# UNHCR bibliography review apparatus

These are the main-agent editorial review notes accompanying the metadata.
Internal JSON filenames identify the retained review packet; they are not
additional public downloads. Public source URLs replace private PDF locations
in the calibration locators. The applied fields appear in
typed_metadata_overlay.json. FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json and PASSAGE_FOLLOWUPS.json
preserve unresolved work. Raw source PDFs and browser captures are not included.

# UNHCR metadata — Fact-Check and Revise v2.8

Main-agent review, 2026-09-09. This is the first editorial round for this packet,
not an independent historical or statistical review.

## Intake and scope

Venue: Craig’s Taking their land site and downloadable bibliography. Composition
and factual metadata correction are authorized; this is model-assisted work.
Sources are the actually inspected browser headers, exact-title alternatives,
and thirteen downloaded PDFs with title, credit, imprint and disclosure pages
read. Original source occurrences, scores, historical narratives and stable
work/access IDs are outside the changes.

## Findings

**Correct.** The 46 candidate identities agree with the observed source titles or
explicitly identified document components. Thirty original HTML pages displayed
readable source headers; thirteen original PDF URLs yielded the documents
inspected. Three missing original links have accessible matches to titles
explicitly named in the original recorded labels. Those matches are represented
as matching access routes, not observed redirects or recovered historical bytes.

**Overstatement avoided.** Spokespersons are kept as quoted speakers. A host logo
does not make Nicholas Morris’s memoir an institutional history. The Burundi
evaluation and South Sudan report retain their own author credits and
disclaimers. The shared UNHCR book page supplies container credit, not newly
established personal authorship for each chapter.

**Wrong or unverifiable.** Six requested fields remain unresolved: the Plain
Savo attachment’s date and caption author, publication dates for the Syria fact
sheet, Morris memoir and Hammond discussion paper, and the Sudan appeal’s exact
publication date. The earlier indexed 2013 Hammond date is not adopted: the
downloaded paper describes an August 2014 meeting as forthcoming. This review
does not infer a replacement publication date from that passage. Hidden text
extracted from the Sudan PDF refers to an unrelated 2021 vaccine report and
January 2022; the rendered contents page does not display it. Those strings are
excluded from appeal metadata.

**Source quality and access.** Web headings and credit roles are source
self-description, sufficient for the bounded metadata claims made here. They
are not independent confirmation of historical claims. The original Ituri and
Plain Savo URLs remain recorded as missing. A matching source title does not
establish byte identity with a lost page. The PDF files are retained privately
with download receipts and hashes. Browser HTML observations are explicitly
transcriptions, not complete raw page archives. Public archive URLs were not
created; web-header verification is date-bounded to this inspection. Earlier
blocked fetches and incomplete portal inspection remain in the evidence trail.

**Structure.** Magazine articles are identified within their issue containers;
book chapters remain separate work/access records. The whole repatriation
document is not renamed after its Tajikistan section. The Hmong regional routes
retain their two original IDs and their different displayed speaker credits.

**Register.** Titles supplied by sources can contain advocacy language; that
language is attributed as a title and does not become the bibliography’s own
historical conclusion. No score, refugee legal status, causal motive or evidence
hold is newly decided here.

**Attribution.** Printed authorship takes precedence over conflicting PDF file
properties for the Morris memoir. The memoir’s author-view disclaimer, the PDES
evaluation disclaimer and the South Sudan commissioning/disclaimer statements
are retained. Cover photographers, language editors and designers are not
promoted to prose authors.

## Grounding and disposition

Consulted sources and locators travel in IDENTITY_DRAFT.json, bound to
BROWSER_HEADER_OBSERVATIONS.json, SUPPLEMENTAL_BROWSER_OBSERVATIONS.json,
PDF_METADATA_OBSERVATIONS.json and the thirteen files recorded in
PDF_DOWNLOADS.json. The source observations were read during this work, not
supplied from model memory. Rendered pages were used to resolve layout and
hidden-text ambiguity. The original selection and source-occurrence inventory
remain the identity and citation-history authorities.

The proposed typed metadata may proceed to Tells and Calibration with the six
field exceptions and access limitations preserved. No requested field has been
filled by guessing. The Iraq source’s 2013 date versus its inherited 2006–2008
topic label warrants a separate passage follow-up; a date difference alone is
not a finding that the historical citation fails.

The original inherited labels are often topical descriptions or mixed-source
notes. Replacing them wholesale would be wrong. The revision is the separate
typed candidate metadata in IDENTITY_DRAFT.json, with exact titles and credits
where observed. Its metadata access date is 2026-09-09. These findings and the
following audit are companion apparatus for the eventual downloadable result.

## Required self-audit

| Required check | Disposition | Evidence or reason |
|---|---|---|
| Grounding | Pass with limits | Source headers and PDF pages were actually read; six unavailable fields remain unresolved. |
| Required vs. offered | Pass | Typed identities add precision; faithful inherited topic labels are preserved rather than called factual errors. |
| Claims | Pass | No historical claim is weakened, strengthened or silently reclassified. |
| Deletions | Pass | Missing-link records and unresolved fields remain visible. |
| Criticisms | Pass | No external reviewer criticism or replacement prose was adopted. |
| Internal consistency | Pass | Source identity, access identity, publication date and topic date remain distinct throughout. |
| Register discipline | Pass | Source advocacy titles stay attributed; metadata notes make no historical advocacy claims. |
| Moral framework register | Pass | No new normative argument is introduced. |
| Political-spectrum contamination | Pass | No ideological spectrum label is added in analytical voice. |
| Attribution posture | Pass | Host, printed author, corporate byline and quoted spokesperson are distinguished. |
| Quotations | Pass | Source strings are transcribed as supplied; normalized title assembly is not presented as a verbatim body quotation. |
| Causal reasoning | Pass | No new causal explanation is inferred from the metadata. |
| Categorical vs. dimensional | Pass | Metadata status is bounded to identity; no binary claim about complex historical motives is added. |
| Denotation/connotation and convenient layer | Pass | Hosting is not treated as endorsement, and an accessible match is not called recovery of a lost original. |
| Proper-name variants | Pass | Printed full names, initials and institutional credits remain as supplied; no expansion from memory. |
| Engagement posture | Pass | Historical ideas remain intact while bibliographic uncertainty is recorded separately. |
| Confidence calibration | Finding retained | Six metadata fields are unresolved; exact-match alternatives do not prove original-page bytes. |
| Fetched-source disclosures | Pass with limits | Relevant Morris, PDES and South Sudan disclosures were read; metadata pages are not claimed as a full historical review. |
| Citation resolution | Pass at candidate scope | Each candidate retains its selected ID and original URL; source bindings identify its exact header or PDF object. |
| Adopted reviewer text | Pass | No reviewer-authored replