDITION", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The 2020 book revises the 2017 dissertation, explicitly acknowledged at physical 10/printed ix. They remain separate access/edition records, not independent witnesses by duplication. The book citation/copyright year is 2020; Helsinki labels online metadata 2019/12/17, and a publisher-indexed chapter sidebar says print release 9 December 2019. These dates are not forced into one exact publication day. Albion M. Butters revised English; no translator credit is inferred.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-THEIN-DATES-PAGES", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The original volume copyright and publisher citation use 2011. A prior deposited DOI record supplies 2010/01/13 and Thein’s 2026 post calls his catalogue 2010. Preserve these distinct observations without overwriting the deposited record. Publisher chapter citation is 79–100; actual text/bibliography ends at printed 99, physical 107; physical 108 is blank. Printed 87–89 are physical 95–97 in this LOC file, and printed 85–88 are physical 93–96.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-CAMODECA-SCOPE", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The linked 2017 chapter discusses Nola at printed/physical 198–200. Page 199 dates CIL X 1273 to the Augustan period and interprets the Sextilii/Aufidia connection as integration. Page 200 dates different inscription CIL X 181* to 80/50 BCE. Neither observation supplies the registry label’s c.80–70 BCE dating of CIL X 1236. Page 199 n.6 mentions CIL X 1236, without that range. Do not substitute 80–50 for 80–70 in the case.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-NOLA-CORRECTION", "records": [ 1, 2 ], "note": "Thein’s original May 3, 2026 post expressly dates CIL X 1236 to the 70s and cites Camodeca, Oebalus 6 (2011), 105–117, at 111. That is a distinct article, also listed in the 2017 chapter bibliography at page 210. The accessible text was read; embedded inscription/note images were not inspected. The exact 80–70 range in the current atlas remains a targeted source-location question, not a newly accepted false-date verdict or completed historical review.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-VOLATERRAE", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Thein’s inspected printed 85–89 discusses incomplete confiscated-land distribution and allows or infers individual veteran allotments at Volaterrae. Existing notes distinguish no completed distribution demonstrated from no veteran ever receiving land. Whole-Italy troop totals and broad grid attribution do not provide local recipient counts, parcels or routes.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-MIGRATION-CHAPTER", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "Stouraitis, chapter 5, printed 141–165/physical 156–180, DOI 10.1163/9789004425613_006, is distinct from the edited book DOI. Printed 154–155/physical 169–170 locates Nikephoros I’s compulsory Asia Minor–Greece transfer, distinguishing 806/7 from the larger 809 movement, forced property sale and inferred military/demographic aims. No exact headcount or uniform displacement of destination residents is supplied. Its Haldon dependence remains explicit; source repetition is not independent corroboration.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-CREDITS-SERIES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Chapter authors, volume editors, series editors, language reviser and publisher remain distinct. The original book prints Johannes Preiser-Kapeller; the Edinburgh page’s Preise-Kapeller spelling and generic citation_author fields do not override printed name/editor credit. The two Migration series are separately numbered 39 and 13 despite mixed institutional display labels. Camodeca text/bibliography ends 211; 212 is blank, while external indexed references include that blank endpoint. Printed-content range is labelled as such, not an assertion that 197–212 is wrong.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Alstola acknowledges ERC, Academy of Finland project funding and OpenAIRE support; the Migration volume declares FWF project Z288 under Claudia Rapp financed open access. These are the sources’ disclosures, not independently verified accounts. Read title/copyright/acknowledgments and selected introductions/chapter pages only; no exhaustive conflict-of-interest or neutrality finding. Series boards and conference invitations are not inferred funding declarations.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-IDENTIFIERS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Two whole-book DOIs are explicit in institutional metadata, Thein’s chapter DOI in publisher-indexed citation, and Stouraitis’s separate chapter DOI on its first page. No DOI is inferred by stripping chapter suffixes or substituting ISBNs. Camodeca’s chapter DOI assignment remains unverified. Seven printed ISBN strings and two ISSN strings retain their indicated roles; Camodeca’s garbled digits/year/series number are read from the page image.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-ACCESS-LIMITS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Four original LOC PDFs returned HTTP200 and parsed. Three context HTML pages returned HTTP200; the publisher returned empty HTTP202, so its web-indexed citation is the usable publisher observation. Two DOI web opens and the publisher page web open returned internal errors. Listed images and pages were read; complete books/chapters, underlying inscriptions, exhaustive disclosures, public archival capture, and remote backup are not claimed. Britannica remains separately policy-blocked; no workaround was attempted.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Preserve this source-role or reading limit; no new historical admission, score or flight assignment." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-MAASAI", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The February 2023 advocacy article discusses historical conservation displacement, subsequent evictions, restrictions and service withdrawal. It does not itself state the frozen event’s exact 1951/1959 chronology or cover later developments through 2026. Photo credit R. Bociaga/Shutterstock and 10 March 2022 describe the photograph, not the writer or article date. Linked reporting and court materials were not newly read; reported totals and interpretations are not independently recertified.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-FIJI", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The September 2017 community profile describes indentured migration, later emigration under coup-related pressure, violence and non-renewal of farm leases. Indentured ancestors and later departing descendants are different cohorts. It does not convert all later migration into formal expulsion or establish that departing people colonized a destination. Its historical dropped proposal stays dropped; no fresh admission or current demographic total is inferred.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-BALUCHIS", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The exact title is Baluchis in Afghanistan. Its historical section explicitly discusses the community across Pakistan, Iran and Afghanistan and reported guerrilla sanctuary in southern Afghanistan in the 1970s. This supplies cross-border background within a four-source event bundle, not direct proof of every displacement, disappearance or civilian killing in the 1948–2026 event. The wider recorded label is descriptive, not evidence that the URL identifies a Pakistan-only report. No wrong-source verdict or case reclassification is warranted from the title alone.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-MONGOLS", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "The November 2017 profile discusses Han migration and government policies in China’s Inner Mongolia, herder displacement and language restrictions. It preserves qualifiers around historical population figures and competing death estimates. It does not supply an exact 1902 onset or update the atlas through 2026 by itself; Wang and Bulag were not newly read. Narrative, coordinates and period boundaries stay unchanged.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-SAHARAWIS-ACCESS", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "The selected community URL returns HTTP 404 and visibly displays Page not found. The web index still returns the older Saharawis in Western Sahara profile. A separately titled Western Sahara country page is live and explicitly updated November 2025. Preserve the original identity and older text; do not relabel the country profile as an unchanged mirror or transplant its date to the original.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-SAHARAWIS-PASSAGE", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "Both the cached original and live country profile discuss Sahrawi flight and Moroccan settlement; the country page retains the historical 120,000-name registration list. It also carries different, qualified refugee estimates. Replacing a broken source link does not authorize silently changing the atlas’s 90,000 planning figure, 350,000 Green March figure, time coverage or legal description. Those numbers have different roles and need separately dated/source-specific review; other case references were not reread.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-DATE-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "Visible dates are 23 February 2023 for the Maasai article, September 2017 for Indo-Fijians and November 2017 for Mongols. Baluchis and the cached original Saharawis have no verified profile update date. Later OpenGraph modified timestamps and the common 2023 footer are platform/footer signals, not proof of a content update. November 2025 belongs only to the separate Western Sahara country page; access is September 2026.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-WRITER-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "Minority Rights Group is recorded as the issuing organization and website. No individually named writer is verified for the five selected pages. Photograph subjects/photographers, linked report authors and site developers are not imported as article/profile writers. The institution’s advocacy character is retained without inventing an individual byline or peer-review status.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-FUNDING", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "The original pages solicit donations and identify the organization and charity registration. The funders/annual-reports page was read, including its institutional supporter list and report links. This is an organization-level disclosure, not a report-specific funding assignment or independent audit. No competing-interest statement was seen in this bounded set; absence of funding or conflicts is not asserted. Linked accounts, donor sites and financial statements were not opened.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-ACCESS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "Five direct requests are terminal: four 403s and one 404. Seven browser pages were inspected: four originals, the original Saharawis error, a separate country profile and the funders page. DOM text/metadata and three exact web-tool transcripts are private evidence; browser content export was unsupported, and no original response HTML is claimed. Cached original content is distinct from live access. No public archive or remote backup is verified.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_minority_rights_20260910", "id": "MRG-FLIGHT", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "Accounts of Maasai flight, Indo-Fijian departure, Sahrawi exile, guerrilla sanctuary or Moroccan expulsions from Algeria do not by themselves identify incoming settlers who fled a source region. Origin pressure, destination settlement and the same cohort must be linked before adding the user’s flight-origin flag. None of these metadata records supplies that completed link, so no new flag or modern refugee legal status is assigned.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain source-specific scope, date and cohort limits. No new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mozarabic_chronicle_20260910", "id": "MC-ROLES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The chronicle is anonymous; Al-Tamimi is the named modern translator and analyst. The page describes a Latin work dating to 754 CE. Its byline does not name the eighth-century author. The Fordham index is a separate identification aid, not another witness.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct source/translation/version roles and existing event exclusions; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mozarabic_chronicle_20260910", "id": "MC-VERSIONS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The online article is dated 22 September 2019. Its 7 December 2020 notice concerns bracketed CE-year conversions; its 28 June 2024 notice reports a full translation revision for readability. These are distinct publication/update roles, not dates of the medieval work or independently verified critical editions.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct source/translation/version roles and existing event exclusions; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mozarabic_chronicle_20260910", "id": "MC-EDITION", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The page introduction does not identify a specific underlying Latin edition. The saved successor source register explicitly states that Gil was not consulted and retains §§45–51 only as a mediated bridge. This review does not promote that bridge to a verified edition citation.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct source/translation/version roles and existing event exclusions; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mozarabic_chronicle_20260910", "id": "MC-BOUNDARY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The captured Muze/Taric/Rudericus through Abdellazis-death notices match the current event’s named source locator. The later Alaor and Zama fiscal/distribution passages are present but remain outside the 711–c.716 operation under the existing event/register boundary. No later machinery is backdated.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct source/translation/version roles and existing event exclusions; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mozarabic_chronicle_20260910", "id": "MC-PERSPECTIVE", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The introduction explicitly discusses an Iberian Christian perspective, divine explanation and rhetorical descriptions of devastation. These are attributed source/translator observations, not a measured population survey or an adopted neutral description of all communities. The translator is an intermediary, not independent historical corroboration.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct source/translation/version roles and existing event exclusions; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mozarabic_chronicle_20260910", "id": "MC-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The page carries Al-Tamimi’s byline and his personal-site identity. No institutional publisher, neutrality, peer-review status or comprehensive funding/conflict finding is inferred. Reading covered stated introduction, selected conquest/later-boundary notices and notes, not the entire chronicle or its Latin edition.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep distinct source/translation/version roles and existing event exclusions; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-IDENTITY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The PDF, landing and embedded title all print Livehood; the recorded inventory says Livelihood. Preserve the old recorded label and stable ID, but use the actual printed title in typed metadata and the fuller citation. This Deusto article is separate from Mukasa’s differently titled work cited in the PLOS reference list.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-DATES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The printed issue and embedded citation_date are 2012; issue number is 10 and pages are 71–84. The landing explicitly gives online publication on 11 December 2017 and uses 2017 in its suggested citation. PDF creation/modification in June/July 2016 and embedded submitted/modified dates are technical/platform observations, not proof of the original issue’s publication day or a historical revision.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-JOURNAL", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The 2012 PDF prints Anuario de Acción Humanitaria y Derechos Humanos / Yearbook on Humanitarian Action and Human Rights and ISSN 1885-298X. Publisher history describes that title’s 2004–2015 stage and the Deusto Journal title from 2016. Current-host eISSN 2603-6002 is separately labelled; neither it nor the later journal name is backdated as the original 2012 imprint.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-METHOD", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The abstract and pp.72–73 describe a three-stage literature review drawing on published/unpublished work, reports, legal documents and other sources. It is not a newly conducted interview study or a primary household census. Its cited official instruments and empirical studies were not independently reopened here.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-LOCATORS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Figure 1 is on printed p.73 (PDF page 3) and places the parks and Echuya reserve in geographic context. Section 1.5 begins on p.77, and Table 1 is on p.78 (PDF page 8). Table 1 reports an earlier May 1991 Mgahinga resolution and a 13 August 1991 Bwindi resolution. These are source-reported gazettement dates, not verified uniform eviction days for every household.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-CHRONOLOGY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The 1991 row of Table 1 reports eviction and restriction without resettlement or compensation. The surrounding pp.78–79 separately discuss later trust funding and selective compensation; the article says the fund began operating in 1995. The event-time absence is not expanded into a claim that no later assistance or compensation existed for anyone. The underlying resolutions, compensation ledgers and uniform household chronology remain uninspected.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-ECHUYA", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "A location map showing Echuya near the parks does not make it part of the same legal or administrative eviction event. Preserve the accepted Bwindi–Mgahinga unit and separate Echuya boundary. The latter’s detailed institutional chronology still depends on the separately cited government plan and prior source review; that plan was not newly retrieved in this pass.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The article identifies Mukasa as a Deusto PhD candidate and thanks Felipe Gómez and Leslie Lieberman for guidance and encouragement; these are historical source statements, not a claim about his current employment. The journal’s current page names an institute sponsor and Basque/University supporters, which are not automatically assigned as this 2012 article’s funders. The World Bank/GEF fund discussed on pp.78–79 concerns the conservation project, not publication funding. No exhaustive article funding/conflict or peer-review audit is claimed.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_mukasa_deusto_20260910", "id": "MD-FLIGHT", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The review concerns Batwa removal, forest exclusion and aftermath. It does not establish flight/refugee origins for the conservation authorities or justify an incoming-flight flag. No event admission, family, score, map or flight classification changes.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Retain exact title/imprint, distinct date roles, precise locators and event-time/source limits. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-IDENTITY-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Four access identities each describe one actual document. The UNHCR story has two named writers; the reports have OCHA institutional authorship. The PDFs’ contact officers, photo credits and map credits do not establish personal authorship.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "1a25019d035b928df37391c73881d295adda1df1c6d6d6488082bf59fc65dff7", "1ca384347a4f75ddfac8bcc98b54fb8f7197ef72452102b55f4d0c8f10cedf93", "7d4bcd4633b1502c7614aeac236df4b8e02d798b787239040d656d5ec968a30c", "7f7dcc900d083f2ae158eb750fadea883ab0b6c7243d3cd969596b17edec983b" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-DATES", "records": [ 1, 2, 3 ], "note": "Flash Update 3 is dated as of 9 November 2023 but the host posts it on 10 November. Updates 42 and 45 have their own dates/cutoffs. These are separate from the frozen events’ onset conventions.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "1a25019d035b928df37391c73881d295adda1df1c6d6d6488082bf59fc65dff7", "1ca384347a4f75ddfac8bcc98b54fb8f7197ef72452102b55f4d0c8f10cedf93", "7d4bcd4633b1502c7614aeac236df4b8e02d798b787239040d656d5ec968a30c", "8b7010b861439ac7a79b5504afd1dda2f4d5d69767fe97e78267575bc704a58d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-METHOD", "records": [ 1, 3 ], "note": "Updates 42 and 45 identify OCHA production in collaboration with coordinating groups and agencies, with response figures self-reported by organizations. Their independence wording is the documents’ description; it does not establish independently audited response counts.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "1a25019d035b928df37391c73881d295adda1df1c6d6d6488082bf59fc65dff7", "7d4bcd4633b1502c7614aeac236df4b8e02d798b787239040d656d5ec968a30c" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-FLASH-LIMIT", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Flash Update 3 uses initial partner inputs and warns that figures fluctuate. China-border crossings are attributed to media and not exactly verified by partners. The map labels verification as ongoing and disclaims boundary endorsement; no atlas geometry is copied.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "1ca384347a4f75ddfac8bcc98b54fb8f7197ef72452102b55f4d0c8f10cedf93", "d123e5588f2554062aba3c752e88fbcfc2b6dcd362282ea42ce81d3cc8ba36f6" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-KAYAH", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The story places renewed Kayah conflict in May 2021 and reports repeated movement from Demoso and Loikaw into Shan. Names are changed for protection. Update 45 continues Kayah/Kayin/southern-Shan reporting; this does not turn a Kayah-origin movement into a northern-Shan event.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "7d4bcd4633b1502c7614aeac236df4b8e02d798b787239040d656d5ec968a30c", "7f7dcc900d083f2ae158eb750fadea883ab0b6c7243d3cd969596b17edec983b" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-RAKHINE", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "The exact saved locus is Update 42 page 3. It reports resumed conflict on 13 November 2023 and distinguishes an estimated newly displaced cohort from total Rakhine IDPs. The bundled source title naming Update 45 and Flash Update 5 is not the identity of this PDF.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "1a25019d035b928df37391c73881d295adda1df1c6d6d6488082bf59fc65dff7" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-SHAN", "records": [ 2, 1 ], "note": "Flash Update 3 names the Three Brotherhood Alliance and reports the 26 October 2023 attacks, local displacement and blocked routes. Update 45 reports continued northern-Shan volatility. Shared AA participation does not establish one combined Rakhine/Shan event.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "1ca384347a4f75ddfac8bcc98b54fb8f7197ef72452102b55f4d0c8f10cedf93", "7d4bcd4633b1502c7614aeac236df4b8e02d798b787239040d656d5ec968a30c" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_myanmar_un_20260911", "id": "MM-COUNT-SCOPES", "records": [ 1, 3 ], "note": "The reports separately present people displaced, people in need, targets, assistance reach and funding. Update 42 page 3 achievements have a 30 September cutoff; its first-page headline is later. Neither is a unique historical removal census, and unlike dated estimates are not silently reconciled.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "1a25019d035b928df37391c73881d295adda1df1c6d6d6488082bf59fc65dff7", "7d4bcd4633b1502c7614aeac236df4b8e02d798b787239040d656d5ec968a30c" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-UKRAINE-IDENTITY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The report was published on 20 March 2026 and covers 24 February 2022–31 December 2025. The saved 2022–2025 label is a coverage range, not a demonstrated wrong publication year. The linked original has 30 PDF pages. Use the full report title rather than the landing heading’s accidental appended day/month.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "ed8a6dd00252bdbd2b906599eebe1d33254bef821e485b1000eba617ec633aaf", "f29d00ab7d9d6fe25c42ed43a60c1a8e61c75f12dc36f8dcc21c66f7bce32d9c" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-UKRAINE-METHODS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The report distinguishes coercively induced displacement from direct flight from fighting. Its methods report 4,255 interviewees across monitoring work; this is not a deportation census. Interviews in government-controlled territory, remote sources and official records support OHCHR’s reasonable-grounds-to-believe assessments. The report states Russia had not granted access to occupied territory. Legal assessments remain attributed to OHCHR.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "630a0bd65a3001522452e68b088afa9e91b97895d17fe2139e1dbcc480799b63", "f29d00ab7d9d6fe25c42ed43a60c1a8e61c75f12dc36f8dcc21c66f7bce32d9c" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-UKRAINE-COUNTS-OUTCOMES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The report’s notices of potentially abandoned properties and properties registered as abandoned are separate categories, not counts of people or identical completed confiscations. Recommendations for return, restitution and rights protection do not establish that those outcomes occurred. The report’s coverage ends in 2025; it does not alone verify all later 2026 developments in the frozen event.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "630a0bd65a3001522452e68b088afa9e91b97895d17fe2139e1dbcc480799b63", "f29d00ab7d9d6fe25c42ed43a60c1a8e61c75f12dc36f8dcc21c66f7bce32d9c" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-IRAN-SCOPE", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "UA IRN 6/2021 is a six-signatory urgent appeal of 22 February 2021, covering Ahwazi Arab, Baluch and Gonabadi Sufi concerns. The Baluch section reports at least 25 executions from 19 December 2020 to 10 February 2021; allegations and the appeal do not constitute an adjudicated finding or a Pakistan-wide displacement estimate. No subsequent response or case outcome was retrieved. Its cross-border atlas use remains a bounded Iran source alongside other references.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "49cec4a63602f348d7d13b96b4026b3c2e2febb29672c0e774356fcb34a19b98" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-MAYOTTE-ROLE", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The linked document is France’s concluding observations E/C.12/FRA/CO/5, distributed 30 October 2023 after adoption on 13 October. The delivered English version says Original: French. Paragraph 44 expresses concern about demolitions and resulting evictions in Mayotte; paragraph 45 recommends adequate accommodation and protection of vulnerable people. Recommendations do not establish delivered housing or a court judgment. Use paragraph locators; the delivered body is HTML, so no PDF pagination is invented.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "ba3333c18c30400af99a4ac2ff993843cd4a9395b29b2ab4a60c32768adede4f" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-CRIMEA-IDENTITY", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "The selected URL is a 28 February 2024 HRMMU press release. Its linked 14-page OHCHR report is a related document, not a silently substituted access identity. Danielle Bell is a quoted official and Kris Janowski a media contact, not named byline authors. Report legal assessments retain their institutional attribution.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "09665063d0c8427191fd0703fe6a024e02cf1dd9e2a65476a913271b5bbbfdd6", "2e7563ba8f46dd74be5679c885d2388f537624a0c81c5b16e040a337fe38ec34" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-CRIMEA-COUNTS-METHODS", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "Report paragraph 6 gives at least 864 deportation orders in 2017–2024. Paragraphs 21–22 distinguish over 50,000 registered Crimean IDPs (footnote 33: information of 31 January 2022) from over 100,000 Russian citizens officially relocated in 2014–2017. Footnote 36 distinguishes state-organized or encouraged transfers from voluntary civilian movement. Enforced disappearances are another category. Annex I describes remote monitoring without practical Crimea access since March 2014 and a reasonable-grounds-to-believe standard. Earlier underlying reports and court registries were not newly examined. These observations do not independently verify all later 2026 events.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "10c6e0d87e75e7510e628174910bdfe79f5d6d60508c8356d8218d84adf01403" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-NEGEV-SCOPE", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "AL ISR 23/2024 is an eight-signatory allegation letter dated 17 December 2024. Its pages 2–3 describe historical concentration/nonrecognition and reported November 2024 Umm al-Hiran demolitions under threat of fines; persons, houses and regional totals remain distinct. Its conditional assessment does not turn reported allegations or requested remedies into a judgment or implemented restitution. No later government response was retrieved. The eight actual signatories do not include WGAD even though the letter contains a WGAD procedural paragraph.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "55ea03aba5eb9b5bd18fa65657c5b1a840c15c2227198b619bcb4a5af174170b" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_ohchr_20260911", "id": "OH-TIBET-SCOPE", "records": [ 5 ], "note": "AL CHN 6/2022 is a four-signatory allegation letter of 11 November 2022; Wang Yi is the addressee, not the author. Reported residential-school numbers and percentages have different populations and time references: almost one million Tibetan children, 78 percent of ages 6–18 in Tibetan areas, 81 percent in TAR as of 2019, and a 22 percent national comparison. They are not an interterritorial deportation census. No later response or independent historical acceptance was retrieved. The existing Tibet model-input record remains inactive.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "9a49163760dac1ae637ec8217927fd729d598c7a4d73b40235012b76fd2994f7" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-DOI-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The HTML citation_doi fields identify parent books; generated chapter citations identify separate chapter DOIs. All seven chapter DOI destinations matched the chapter title and generated citation. Publisher metadata and citations are not independent scholarly corroboration.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-DATE-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Printed publication years, metadata /01 values and later platform online dates remain distinct. The PDF generation date in December 2025 is neither a new edition nor an updated historical result.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-PAGE-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Printed chapter page ranges remain distinct from file page counts. Jacotot chapter 5 is printed pp. 241–298; its generated PDF has 59 pages including its cover.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-NOLA-NAME", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Mathieu Jacotot is the grounded name. The current source label says Thierry, while the existing source note already says Mathieu. One given-name correction is required and unapplied.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-NOLA-LOCATOR", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Chapter 5 paragraph 20 reproduces CIL X 1236 = ILLRP I 116 and names Nola; chapter 8 note 95 cites it. A direct chapter 5 link is offered. The consulted reproduction does not itself name Sulla, veterans, confiscation or prior landholders. CIL I² 3127 and the dating reported elsewhere remain at prior verification status; no new alias/date validation is claimed.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-MINTURNAE-LANGUAGE", "records": [ 3 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The chapter heading and consulted historical paragraphs are Italian, while HTML language metadata says fr and the requested UI is English. These roles stay explicit; container language and translation are not guessed.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-SEGARD-PUBLISHERS", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Chapter metadata names Publications du Centre Camille Jullian; the generated book citation also names Éditions Errance. Preserve separate chapter and container publisher roles.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-HERMON-REDIRECT", "records": [ 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The recorded /pur/199839 URL redirects to /pur/6724, the Ella Hermon chapter. Retain the original work ID/access URL and the observed destination. Paragraph 10 questions literal colonist totals and discusses indigenous continuity and administrative integration; this is not new proof of mass elimination or an exact migrant count.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-FUNDING", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Jacotot’s funding page describes library-supported open access through OpenEdition Books Select, Knowledge Unlatched and Couperin; this concerns access, not an inferred complete research-funding history. His foreword identifies a 2009 thesis. Segard’s acknowledgments identify a revised 2005 thesis and support including a regional archaeology service linked to his thesis bursary. Ahrweiler’s foreword is a tribute to Kaplan, not independent validation of Haldon’s chapter.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-PRIOR-HISTORY", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "All existing source-note and case qualifications stay in force. Selected passages were read for locator/context checks; no complete historical chapter was newly read. No authoring admission, family assignment, map geometry, statistics or historical confidence score is changed.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_openedition_20260910", "id": "OE-ACCESS-RIGHTS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Sources are readable online; metadata lists the OpenEdition Books licence. EFR legal text places copyright rules at book/chapter level. Some records offer freemium PDF/ePub access. Readability is not a blanket reuse licence; the linked user terms were not fully audited. Dated evidence remains private and locally hash-bound; remote backup and external archive captures remain pending.", "disposition": "Retain the explicit role/reading limit; no new historical acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-PUBLISHER-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 5, 6, 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Oxford Academic is the platform. Eldridge’s book is published by Manchester University Press; the Zanzibar article is published by OUP on behalf of the Royal African Society. Platform hosting does not establish independent scholarly corroboration.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-OCD-EDITOR", "records": [ 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Lucy Grig is shown as the current editor-in-chief of the In Progress Oxford Classical Dictionary. She is not asserted as author or historical editor of these four entries published on 7 March 2016. No numbered print edition, translator or print pagination is inferred.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-TURKEY-DATES", "records": [ 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The chapter displays publication on 21 March 2024, chapter number 19 and pp. 324–342. The containing book displays a publication range of 23 January 2024–21 August 2025 and print availability on 1 August 2026; the chapter copyright line is 2026. These are separate roles. DOI suffix .16 is not a chapter-number correction.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-ZANZIBAR-DATES", "records": [ 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "African Affairs identifies volume 124, issue 496, July 2025, pp. 235–260 and separate publication on 15 September 2025. Crossref identifies July 1 as print metadata and September 15 as online metadata. The platform footer’s 2026 date is not the article publication date.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-SOURCE-NOTE-LIMITS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The existing Samnite, proscription, Astakos, Circeii and restoration source notes remain controlling for historical qualifications. Metadata and visible extracts do not establish precise event dates, censuses, deaths, routes, parcels or motives. Samnium’s broader regional analysis is not another independent witness to a particular event.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-INACTIVE-SCOPE", "records": [ 5, 6, 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The three current-registry citation IDs have no current atlas cases. Algeria and Turkey occur in inactive model input records; Zanzibar also occurs in the active release. Metadata verification does not activate an event, assign a current case or alter any hold.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-ZANZIBAR-LIMITS", "records": [ 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The authors explicitly describe their Gazette confiscation dataset as incomplete: some properties were taken without orders, and gaps suggest not all orders appeared in the Gazette. Property counts are not people, household or refugee counts. Footnote 98 lacks the overall female-owner denominator needed for comparative victimization likelihood. No underlying Gazette documents, linked references or dataset were independently inspected here.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-SAMNIUM-SUPPORT", "records": [ 0 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The visible acknowledgments extract identifies an Exeter thesis and post-PhD work at the British School at Rome, naming support from the Overseas Research Student Award Scheme, Universities UK, Exeter Graduate School, British School at Rome and British Academy. This is an attributed partial disclosure, not proof of a complete funding history or independence.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-ELDRIDGE-SUPPORT", "records": [ 5 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The visible acknowledgments extract thanks academic supervisors and colleagues at St Andrews, Keele, Southampton and Portsmouth and mentions Leeds. No explicit grant appears in that extract; full acknowledgments were inaccessible. Do not equate limited disclosure access with absence of funding.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-ZANZIBAR-SUPPORT-RIGHTS", "records": [ 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Author notes disclose partial support from the SSHRC Canada Partner Grant Appraising Risk, Past and Present. Participant names are anonymized according to footnote 5. The article displays CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. The full grant title is preserved in private evidence. Readability and funding disclosure do not establish unrestricted reuse or absence of competing interests.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_oup_academic_20260910", "id": "OUP-ACCESS-ARCHIVE", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Eight direct original requests returned 403. Ordinary-browser pages and all eight DOI destination identity zones were readable; five registry responses matched and three were rate-limited. No bypass or identical failed retry was used. Browser evidence consists of dated structured transcriptions, not raw HTML/full-page archives. Full books, reference entries and the Turkey chapter were not read. Disclosure coverage, external archive capture and remote backup remain incomplete.", "disposition": "Retain the stated source role and reading limit; no historical admission or public application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-GRANIUS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The opening locus 26.1.1 labels the beginning of a page containing surviving Books 26, 28, 33, 35 and 36. Complete Book 36 was read. Sections 8–10 distinguish Volaterrae surrender/proscribed men, the earlier Nolan action and Mutilus’s flight; sections 36–38 include reddiderunt. The existing Faesulae note explicitly discusses the recovery emendation. Preserve the distinction between surviving Latin, supplied letters, translation choices and the fates of bounded groups.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-VELLEIUS", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The whole displayed 1.14 chapter was read. Ariminum and Beneventum occur in section 7; the URL’s opening label 1.14.1.1 does not mean only section 1 was retrieved. Retain the surrounding chronology as the ancient account, without recomputing dates, citizenship scope or a settler population from this metadata pass.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-COPIA", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "Livy 35.9.7–8 names castrum Frentinum and distinguishes potential allotments of 30/60 iugera from actual 20/40 allotments after reserving a third of the land. The stated 3,000 infantry and 300 cavalry are incoming groups, not a resident population total. The Barrington directory introduction explicitly associates Copia with Livy 35.9, while its unlocated-toponym entry says the place is in Thurii’s territory and perhaps Copia. The current Copia label is not shown to be a wrong-work citation; retain the location qualification without moving a coordinate or recertifying the event.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-BUXENTUM", "records": [ 3 ], "note": "Livy 39.23.3–4 reports deserted colonies at Sipontum and Buxentum and the appointment of commissioners to recruit colonists. It does not by itself prove every previous resident’s fate or successful completion of a renewed settlement. Active, inactive and registry scopes remain distinct.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-POTENTIA", "records": [ 4 ], "note": "Livy 39.44.10 pairs Potentia in Picenum with Pisaurum in Gallic territory, names the commissioners and gives six iugera per individual. Retain the two-place and allocation scope; do not turn this into a settler count, exact cadastral geometry or total confiscated area.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-EDITIONS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "PHI Canon credits Criniti 1981 for Granius; Hellegouarc’h, volumes 1–2, 1982 for Velleius; McDonald, volume 5, 1969 for Livy Books 31–35; and Weissenborn/Mueller, part 3, n.d. for Books 36–40. Two year fields remain null for the undated book range. No printed publisher, manuscript witness or exact physical copy is inferred. The related Attalus edition-year amendment is explicit and separately reviewed.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-LOCATORS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "All five original URLs, including their exact percent encoding and offset strings, are retained. Observed titles and Latin bodies identify the returned work/chapter. Client-side highlight behavior and offset semantics were not tested; numeric URL tokens are not substituted for a displayed bibliographic locus. Whole-work Granius and chapter-level Livy/Velleius routes are distinct.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-PAGINATION", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The Volaterrae note calls the Attalus page marker 32 a Criniti page. The captured Attalus introduction assigns red page numbers to Flemisch and green sentence numbers to Criniti. The exact printed Criniti page 32 has not been inspected. Offer a web-locator clarification using Book 36.8–10 and Attalus red page 32 (Flemisch pagination), without asserting that a physical Criniti page reference has been disproved.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-CONTEXT-PDF", "records": [ 2 ], "note": "The 14-page publisher-hosted Map 46 Bruttii directory credits I.E.M. Edlund-Berry and A.M. Small, compiled 1997. Physical pages 1, 8 and 9 were inspected as images, including the introduction, Unlocated Toponyms heading and Frentinum row (printed p. 703). The compilation year is not assigned as PDF publication year. Other directory pages, its underlying reference works and the separate map image were not inspected.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_phi_latin_20260910", "id": "PHI-ACCESS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4 ], "note": "Eleven direct requests are terminal: ten HTML and one PDF. Thirty-five private source/derived files are hash-bound. Three author pages, About and relevant Canon entries were read; the full Canon and all Granius books were not. About attributes the corpus to earlier PHI CD ROM 5.3, a platform statement rather than independent corpus verification. No funding/COI statement was observed in the inspected material; broader disclosures, external archives and remote backup remain incomplete.", "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source observation and reading limits without new historical or publication acceptance." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-ACCESS", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Both selected URLs return the same article text despite different slash encodings. Retain both stable IDs, recorded labels and five occurrences; the two routes are not independent studies.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-BUNDLE", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "One active-release source label names the PLOS article, a separate Norman Mukasa work and a Ugandan MWE/NFA Echuya plan but links only PLOS. Typed metadata here applies only to the linked article. Saved source-review locators identify separate Deusto and ministry URLs; those works are not newly opened or certified in this pass. Preserve the combined historical label and offer a fuller PLOS-only citation for later display.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-VERSION", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Original article publication is 16 August 2023, volume 3 issue 8, e0002129. The separate staff correction was published 14 September 2023, volume 3 issue 9, e0002413, and reports republication on 21 August solely to correct title capitalization. Keep the corrected title and all three date roles. The paired original/corrected PDFs linked by the notice were not downloaded or compared; the scope is the publisher’s statement, not a byte-level version audit.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-METHOD", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "This Batwa-led qualitative study reports purposively recruited adult participants, interviews in Rukiga during August–November 2022, English translation and thematic analysis. Results describe 19 interviews: nine male and ten female participants, aged 21–107. These are study-sample counts, not the population evicted in 1991. The Limitations section explicitly restricts representativeness and transferability beyond the sampled district/community context.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-CATEGORIES", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Recruitment and analysis lists repeat a born-after phrase while parenthetically describing young people present at eviction. The Results section clearly distinguishes eleven participants who lived in the Forest as adults, five as young people and three born after eviction. Preserve this textual discrepancy; do not silently rewrite source wording or treat all 19 as adult eyewitnesses in 1991.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-DISCLOSURES", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The article gives author affiliations and a positionality statement, identifies Wellcome Trust grant 220767/Z/20/Z to Samrawit Gougsa, states the funder had no role, and declares no competing interests. It states ethics approvals and restricts data access pending additional Indigenous ethics agreements. These are author/publisher disclosures, not independently audited funding, ethics, neutrality or dataset validation; no data request was sent.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-HISTORY", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The abstract places forced eviction with national-park establishment in 1991; Results attribute memories or stories of armed removal and ongoing exclusion to interviewees. This supplies a bounded source-use check, not a new complete event, legal, clinical or causal audit. Narrated illness, mortality and loss are not converted into measured population rates. Wishes for Landback and return are not evidence of a completed return.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-GEOGRAPHY", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The accepted model event is the 1991 Bwindi–Mgahinga unit and explicitly excludes Echuya. Exact gazettement dates and the Echuya institutional distinction rely on the saved multi-source review, including the separate Mukasa and government-plan works. This PLOS metadata review does not independently re-prove those boundaries, reactivate the older umbrella or authorize atlas rendering.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_plos_batwa_20260910", "id": "PB-FLIGHT", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "The article concerns the Batwa as people displaced by conservation enforcement. Their displacement or later movement does not establish refugee/flight origins for the incoming state authorities or automatically assign the incoming-flight feature. No score, family, event boundary or flight classification changes.", "status": "scope_limit_retained", "disposition": "Keep source identity, version dates, attribution, sample limits and existing event boundaries. No historical re-adjudication or flight flag." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_pmc_remaining_20260911", "id": "NORBA-SOURCE-SCOPE", "note": "This is a ceramic production and trade article with archaeological landscape background. It discusses destruction in 82 BCE and a possible contribution of the Via Appia to abandonment; the road mechanism is a possibility. Republican villa/kiln evidence and the fourth–first-century ceramic range do not by themselves demonstrate permanent occupation after 82 BCE. Preserve the atlas distinction between the walled town and wider territory, with its separate Santangelo support for later activity near Norma.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "7d5a09379680616bec4bc379bb4b99c4957242e5c4dc8989364a67d3b7ca6cfa" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_pmc_remaining_20260911", "id": "NORBA-ARTICLE-IDENTITY", "note": "180 is an article number, not a page count. The source reports 32 selected rim-fragment samples, including 22 type-2 and 10 type-3a jars; the sample does not enumerate inhabitants or displaced households.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "5316862f6b1bdfcfaaa3cd54b19a5f964989d0ade6a7066e74d130b582240280", "7d5a09379680616bec4bc379bb4b99c4957242e5c4dc8989364a67d3b7ca6cfa" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_pmc_remaining_20260911", "id": "LIPSON-VERSION-AND-DATES", "note": "The inspected university-hosted typeset PDF is marked article in press and paginated 1–9, within a 10-page file including a cover. It prints 28 February 2018 as Published and 2 April 2018 in the issue footer. Crossref gives final pagination 1157–1165.e7 and 30 authors. A separate Oxford repository search preview has a different byline, including no Thomas K. Harper in its displayed full byline. The exact relationship of that manuscript and the selected PMC copy remains unverified; do not merge them as byte-identical versions.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "5ec0f2730ff404003aac602b46f7fe8cf24d6ec874b170dd97adf8683f424202", "aa29beaa52cd081847d48f1f6c758b22c3b9244d83c2b6bc0fe85687d40480c8", "ad3a50ce2f4656ce857880af25709b3d9fdb3d64ad5b6d12cd7b306ae2a0904e" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_pmc_remaining_20260911", "id": "LIPSON-ANCESTRY-SCOPE", "note": "The genetic evidence concerns sampled ancestry, migration and mixture; it does not alone establish deliberate violence, a legal refugee category or a colonizer flight-origin flag. The paper distinguishes 14 ancient individuals from 185 present-day individuals. Its note on later Rabaul-related displacement concerns a distinct ancestry-source discussion and is not an automatic atlas assignment.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "aa29beaa52cd081847d48f1f6c758b22c3b9244d83c2b6bc0fe85687d40480c8" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_pmc_remaining_20260911", "id": "NARASIMHAN-VERSION", "note": "The exact indexed PMC record explicitly identifies an author manuscript available on 31 October 2019 and separately cites the final Science publication dated 6 September 2019, volume 365 issue 6457, eaat7487. The previously accepted DOI record remains unchanged, including its deposited 117-author list. The new display credit is shortened deliberately; no fresh full PMC-byline or supplement comparison is claimed.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "7ac395c23ed3f101ebc905d8a5edddffb122a3f26b6154b3f7f5e5a25d97015f", "ad3a50ce2f4656ce857880af25709b3d9fdb3d64ad5b6d12cd7b306ae2a0904e" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_pmc_remaining_20260911", "id": "NARASIMHAN-CAUSAL-SCOPE", "note": "The indexed article presents ancestry models and discusses directions of spread as plausible, with insufficient sampling for exact routes. Neither a genetic component nor an inferred language connection establishes coercion, ethnicity, individual motivation or a new historical admission. The original source registry entry remains unassigned.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "ad3a50ce2f4656ce857880af25709b3d9fdb3d64ad5b6d12cd7b306ae2a0904e" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_routledge_20260910", "id": "RT-EDITED-ROLES", "records": [ 2, 3 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The publisher bylines and ebook contributor roles identify two edited collections. Chapter titles or editors alone do not verify individual historical assertions. Nicholas B. Breyfogle appears in the Russian collection’s contents/copyright statement, while its editor byline omits B.", "disposition": "Retain this limitation with the reviewed metadata; it does not establish a defective original source label or a newly verified historical assertion." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_routledge_20260910", "id": "RT-DATE-ROLES", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "All seven books:release_date values are malformed five-digit years and are excluded. Browser print dates, ebook publication dates, ebook firstPublishedYear and copyright dates retain explicit roles. Handbook copyright 2017/ebook 2016, Borneo copyright 2011/ebook 2010, Taiwan copyright 2019/ebook 2018 and Ahmida copyright 2021/publication 2020 are not silently harmonized.", "disposition": "Retain this limitation with the reviewed metadata; it does not establish a defective original source label or a newly verified historical assertion." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_routledge_20260910", "id": "RT-GAT-FORMAT", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Original URL and selected browser record identify hardback ISBN 9780714646893, 220 pages, published May 1, 1997. HTML canonical/OG/books:isbn names paperback 9780714642239, with 224 pages in its own hidden format block. The original link is usable; no URL repair is indicated.", "disposition": "Retain this limitation with the reviewed metadata; it does not establish a defective original source label or a newly verified historical assertion." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_routledge_20260910", "id": "RT-FUNDING-LICENCE", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Ebook metadata contains null funding statements/names and a license type open-access with null description/location, alongside SELLABLE/distribution metadata. These fields do not establish no funding, unrestricted access or permission to reproduce.", "disposition": "Retain this limitation with the reviewed metadata; it does not establish a defective original source label or a newly verified historical assertion." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_routledge_20260910", "id": "RT-OOI-NAME", "records": [ 5 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Preserve the displayed full name Ooi Keat Gin. Publisher structured given/family fields and generated citation invert it as Keat Gin, O.; no inferred surname split or generated citation is adopted.", "disposition": "Retain this limitation with the reviewed metadata; it does not establish a defective original source label or a newly verified historical assertion." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_routledge_20260910", "id": "RT-GAT-CONTENTS", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The publisher Table of Contents area contains review quotations, including an apparent reference to Kaiser. No contents or author-identity claim is derived from that area.", "disposition": "Retain this limitation with the reviewed metadata; it does not establish a defective original source label or a newly verified historical assertion." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-BUNDLED-LABELS", "records": [ 0, 2, 3, 6, 7, 8 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "A single access record sometimes carries a label listing several sources. Metadata identifies only the retrieved document, without consolidating the bundle or claiming the other listed sources were read.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-DUPLICATE-ACCESS", "records": [ 1, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Pairs 1/5 and 4/7 have matching PDF/DOCX title, symbol and date identities; 8/9 use one inspected official PDF. Preserve all original access identities and occurrences. Duplicate access is not independent corroboration or full version equivalence.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-WORD-FORMAT", "records": [ 5, 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The two original URLs ending in t=pdf: returned DOCX bytes. The initial helper misnamed those bytes .html and produced unusable HTML-derived text. Original bytes/receipts are retained; byte-identical .docx copies and XML extractions supply the inspected evidence. Garbage publisher-05/07.txt and .meta.json files are excluded as content evidence.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-ACCESS-CONTROLS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Seven Digital Library originals returned 202 bot-check pages, excluded as evidence. Four originals returned PDFs and two returned DOCX. Six official alternate requests returned five PDFs and one 200 ODS error page; the UNISPAL follow-up supplied the remaining report identity. No CAPTCHA was bypassed or failed original request identically retried.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-UNRWA-DATE", "records": [ 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The cover identifies 1967 and the reporting period 1 July 1966–30 June 1967. The transmittal is dated 15 September 1967. The inspected UN-hosted dossier index, page 40, row 999, dates A/6713 to 15 September 1967; the reviewed issued_date uses that bibliographic report date. UNISPAL’s displayed 30 June 1967 date remains separately attributed. No physical printing day, full English PDF access or table-PDF inspection is claimed.", "disposition": "Prepared issue-date question resolved by additional main-round source evidence; the preparation record remains intact." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-UNRWA-ROLES", "records": [ 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Laurence Michelmore signs as Commissioner-General. The transmittal says Advisory Commission members and Israeli representatives were consulted; it explicitly does not imply represented governments subscribe to all views. Advisory Chairman Adrian T. Middleton is not substituted as report author. The letter describes financial and mandate constraints; no full funding or competing-interest audit is claimed.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-DRC-MAPPING", "records": [ 0 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The August 2010 English report identifies itself as an unofficial translation from French. Printed p. 34, paragraph 90 and footnote 69 identify OHCHR leadership, UNDP financial administration and ten voluntary funding partners. Printed p. 39 describes reasonable suspicion below criminal-conviction proof, excludes determining individual criminal responsibility, and says reports using one primary source are not separate corroboration. Metadata does not certify every incident.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-REPORT-DATE-ROLES", "records": [ 1, 3, 4, 5, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Issue/distribution dates, reporting periods, visit dates, session dates and processing codes are distinct. No new historical onset is inferred from a report date. Cover notes about translation/circulation and late submission do not create a new edition.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-RESOLUTION-PAGE", "records": [ 2 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The one-page official PDF reproduces printed page 6, containing all of resolution 497 and adjacent material including resolution 498. The resolution title/date, unanimous adoption and 2319th meeting were inspected visually; adjacent text is not part of resolution 497. No broader legal-status review is performed.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-ESCWA-ROLES", "records": [ 4, 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "A/79/975 and E/2025/82 identify one dual-symbol document. It is transmitted as a Secretary-General note and says ESCWA prepared the report with contributions from listed agencies. Contributor institutions are not treated as independent corroboration. Golan paras. 94–97 were inspected for locator scope; underlying demographic sources and all historical numbers were not independently verified.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-MARSHALL-2025", "records": [ 8, 9 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Paula Gaviria Betancur reports in her Special Rapporteur role on an October 2024 visit, issued June 2025. The report describes interviews and mission support, and cited paras. 6–12 distinguish Bikini, Enewetak/Enjebi and Rongelap/Utirik displacement chains. This inspection does not merge their cohorts, replace source-specific qualifiers or re-admit cases.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-THULE-SCOPE", "records": [ 10 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "José Francisco Calí Tzay’s report covers Denmark and Greenland following a February 2023 visit; Thule relocation is treated in paras. 47–48. The existing Thule label is a valid subject description, not the full report title. The record remains without a current atlas case.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-TIMOR-ALLEGATIONS", "records": [ 11 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The December 2025 Working Group session report contains an Annex II general allegation about Indonesia and Timor Leste. Page 43 attributes information and uses reportedly/allegedly. Keep the current allegation wording. Metadata verification does not independently adjudicate the allegations or recode the wider Indonesian-occupation case.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-MARSHALL-2024", "records": [ 12 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "A/HRC/57/77 is an OHCHR report requested by the Human Rights Council, distinct from the 2025 Special Rapporteur report. Page 2 describes consultations, oral tradition and documentary inputs; footnote 2 discloses significant implementation constraints from the Secretariat regular-budget liquidity crisis. The inactive/unassigned model scope stays unchanged.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_documents_20260910", "id": "UN-READING-LIMITS", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Nine PDF identity-page images were inspected. Selected report introductions, scope/limitation disclosures and a few existing passage locators were read; full reports and underlying cited sources were not all read. DOCX inspection is XML text, not a rendered Word-layout comparison. Local private capture is not an external archive or verified remote backup; complete funding/competing-interest coverage is not claimed. Main review also inspected the dossier index column labels and page 40 image/row 999; no other dossier content is claimed read.", "disposition": "Retain roles and reading limits; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-SCOPE", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Preserve all original URLs, 45 occurrences, ten citation IDs and three current cases. Active, unassigned, inactive and reviewed-negative scopes are not changed by bibliographic identification.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-BOUGAINVILLE", "records": [ 1 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "This is a 2006-copyright proceedings volume from an October 2004 conference, not an OHCHR-authored Bougainville report. Keep Aggarwal, editors, HIC-HLRN publisher, Havini presenter and Garasu represented-testimony roles distinct. Printed 153 ends the contribution before Cook Islands material on the same page. Copyright month is not asserted as issue day. Main review confirmed that two bound historical/audit occurrences explicitly say UN human-rights report; the attribution/type finding is grounded in those records as well as the source imprint.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-FIJI-SUPPORT", "records": [ 1 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Front matter credits RRRT, HIC-HLRN, APWLD and IWRAW-AP as organizers, cooperation with the UN Special Rapporteur and OHCHR, support of UN Habitat, and financial/institutional contributions of New Zealand Aid, UNDP GOLD and OHCHR. These are reported acknowledgments, not a complete funding/conflict-of-interest audit. Testimony and report synthesis are not independent corroborating sources.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-CRIMEA", "records": [ 2 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "HRMMU landing-page date 25 September 2017 is distinct from the 22 February 2014–12 September 2017 reporting period. Executive-summary paragraph 2 says HRMMU monitored from mainland Ukraine after access to Crimea was not provided. Page navigation under Secretary-General reports does not override the explicit OHCHR author credit.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-AFGHAN-EXPERTS", "records": [ 3 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "OHCHR publishes the press release; the twelve named people are the statement issuers, including five Working Group members. The page says Special Procedures experts are independent, voluntary and not UN staff. Concerns, allegations and risk assessments are not converted into adjudicated findings; media contacts are not authors.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-SANMARINO", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Minister Nicola Renzi’s statement is marked Check against delivery and names a 10–11 December 2018 conference. Do not infer an exact delivery day. Its wartime refugee account remains a government statement; reviewed-negative scope is unchanged, and the modern refugee passage does not establish colonizing activity.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-CLAPP", "records": [ 5 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "A/1106 is the first interim report, not the later final report. Mission signatories include Clapp and three deputy chairmen; Hussein C. Yalcin transmits it for UNCCP. The report is signed 6 November 1949; letter and platform publication date are 16 November. Platform migration timestamps are not report dates. Historical counts and reference chains are not independently verified.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-SETTLEMENT-VERSIONS", "records": [ 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The portal A/HRC/58/73 identity matches both linked 18-page PDFs, whose title pages were inspected. Both give 6 March 2025; the reviewed metadata now records that issue date separately from the platform date. The final PDF is byte-identical to the predecessor UN-document capture. The advance PDF cover says Advance edited version; the portal extract still says Advanced unedited version. Complete portal paragraph 2 matches both PDF texts after whitespace removal, so it does not identify the HTML source version. Preserve both portal labels, original access identity and remaining HTML-version qualification. No whole-content or final/advance format equivalence is asserted.", "disposition": "Two linked versions directly inspected; issue date and exact final-PDF counterpart established. HTML-version qualification remains visible." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-ESCWA", "records": [ 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The portal heading and opening match the sealed A/79/975–E/2025/82 report of 21 July 2025. ESCWA prepares it; the Secretary-General transmits a note. The two symbols denote one report, and this portal is not another independent source. It remains an inactive/unassigned model-input record; full transcription equivalence is not verified.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-TOKELAU", "records": [ 8 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Original automated access was empty HTTP 202, but the ordinary browser loaded the June 1987 No. 30 issue, with 13 pages reported by its viewer. The historical paragraph on printed p. 3 distinguishes the initial 1863 removals from later periodic raids and joint disease/raid population effects. Do not merge these numbers or treat metadata inspection as historical re-admission. No local PDF or screenshot archive was obtained.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-WESTERN-SAHARA", "records": [ 10 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Browser access recovered the Western Sahara page with last-updated label 9 September 2024. That label does not date every data item. Linked A/5514 Annex III, Spain’s 1976 communication and UNdata are not independently inspected. No status, population or legal judgment is updated.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-RESOLUTION", "records": [ 9 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Resolution 237 is dated 14 June 1967 and was adopted unanimously at the 1361st meeting. Its calls and requests are kept distinct from evidence that they were implemented; linked treaty provisions were not independently read.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_un_portals_20260910", "id": "UNP-ACCESS-AND-READING", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Eleven original requests are terminal: four PDFs, five HTML content pages and two zero-byte 202 responses. The Crimea follow-up is a 200 HTML page. Normal browser inspection recovered the two empty-response sources without CAPTCHA interaction. Eight local PDF images were read (four first pages, Fiji imprint and contribution opening, San Marino pages 2–3); additional rendered pages were not read. Full reports, underlying cited sources, complete disclosure coverage, independent reviewer acceptance, external archives and remote backup are not claimed. Main review adds two successful linked-PDF requests and six private files (two PDFs, two text extractions, two first-page images). Both images were read. A full character-sequence diff completed but its partial displayed differences are not used to assert semantic equivalence.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded role, identity and reading qualification; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-SOMALIA-BUNDLE", "records": [ 0 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The selected URL is the UNHCR Somalia PSMN Q2 2026 report, one item in a label that also names a World Bank work and a UNHCR country profile. Keep this access identity distinct and retain the bundled occurrence text. The other works and their listed pages were not newly read.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-SOMALIA-FLOW", "records": [ 0 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The report credits UNHCR Somalia, with NRC as partner. Page 8 defines flow tracking rather than IDP stock and limits incident coverage; field interviews and protection observations are not complete national counts. Its July 2026 report date, 23 July platform date and April–June reporting period remain distinct. Outlook figures are projections, not observed Q3 outcomes.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-NOTE-MISMATCH", "records": [ 1 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The Refworld URL identifies a December 2003 UNHCR Moscow edited extract, not the 1994 HRW report or either ECHR judgment named in the occurrence bundle. The ecoi.net copy matches the inspected title, date and opening but no byte identity is claimed. Original text groups Sumgait and Baku under 1989/1990; this metadata pass does not resolve or adopt that historical chronology or its legal-status conclusions.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-HRW-MISMATCH", "records": [ 2 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The Refworld record and primary publisher PDF identify a May 1996 report with primary author Erika Dailey, not the cited 1994 HRW/ECHR bundle. The Refworld record displays 1 May; the PDF gives May only. Cover contents points acknowledgments to page 33, whereas the actual final physical/printed page is 39. Use inspected physical location; no full Refworld/PDF text equivalence or transplanted passage verification.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-PAKISTAN-PROFILE", "records": [ 3 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The 2 December 2009 IDMC profile combines an IDMC-authored overview and navigation headings with excerpts from multiple sources, whose views IDMC does not necessarily share. ReliefWeb is the host. The 104-page PDF is not all newly read; each original source retains its role. Main review read physical/printed page 2 and its institutional self-description. The NRC role is recorded as founding organization, the exact relationship stated there, without importing the page’s promotional leadership claim.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-PAKISTAN-ANNUAL", "records": [ 4 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The 17 May 2010 Refworld entry is the Pakistan part of the 2009 global overview, distinct from the December 2009 profile. Its Balochistan paragraph explicitly notes limited information and describes an upper-bound displacement estimate. The page disclaims UNHCR authorship/endorsement. No historical numbers or case judgments were revised.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-ANGOLA", "records": [ 5 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The country dashboard is dynamic and presently describes refugees and asylum seekers hosted in Angola, rather than providing the named civil-war history. Its population panels carry 31 August 2026, not a whole-page publication date. Related repatriation links were not opened; source identity repair leaves the historical passage-support gap visible.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-LIBYA", "records": [ 6 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The update covers 16–22 June 2017; its second-page response map is dated 19 June and different indicators have their own sources/dates. The Tawergha paragraph reports a ratified return agreement and earlier displacement; it does not establish completed return, legal attribution or a new case classification. The French URL route serves an English PDF.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-UKRAINE", "records": [ 7 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "The Ukraine Refugee Situation page is a changing UNHCR Operational Data Portal view. Individual document dates, dataset dates and copyright are not a publication date for the entire portal. No linked dashboard, total refugee estimate or historical classification is newly accepted.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-BIAFRA", "records": [ 8 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Nathaniel H. Goetz is the working-paper author; UNHCR supplies its series/host context. The cover says these are preliminary research results and do not represent official UNHCR views. The introduction footnote describes the graduate internship and thanks contributors. Metadata uses readable service extracts; the original PDF was not locally captured or visually inspected and underlying archival evidence remains unreviewed.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-DISCLOSURE-AND-SCOPE", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Somalia page 8 visibly credits support and partnership logos; HRW page 39 names contributors, supporting foundations and a no-government-funds statement. These inspected disclosures do not amount to complete funding or conflict-of-interest checks across all sources. All original scopes, 36 occurrences and zero current atlas cases remain. No colonization/refugee-origin flag, coordinate, hold or scientific result is changed.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UR-ACCESS-AND-READING", "records": [ 0, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 ], "status": "scope_limit_retained_main_fact_checked", "note": "Seventeen direct requests are terminal: nine originals, six follow-ups and two publisher-PDF routes. Five source PDFs are locally captured. Four original Refworld requests and two later PDF requests returned 403; the UNHCR media landing returned 404. Normal browser access stopped at a challenge without interaction. Four successful service extracts and an explicitly authored observation of an earlier Refworld view supplement local evidence; a later timeout is retained but excluded as source content. Eight local PDF images were read. Full works, source archives, remote backup and independent review remain incomplete. Main review read the IDMC profile page 2 image and existing text, adding one private rendered image and bringing inspected local images to nine. No additional retrieval was run; all nine candidates now carry the actual 10 September 2026 access date.", "disposition": "Retain the bounded source role and reading limit; no historical or publication application." }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_remaining_20260911", "id": "UNHCR-ETHIOPIA-IDENTITY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The exact indexed URL identifies an Ethiopia situation section of Global Report 2021. Its reporting year is 2021; its publication date remains unknown. A separate regional page’s 16 June 2022 date and the global PDF’s upload path cannot date this individual page. The current origin returns 404.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "8b4d184250bbca574273211d6317327b642c0a5e2670b1e030329b3e29d090df", "fd5463f33951142e00e131419b885a9658aba0b1c85e266567db308d849a72ee" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_remaining_20260911", "id": "UNHCR-ETHIOPIA-SCOPE", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The indexed section estimates 3.6 million IDPs across the widening northern conflict and reports 57,000 Ethiopian refugees registered in Sudan at end-2021. Its combined 215,000 refugee figure includes Eritrean refugees in Ethiopia and is not solely Ethiopian outflow. Planned capacity for 25,000 Eritrean refugees is not completed relocation. These indexed passages do not establish a 2022 endpoint or all atrocity claims in the active event.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "8b4d184250bbca574273211d6317327b642c0a5e2670b1e030329b3e29d090df" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_remaining_20260911", "id": "UNHCR-MYANMAR-IDENTITY", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The exact indexed URL is a 2020 country-results page titled Myanmar - Communities affected by displacement (nationwide), not a current map or post-2021 national total. The publication date remains unknown and the original currently returns 404. Do not substitute a 2025/2026 map under this identity.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "dce20bf7ae986d5dee532a3b7259c9ebe8f81852443450face2af63ae2ebde8d", "fd5463f33951142e00e131419b885a9658aba0b1c85e266567db308d849a72ee" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_remaining_20260911", "id": "UNHCR-MYANMAR-SCOPE", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The indexed text distinguishes end-2020 Kachin/northern Shan counts of 104,475 people and 20,106 households in 170 locations from 15,568 people in protracted southeastern displacement. Around 3,000 supported people had been displaced in 2019. Reported departures to pursue solutions do not establish every return’s durability; the page describes continued safety risks and uneven humanitarian access. The umbrella Myanmar input remains inactive.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "dce20bf7ae986d5dee532a3b7259c9ebe8f81852443450face2af63ae2ebde8d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-IDENTITY", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "The selected URL identifies the 2014 World Bank report by Bryld, Kamau and Sinigallia, produced by Tana Copenhagen under the Global Program on Forced Displacement. The retained occurrence title describes three works; its UNHCR/NRC and UNHCR claims are prior reading-history provenance, not new consultations or metadata for those separate works.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "837f3c35d50fd03705f91b9f4dabb2f08c4710c48ff8faf857077f51cb16c94e", "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-DATES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Visible copyright is 2014. The publisher catalogue labels document date 9 December 2014 and disclosure 17 December 2014. Embedded page-one text says July 2014, but that line is not visible on the rendered photo cover. Keep these separate; no preferred July publication day or substantive revision is inferred.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d", "d01756c6db6f8fd0104586b432859fbc9b1b5be8fc3b4aced6bd546d1869c1cf" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-ROLES", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Named Tana researchers are authors. World Bank research support and peer comments, Danish Ministry of Foreign Affairs and UNHCR comments, and United Nations Photo/Tobin Jones cover credit have distinct roles. The disclaimer assigns views to authors. No exhaustive funding, conflict, licensing or independence determination is claimed.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-METHOD", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Field study ran February–June 2013, combining desk review and interviews in Mogadishu, Doolow and Hargeisa, plus other informants. The report includes later statistics and 2014 narrative; their dates are distinct from the field study, and every claim is not a direct field observation. The report primarily studies IDPs; fluid population, mixed categories and inconsistent methods limit counts.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-DEFINITIONS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "Refugee in Somalia, Somali refugee and returnee have explicitly stated report-specific meanings. The account of Somaliland administrative practice and state terminology is not a new legal-status ruling. Displacement victims do not automatically establish flight among actors taking land.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-CONFLICT", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "PDF 13–16 (printed 10–13) support the national 1991–1995 wave, 1992 peak, 2005–2009 Mogadishu movement, northern front and conflict/land-loss mechanisms at the stated aggregate level. They do not supply individual movement histories, all actors or unique cohorts; drought, famine and violence interact.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-EVICTIONS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "PDF 17 and 21 (printed 14 and 18) distinguish reported evictions from public buildings in 2012 and returning-owner removals from the announced January 2013 plan aiming at August 2013 relocation. The plan is not evidence all proposed relocations occurred. General urban trends and late-2013 settlement stocks are not a count of implemented 2012–2013 removals.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-COUNT-DATE-LIMITS", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "PDF 14 describes Puntland independence in 1998 while PDF 15 describes a semi-autonomous declaration in 1993. These are different date and state-status formulations; neither is independently established as corrected history here. PDF 21 lists location counts summing to 149,000 beside 129,400, with footnote 39 identifying unrevised location figures and earlier totals. PDF 22 warns the Somaliland figure excludes some displaced people under local classification. Preserve all denominators and dates; no silent repair.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOM-RETURN-FLIGHT", "records": [ 0 ], "note": "PDF 21 reports returning refugees and diaspora evicting IDPs; it is a specific lead for incoming-flight research, not a completed flag assignment. PDF 12 and 23–24 distinguish voluntary/coerced return, repatriation pressure, lack of support and plans from outcomes. No named returned evictor is linked here to a particular flight history or accepted colonial classification.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-CERNEA-IDENTITY", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The PDF is Cernea’s broad sociological working paper, not a dedicated technical assessment of Three Gorges resettlement. Printed January 1997, Environment Department Papers, Social Assessment Series 044, department and division control the citation. The catalogue document day and 2010 disclosure are separately labelled. Search-indexed alternative SDP16 and additional file remain unverified.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "d01756c6db6f8fd0104586b432859fbc9b1b5be8fc3b4aced6bd546d1869c1cf", "f939d6ce67b962ca48d1afc96595da3ebafaa237adb83ee5cd061514a1dedf71" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-CERNEA-ROLES", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The paper identifies Cernea as World Bank senior adviser and explicitly says these discussion papers are not formal Bank publications and views are the author’s. Acknowledgement credits NORAD conference feedback and Bank colleagues/editorial production, not coauthorship or an independent dedicated project audit. The earlier conference version has no date in the inspected acknowledgement.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "f939d6ce67b962ca48d1afc96595da3ebafaa237adb83ee5cd061514a1dedf71" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-CERNEA-TABLES", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "Table 1, printed 6/PDF 12, lists Three Gorges under construction with 1,100,000 people. Annex 1, printed 22/PDF 28, gives FY 2008, 8200 MW, 110000 ha and 1,300,000 people. Printed 21/PDF 27 defines FY as completed or expected completion and describes mixed sources and project-inception estimates. The 200,000 difference is unreconciled; neither number is a verified final resettlement census.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "f939d6ce67b962ca48d1afc96595da3ebafaa237adb83ee5cd061514a1dedf71" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-CERNEA-EVENT-SCOPE", "records": [ 1 ], "note": "The saved Three Gorges event runs 1994–2012 and describes varied compensation and livelihood outcomes. A 1997 general paper and its projected table cannot alone verify the later end date or those later project-specific outcomes. Targeted later evidence is required before stronger authoring. This source review changes no frozen event or score.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "0f47fe9e49055b7c4227b61d135258005705207701df69a189a53f0cae5bff0d", "f939d6ce67b962ca48d1afc96595da3ebafaa237adb83ee5cd061514a1dedf71" ] }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-READING-SCOPE", "records": [ 0, 1 ], "note": "Two original PDFs were captured. Seventeen Somalia original page images and nine Cernea images were read; extracted text also covers the selected Cernea bibliography pages 32–35 without visual inspection. Neither whole report was read. PDF creation/modification timestamps are technical metadata and do not establish substantive revision.", "retained_evidence_sha256": [ "23359989fe725bfe48b1f312d27ffc4b8be705fc720665956dcc8775d43df3bf", "96fa7b439a06207054b42e0b794de36bd85acc5aa4b0a7407a781ed18498f17d", "ea211dde8811c3a65b391d92c4b62a5753ca4005578f0f86d80943cbb08af11c", "f939d6ce67b962ca48d1afc96595da3ebafaa237adb83ee5cd061514a1dedf71" ] } ], "source_followups": [ { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-FORNARA-25-26", "work_id": "access:99f919554a7e7a6bff9b", "status": "unresolved_source_locator", "question": "Inspect the recorded Croton locus pp.25–26 in Fornara’s second edition and determine whether the linked excerpt actually includes it.", "new_global_hold": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_cambridge_assets_20260910", "id": "CA-HUGUENOTS-PASSAGE", "work_id": "title:the huguenots history and memory in transnational context", "status": "unresolved_source_locator", "event_id": "modern-huguenot-exile", "question": "Locate the passage supporting the existing Revocation/exile narrative in the intended Trim volume. Introduction pp.1–42 is a publisher-contents lead only; the current erroneous Cambridge link cannot verify that work.", "new_global_hold": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_emishi_remaining_20260911", "id": "EM-GRANT-OUTPUT-METADATA", "status": "open", "work_id": "access:663c94b574f728149cde", "question": "Two linked output citations disagree between project record and report: the 2017 Shinano article’s page range and the 2015 Yamanashi journal volume. Leave these product-level differences open until the original articles are inspected; do not change the checked project identity or assert all listed output counts match.", "next_action": "Consult original 2017 Shinano and 2015 Yamanashi product records if those products are selected for citation; retain both observed variants meanwhile.", "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_global_press_batwa_20260910", "id": "GP-JUDGMENT-IDENTITY", "status": "primary_document_comparison_pending", "work_id": "title:court ruling brings hope to a displaced people global press journal", "question": "Which original judgment(s) are represented by the two ULII entries, and what do their operative orders actually establish?", "leads": "JUDGMENT_SOURCE_LEADS.json", "historical_changes": 0, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_livy_mirror_20260909", "work_id": "url:swartzentrover.com/cotor/e-books/misc/livy/hor_06.htm", "question": "The Book 6 mirror has markers 6.15 and 6.17 but no literal 6.16 marker. Check a required passage against a suitable counterpart before deciding whether this is only missing markup or missing text.", "observed_missing_marker": "6.16", "status": "separate_passage_structure_question_open", "followup_id": "livy_book6_marker_and_6166_locator", "calibration_group": "L17", "verdict": "Uncheckable", "current_citation_ids": [ "b35_204f330763b38d" ], "current_cases": [ "gr-roman-pomptine-division-settlement-383-358", "gr-roman-satricum-countercapture-382", "gr-roman-satricum-roman-conquest-colony-386-385" ], "current_locator": "6.16.6", "source_passage_newly_verified": false, "historical_acceptance_changed": false, "effective_status": "resolved_at_bounded_main_source_scope", "resolution_review_id": "source_locator_livy_book6_20260910" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_loc_20260910", "id": "LOC-NOLA-INSCRIPTION-DATE", "status": "unresolved_targeted_source_location", "work_id": "access:ea18db86947acb8335c6", "current_case": "prospective-gr-roman-sulla-nola-veteran-allotment-81-78-bce", "question": "Where does the current c.80–70 BCE date for CIL X 1236 appear in Camodeca’s actual evidence?", "next_source": "Camodeca, Porcii Catones e Tullii a Nola, Oebalus 6 (2011), pp. 105–117, especially 111.", "institutional_record": "https://unora.unior.it/handle/11574/32870", "access_limit": "Institutional search result lists no associated file; article text has not been opened in this pass.", "next_action": "Locate and inspect the original article or epigraphic record; compare exact date with the already cited Thein 2026 attribution. Any substantive case amendment retains its review gate.", "new_global_hold": false, "effective_status": "resolved_at_bounded_main_source_scope", "resolution_review_id": "source_locator_nola_inscription_20260910" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_nature_20260909", "work_id": "access:a62ecae8e1b52b7db889", "question": "Check the retained genomic-formation section and figure 5 locator against the exact Yin article before claiming new passage acceptance.", "status": "separate_passage_review_open", "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_nature_20260909", "work_id": "access:b1cda7e2da9fefb6dc92", "question": "Use corrected Mittnik text/supplement when assessing chronology or coordinates affected by its notice; assess any case-specific impact through the substantive review process.", "status": "separate_passage_review_open", "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_springer_20260909", "work_id": "title:posth et al 2018 language continuity despite population replacement in remote oceania nature ecology evolution 2 731 740", "question": "Before treating the local manuscript as identical to the publisher version for a passage, establish its version and check the specific passage against the required version.", "status": "separate_version_and_passage_review_open", "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_teara_20260910", "id": "TA-LICENCE-VERSION", "status": "open_source_disclosure", "question": "Copyright body and footer display different licence versions. Resolve before any reuse that depends on a specific licence. Metadata identity acceptance does not determine copyright permissions.", "preferred_identity_field": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_topostext_20260910", "id": "TT-MELOS-THEATRE", "work_id": "access:2fd7f29a0826e9f131dc", "citation_ids": [ "b31_2fd7f29a0826e9", "b33_2fd7f29a0826e9" ], "case_ids": [ "prospective-athenian-destruction-colonization-melos-416-bce", "prospective-spartan-restoration-melos-405-bce" ], "status": "main_scope_review_complete_offered_labels_publication_pending", "question": "Keep the theatre access identity and distinguish representative urban context from exact Classical settlement location. No relocation or historical contradiction is established by this metadata pass.", "disposition": "The source identifies the Theatre of Melos. Actual cases use it representatively; naming the theatre is accepted as an offered clarification. No historical repair or relocation is established.", "decision": "DECISIONS.json", "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UNHCR-REFWORLD-BUNDLE-01-SUPPORT", "identity_correction": "UNHCR-REFWORLD-BUNDLE-01", "work_id": "access:7bf460e13164c146ae0e", "event_ids": [ "prospective-nk-baku-anti-armenian-pogrom-1990" ], "citation_ids": [], "occurrence_ids": [ "occ:83d373fa2cd95505a6de", "occ:a5d3751101dc5a3a6895" ], "status": "open_historical_source_support_review_required", "finding": "The URL resolves to a different work from the named 1994 HRW/ECHR bundle. Preserve the original record and identify this linked work accurately; do not treat it as evidence for the bundled works or inherit their page/paragraph locators.", "next_action": "Identify the intended historical work and verify the event-specific passages, preserving the original citation bundle and locators. Any substantive historical change requires the saved review process.", "claim_proven_false": false, "case_hold_changed": false, "publication_application": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UNHCR-REFWORLD-BUNDLE-02-SUPPORT", "identity_correction": "UNHCR-REFWORLD-BUNDLE-02", "work_id": "access:a6ac7c71e1b415301a54", "event_ids": [ "prospective-nk-baku-anti-armenian-pogrom-1990", "prospective-nk-sumgait-anti-armenian-pogrom-1988" ], "citation_ids": [], "occurrence_ids": [ "occ:c1d15df5910299673577", "occ:15c06c51df47ca4e474c", "occ:800fec0b565cfef7e663", "occ:35b8da229ffa9a949fe2" ], "status": "open_historical_source_support_review_required", "finding": "The URL resolves to a different work from the named 1994 HRW/ECHR bundle. Preserve the original record and identify this linked work accurately; do not treat it as evidence for the bundled works or inherit their page/paragraph locators.", "next_action": "Identify the intended historical work and verify the event-specific passages, preserving the original citation bundle and locators. Any substantive historical change requires the saved review process.", "claim_proven_false": false, "case_hold_changed": false, "publication_application": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_refworld_20260910", "id": "UNHCR-ANGOLA-DASHBOARD-SCOPE-SUPPORT", "identity_correction": "UNHCR-ANGOLA-DASHBOARD-SCOPE", "work_id": "title:unhcr angola repatriation after the long civil war", "event_ids": [ "modern-angola-civil-war-displacement" ], "citation_ids": [ "modern_angola_unhcr" ], "occurrence_ids": [ "occ:195be162d936321efb85", "occ:c49e6c70f4a6c49ee6e1", "occ:bf5771d1f645bcd15da0", "occ:a9e2a473c511a1bb34cf", "occ:8c56d95e5f46f8bdfa4f" ], "status": "open_historical_source_support_review_required", "finding": "Two preserved audit/inventory occurrences classify this dynamic country portal as UN agency country history, while the current label claims repatriation after the long civil war. The inspected page describes current refugees/asylum seekers in Angola; it is not the named historical work.", "next_action": "Identify the intended historical work and verify the event-specific passages, preserving the original citation bundle and locators. Any substantive historical change requires the saved review process.", "claim_proven_false": false, "case_hold_changed": false, "publication_application": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_remaining_20260911", "id": "UNHCR-ORIGIN-ACCESS-0", "work_id": "title:unhcr ethiopia situation tigray conflict displacement", "status": "open", "question": "Restore a working official or provenance-matched archived access copy of the exact source; retain the observed 404 and indexed evidence meanwhile.", "next_action": "Use a changed official route or an archive with a verifiable exact-source match when available; do not retry the same failed origin without changed evidence.", "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_unhcr_remaining_20260911", "id": "UNHCR-ORIGIN-ACCESS-1", "work_id": "title:unhcr protracted displacement in myanmar s ethnic conflicts", "status": "open", "question": "Restore a working official or provenance-matched archived access copy of the exact source; retain the observed 404 and indexed evidence meanwhile.", "next_action": "Use a changed official route or an archive with a verifiable exact-source match when available; do not retry the same failed origin without changed evidence.", "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-THREE-GORGES-LATER-EVIDENCE", "work_id": "title:world bank technical assessment of three gorges resettlement", "status": "open", "question": "Identify project-specific source evidence for the 1994–2012 event endpoints, realized removal total, and compensation/livelihood outcomes; reconcile the 1997 Table 1 and Annex 1 figures without treating forecasts as a census.", "basis": "WB-CERNEA-TABLES; WB-CERNEA-EVENT-SCOPE", "historical_acceptance_changed": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOMALIA-PUNTLAND-CHRONOLOGY", "work_id": "access:ea331da1ecb7a28815b0", "status": "open_if_used_in_authoring", "question": "Resolve the source’s 1998 independence and 1993 semi-autonomous declaration formulations with an authoritative chronology before quoting either as atlas history.", "basis": "WB-SOM-COUNT-DATE-LIMITS", "historical_acceptance_changed": false, "effective_status": "resolved_at_bounded_main_source_scope", "resolution_review_id": "source_locator_puntland_20260911" }, { "review_id": "bibliography_worldbank_20260911", "id": "WB-SOMALIA-RETURNED-EVICTOR-FLIGHT", "work_id": "access:ea331da1ecb7a28815b0", "status": "unaccepted_source_lead", "question": "Can the returning refugees described as evicting IDPs be linked to a specific accepted event, named actor/cohort and source-supported flight pressure, without equating all diaspora or returnees with colonizers?", "basis": "WB-SOM-RETURN-FLIGHT", "event_id": "prospective-somalia-mogadishu-urban-evictions-2012-2013", "flight_assigned": false, "effective_status": "open_with_recorded_limits" } ], "separate_source_reviews": [ { "review_id": "source_locator_livy_book6_20260910", "decision": { "status": "main_source_locator_review_complete_publication_pending", "question_resolved_at_main_source_locator_scope": true, "resolved_question": "livy_book6_marker_and_6166_locator", "basis": "The required passage is present in the existing mirror. OCT digital 6.16.6 contains both statements; the other digital locators differ as recorded.", "existing_citation_supported": true, "required_correction": false, "offered_locator_clarification": true, "exact_print_edition_resolved": false, "historical_acceptance_changed": false, "publication_application": false, "preceding_sealed_question": "monograph/bibliography_livy_mirror_20260909/SCOPE_FOLLOWUPS.json", "preceding_review_edited": false }, "reviewed_note": { "status": "main_reviewed_publication_pending", "citation_id": "b35_204f330763b38d", "case_ids": [ "gr-roman-pomptine-division-settlement-383-358", "gr-roman-satricum-countercapture-382", "gr-roman-satricum-roman-conquest-colony-386-385" ], "original_work_id": "url:swartzentrover.com/cotor/e-books/misc/livy/hor_06.htm", "text": "Livy’s reported order for 2,000 Roman citizen colonists at Satricum and two-and-a-half jugera per person is present in the linked Roberts mirror. Its Book 6 page omits the 6.16 marker; find the passage beginning “Before any demand had been put forward” between the 6.15 and 6.17 markers. The OCT text in Perseus places both statements at 6.16.6. The Teubner digital text splits them across 6.16.6–7, while the Roberts digital text places them at 6.15.12 and also omits chapter 16. These locator differences do not establish missing passage text. The figures remain Livy’s report, with the existing case’s limits on actual arrivals and resident displacement unchanged.", "source_urls": [ "https://www.swartzentrover.com/cotor/e-books/misc/Livy/HOR_06.htm", "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/PerseusDL/canonical-latinLit/master/data/phi0914/phi001/phi0914.phi001.perseus-lat3.xml", "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/PerseusDL/canonical-latinLit/master/data/phi0914/phi001/phi0914.phi001.perseus-lat2.xml", "https://raw.githubusercontent.com/PerseusDL/canonical-latinLit/master/data/phi0914/phi001/phi0914.phi001.perseus-eng3.xml" ], "source_accessed": { "mirror": "2026-09-09", "counterparts": "2026-09-10" }, "historical_acceptance_changed": false, "publication_application": false, "apparatus": [ "PASSAGE_OBSERVATIONS.json", "SOURCE_DISCLOSURES.json", "SOURCE_EVIDENCE_MANIFEST.json" ], "kind": "offered_source_locator_clarification", "main_review_complete": true, "reviewed_by": "main_agent", "review_apparatus": [ "ROUND_1_REVIEW.md", "ROUND_2_REVIEW.md", "ROUND_3_REVIEW.md", "CALIBRATION.json", "SOURCE_DISCLOSURES.json", "SOURCE_EVIDENCE_MANIFEST.json" ] }, "seal_sha256": "4779d34a207607af891d9680be230f648c75e5c1f732338cacc3ca7772a78b10", "note_sha256": "dab2fdab4215f2254fea9dc10cbbbbbff35188d5389dce13587fc28fb9500bcf" }, { "review_id": "source_locator_nola_inscription_20260910", "decision": { "status": "main_source_locator_review_complete_publication_pending", "reviewer": "main_agent", "resolved_question": "LOC-NOLA-INSCRIPTION-DATE", "source_locus": "Camodeca 2011, p.111 n.22", "decision": "The existing c.80–70 BCE inscription date has a located source. Preserve it and expose the distinct 2011 citation in a later successor.", "locator_note": "LOCATOR_NOTE_REVIEWED.json", "related_metadata_repair": "LOC-CAMODECA-CITATION-LABEL", "related_metadata_packet": "monograph/bibliography_loc_20260910/DECISIONS.json", "metadata_composite_unchanged": true, "new_bibliography_ids": 0, "historical_disposition_changes": 0, "date_changes": 0, "public_source_addition_pending": true, "publication_application": false, "created_at": "2026-09-10T15:50:24.239254+00:00" }, "reviewed_note": { "question_id": "LOC-NOLA-INSCRIPTION-DATE", "public_note": "Camodeca dates the inscription attesting Nola’s colony and colonists to approximately 80–70 BCE (2011, p.111 n.22). This dates the inscription, not the act of land assignment.", "citation_label": "Giuseppe Camodeca, “Porcii Catones e Tullii a Nola in una iscrizione tardorepubblicana erroneamente ritenuta falsa (CIL X 181*),” Oebalus 6 (2011), pp.105–117, especially p.111 n.22", "citation_url": "https://www.academia.edu/2512620/Porcii_Catones_e_Tullii_a_Nola_in_una_iscrizione_tardorepubblicana_erroneamente_ritenuta_falsa_CIL_X_181_", "application_rule": "Expose a separate 2011 source/locator for the existing date. Preserve the 2017 LOC chapter identity and its scoped label repair for later community/integration discussion. Do not repurpose its stable work/access ID as the 2011 article. Neither a new bibliography ID nor a new registry citation is created in this review.", "public_source_addition_pending": true, "current_case_date_unchanged": true, "historical_acceptance_changed": false, "publication_application": false }, "seal_sha256": "a675612633f9b01fab0359a42cc9a04c57a037b062774c971668affadb5899e8", "note_sha256": "eb8481a197c1c62b7ed4349b1e2087ec9666e71704e6bb7d540940b95b7ae426" }, { "review_id": "source_locator_echuya_plan_20260910", "decision": { "status": "main_source_locator_review_complete_with_limits_publication_pending", "reviewer": "main_agent", "task_id": "LOC-ECHUYA-PLAN", "verified": [ "Cover identity and March 2023 date", "Precise saved-source locators", "Separate Echuya plan scope" ], "remaining_questions": [ "ECHUYA-EXACT-DISPLACEMENT", "ECHUYA-SUBSTANTIVE-REVISION" ], "calibration_counts": { "Matched": 11, "Uncheckable": 2 }, "required_corrections": 0, "offered_refinements": [ "EP-FULL-CITATION-LOCATORS" ], "metadata_composite_unchanged": true, "new_bibliography_ids": 0, "new_preferred_metadata_nulls": 0, "historical_disposition_changes": 0, "date_changes": 0, "new_incoming_flight_flags": 0, "public_application": false, "local_publication_application": false, "remote_copy_verified": false, "created_at": "2026-09-11T03:11:49.472359+00:00" }, "reviewed_note": { "task_id": "LOC-ECHUYA-PLAN", "citation_label": "Republic of Uganda, Ministry of Water and Environment and National Forestry Authority, Vulnerable and Marginalized Groups Plan (VMGP) for the Batwa around Echuya Central Forest Reserve, March 2023, IFPA-CD project P170466", "citation_url": "https://www.mwe.go.ug/publications/35/download", "verified_locators": { "introduction": "p.7 §1.0; separate plans p.8", "purpose": "pp.11–12 §1.1", "institutional_history": "p.12 §1.2 and n.5", "regional_map": "p.13 Figure 1, Map of Echuya CFR", "social_economic": "pp.16–17 §1.4(a)", "population": "pp.17–19 §1.4(b), Tables 2–4", "culture_survey": "p.19 §1.4(c)", "land_access": "p.20 §1.4(d)", "refugee_programmes_inapplicable": "p.11, subcomponents 3.1 and 3.2" }, "source_note": "The March 2023 MWE/NFA plan treats Echuya separately from Bwindi, Mgahinga and Semuliki (p.8). Its reserve history is on p.12 (§1.2); these institutional dates do not establish an eviction date. The plan reports district-wide population, local household estimates and survey participants in separate passages (pp.18–19). None is an Echuya eviction census. Its land-access discussion combines reports of non-compensation with selective later assistance and continuing tenure uncertainty (p.20).", "application_rule": "Offer a distinct, accurately dated government-plan citation and these precise locators in the future citation integration. Retain the separate PLOS and Mukasa identities. This source check creates no registry ID, changes no event date or score and does not resolve the exact Echuya displacement question.", "required_corrections": [], "offered_refinements": [ { "id": "EP-FULL-CITATION-LOCATORS", "basis": "The earlier broad page ranges led to the right material; make section starts and the distinct government-plan citation explicit." } ], "source_limit_flags": [ "ECHUYA-EXACT-DISPLACEMENT", "ECHUYA-SUBSTANTIVE-REVISION" ], "public_application": false, "local_publication_application": false }, "seal_sha256": "8c6125b76f6a56c1c8c0ba5f96d2dde1aa4b225800a6b6a4353cc3fafdef273c", "note_sha256": "6cc09075512b5336a51af762c65ca29803d4b03ac32bc4de4da3fa48e98e3419" }, { "review_id": "source_locator_batwa_judgment_20260910", "decision": { "status": "bounded_main_review_complete_original_comparison_unresolved", "task_id": "GP-JUDGMENT-IDENTITY", "selected_task_complete": false, "original_comparison_complete": false, "main_bounded_review_complete": true, "reviewer": "main_agent", "remaining_questions": [ "GP-JUDGMENT-IDENTITY", "BATWA-JUDGMENT-LATER-REMEDY", "ECHUYA-EXACT-DISPLACEMENT" ], "calibration_counts": { "Matched": 11, "Uncheckable": 3 }, "required_corrections": 0, "offered_refinements": [ "BJ-PRIMARY-PASSAGE-NOTE" ], "metadata_composite_unchanged": true, "new_bibliography_ids": 0, "new_preferred_metadata_nulls": 0, "historical_disposition_changes": 0, "date_changes": 0, "new_incoming_flight_flags": 0, "public_application": false, "local_publication_application": false, "remote_copy_verified": false, "created_at": "2026-09-11T17:11:32.298311+00:00" }, "reviewed_note": { "task_id": "GP-JUDGMENT-IDENTITY", "citation_label": "United Organisation for Batwa Development in Uganda (UOBDU) and 11 others v Attorney General, Uganda Wildlife Authority and National Forestry Authority, Constitutional Petition No. 003 of 2013, Constitutional Court of Uganda, judgment of Elizabeth Musoke JCC, 19 August 2021 (counsel-hosted scan; catalogue/version comparison unresolved)", "citation_url": "https://onyangoadvocates.com/assets/PDF/Batwa-Judgement.pdf", "verified_locators": { "identity": "Counsel PDF pp.1–4; Musoke printed p.1 at PDF p.4", "date": "Counsel PDF pp.2–3 and 49; Musoke printed p.47", "native_title_scope": "Musoke printed p.38 / counsel PDF p.40", "compensation": "Musoke printed pp.41–43 / counsel PDF pp.43–45", "prayers": "Musoke printed pp.43–45 / counsel PDF pp.45–47", "referral_and_declarations": "Musoke printed pp.45–47 / counsel PDF pp.47–49" }, "source_note": "The inspected judgment identifies Petition 003 of 2013 and is dated 19 August 2021. Musoke’s opinion records inadequate compensation for loss of land while distinguishing some payments for structures and crops (printed pp.41–43). It refers determination of appropriate affirmative-action measures to the High Court and orders costs against the respondents (pp.45–47). Ownership registration and the timelines on pp.43–44 are requested relief. Declaration (a) concerns Echuya, Mgahinga and Bwindi collectively and places eviction around 1991–1996; it does not establish a separate exact Echuya date. The scan’s pagination has a gap, and comparison with the two ULII originals remains open. Later remedies, appeal outcome and implementation are unverified.", "source_limit_flags": [ "GP-JUDGMENT-IDENTITY", "BATWA-JUDGMENT-LATER-REMEDY", "ECHUYA-EXACT-DISPLACEMENT" ], "required_corrections": [], "offered_refinements": [ { "id": "BJ-PRIMARY-PASSAGE-NOTE", "basis": "Attach a separate provisional primary-source citation with exact printed/PDF locators and its unresolved version limits; do not replace the Global Press article identity." } ], "application_rule": "Retain as a reviewed bounded source note for later integration, with catalogue comparison still open. No new event date, score, registry identity or public implementation is accepted by this source review.", "public_application": false, "local_publication_application": false }, "seal_sha256": "898005e08e8b64699e9e6561753150ee868f8483c6c1002975440427a1c5138d", "note_sha256": "292cc01dbc63a5b23a391159f43d161c0a9b05e7cd5c0666aaae47eee24cc798" }, { "review_id": "source_locator_puntland_20260911", "decision": { "status": "bounded_source_question_resolved_for_later_citation", "question_id": "WB-SOMALIA-PUNTLAND-CHRONOLOGY", "resolved": true, "source_note": "SOURCE_NOTE.md", "formation_month": "1998-08", "formation_status": "autonomous administration within Somalia", "main_review_complete": true, "independent_case_review": false, "original_charter_inspected": false, "current_status_verified": false, "exact_formation_day_verified": false, "required_application": "Do not reproduce the World Bank1993 formation or independence wording as the atlas’s own historical assertion. Use the two cited UN accounts for the bounded founding statement; preserve the original record and qualify report-specific definitions.", "metadata_record_changes": 0, "historical_event_changes": 0, "publication_application": false, "remaining_other_worldbank_questions": [ "WB-THREE-GORGES-LATER-EVIDENCE", "WB-SOMALIA-RETURNED-EVICTOR-FLIGHT" ] }, "reviewed_note": "# Puntland formation — source clarification for later authoring\n\nPuntland’s formation should be dated to **August 1998**, as an autonomous administration within Somalia. The 2001 UNDP report dates formation to that month and describes the provisional charter’s commitment to Somali unity. Walter Kälin’s 2010 UN mission report likewise places the declaration of an autonomous region within Somalia in 1998.¹ ²\n\nThis resolves the bounded source question raised by the World Bank report’s 1993 date and its 1998 “independence” wording. Use the UN reports for the formation statement and keep the World Bank wording as source provenance. This correction does not determine current political status, territorial boundaries or any particular displacement event. The original 1998 charter and an exact formation day were not inspected or accepted here.\n\nThe UNDP report names Mark Bradbury, Ken Menkhaus and Roland Marchal as authors, with Bradbury also coordinating editor. Its methodology combines existing studies and interviews. Its acknowledgements credit financial support from Denmark through DANIDA; production, design, editing and Somali-overview translation are separate credits. This is an institutional synthesis with disclosed support, not an inspection of the original constitutional instrument.¹\n\nKälin’s report records a 14–21 October 2009 mission and carries a 21 January 2010 document date. The downloaded edition has Arabic front matter and an English annex. The mission visited northern settlements and interviewed arrivals from the south, but security prevented travel to south-central Somalia and limited government consultations. Its retrospective 1998 statement is not a claim that the mission observed Puntland’s founding.²\n\n**Grounding and limits:** nine UNDP and four HRC original page images were read, including source identity, relevant credits/methods and the cited passages. Neither entire report was read. No full charter, current constitution, independent field data or new population count was verified. The main-agent review supports this source note; independent case and statistical acceptance remain separate. No event, score, geometry, incoming-flight note, global bibliography ID or publication was changed.\n\n1. Mark Bradbury, Ken Menkhaus and Roland Marchal, *Human Development Report Somalia 2001* (UNDP Somalia Country Office, 2001), printed 52/PDF 55; also printed 173/PDF 176. Author/method and acknowledgement pages: PDF 6 and 15–17. [Official UN copy](https://somalia.un.org/en/download/7250/34529). Accessed 11 September 2026.\n2. Walter Kälin, *Report…on his mission to Somalia (14–21 October 2009)*, A/HRC/13/21/Add.2, 21 January 2010, English annex paragraph 4, printed/PDF 4; mission scope paragraphs 1–3. [Official UN copy, Arabic front matter with English annex](https://documents.un.org/doc/undoc/gen/g10/103/94/pdf/g1010394.pdf). Accessed 11 September 2026.\n", "seal_sha256": "490904ba0a018796f35eda32be87b721dcd7cc774483c8c5d0a159b31549dbf2", "note_sha256": "a9d051b9803778851d83df44172717563f94e3f3b974a829defe9048b3acb68b" }, { "review_id": "source_locator_three_gorges_20260911", "decision": { "status": "bounded_source_findings_verified_selected_question_partial_open", "question_id": "WB-THREE-GORGES-LATER-EVIDENCE", "source_question_resolved": false, "selected_task_complete": false, "main_review_complete": true, "independent_case_review": false, "source_note": "SOURCE_NOTE.md", "accepted_scope": [ "Historical compulsory-relocation provisions", "Government-attributed end-2011 administrative total with explicit category", "Author-reported uneven household outcomes with 351/521 follow-up distinction" ], "reported_administrative_count": { "value": 1296400, "cutoff": "end-2011", "source_category": "实际移民搬迁建房人口", "independent_census": false, "applied_to_event": false }, "remaining_questions": [ "event_endpoints", "final_cohort", "forecast_difference", "full_study" ], "metadata_record_changes": 0, "historical_event_changes": 0, "flight_changes": 0, "publication_application": false }, "reviewed_note": "# Three Gorges — later evidence for authoring\n\nThe inspected sources support compulsory relocation and uneven livelihood outcomes. **The event’s saved 1994–2012 endpoints and a fully reconciled final displacement total remain unresolved.** This note supplements the corrected Cernea citation; it does not change the frozen event.\n\nThe State Council’s 2001 regulation required people and organizations designated for relocation to move; Article 31 prohibited refusal or delay, with sanctions addressed in Article 58. Articles 3, 5 and 7 set out livelihood-restoration goals, compensation and subsequent support. These provisions establish the policy framework, not whether each household received adequate compensation. The consent clauses in Articles 12 and 18 concern household-registration conversion and joint house construction, respectively; they do not make the overall relocation voluntary. The regulation was promulgated on 15 February 2001 and took effect on 1 March, replacing the 1993 regulation. The National Energy Administration’s 19 August 2011 page date is a later hosting date.¹\n\nThe National Audit Office reported **1,296,400 people** in its relocation-and-housing category by the end of 2011, against a plan of **1,245,500**. This is a government-reported administrative total with a stated cutoff, not an independently reconstructed census. The audit covered draft financial accounts and distinguished construction, resettlement-fund and reporting dates. Its regional income indicators cannot establish every resettled household’s outcome. Its indexed later sections also record compensation-related petitions, funding irregularities and continuing support needs; its opening statement about rectification should not become a claim that every household’s grievance was resolved. The provincial republication available through the web reader ends before those later sections; the central-government indexed extracts preserve them. A complete original audit body was not captured.²\n\nBrooke Wilmsen reports improved livelihoods alongside persistent disadvantages for rural-to-urban households in Badong and Zigui. **351 of 521 households** responded in 2012/13 about 2011 conditions; the 2003/04 questionnaire also sought retrospective accounts around 1998. Keep this sample, nonresponse and the distinction between correlation and causation explicit.³\n\nThe April 2017 compendium contains presentation summaries and acknowledges ADB, World Bank and Philippine Learning Center support. These event credits establish neither study funding nor independence. Wilmsen’s summary has no study-specific disclosure and cites a differently titled 2016 article whose full text remains uninspected.³\n\nThe earlier Cernea tables contain different forecasts. Their difference remains unexplained; neither should be silently replaced by the later administrative count. The inspected sources do not settle the first and last displacement dates for the saved event. Dates of regulations, surveys, construction or account closure are not substitutes. The next historical review must specify which relocation cohort and date convention it is assessing.\n\n## Sources and inspection limits\n\n1. State Council, *长江三峡工程建设移民条例*, Order 299, 15 February 2001, Articles 3, 5, 7, 12, 18, 31, 58 and 64. [National Energy Administration text](https://www.nea.gov.cn/2011-08/19/c_131060587.htm). Captured HTML and its article text were read. English descriptions above are paraphrases of the Chinese text, not an official translation or a claim about current law.\n2. National Audit Office, *长江三峡工程竣工财务决算草案审计结果*, 7 June 2013. [Central-government source](https://www.gov.cn/gzdt/2013-06/07/content_2421795.htm); [Liaoning Audit Department republication, posted 25 December 2013](https://sjt.ln.gov.cn/sjt/tzgg/9E749E8471B04CC7BEC77048E49676D9/index.shtml). Read the provincial web-reader body and central-government indexed excerpts, including sections IV–V and footnotes. Direct requests failed; the provincial text is incomplete. The report’s administrative count is verified as an attributed statement, while full-text reconciliation remains open.\n3. Brooke Wilmsen, “After the deluge: A longitudinal study of resettlement at the Three Gorges Dam,” *Resettlement and Livelihoods: IAIA Special Symposium Compendium*, April 2017, pp. 81–82. [PDF](https://iaia.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/03/Resettlement-and-Livelihoods-IAIA-Special-Symposium-Compendium.pdf). Visually read pages 1–4, 8, 81–82; underlying data uninspected. The 2018 file metadata and 2025 URL path are separate dates.\n\nAccessed 11 September 2026. Local source captures and exact anchors accompany this note; no public archival snapshot or remote backup is claimed. The accompanying Fact-Check, Tells and Calibration files record the main-agent review. Required independent historical review remains pending. No event, score, geometry, flight note, global bibliography identity or release changed.\n", "seal_sha256": "1315a0c640c6d9322673cb63353afa498d65adcc8fb03a71203c7357e4ef0d2f", "note_sha256": "2e7a00ba9cb81309e92b3f96dcdfb4fb7f414750544ec09add1545948461fe76" } ], "reading_rule": "Review records retain their pre-publication status text as provenance. Effective follow-up status includes later accepted resolutions. A main source review does not replace independent historical review." }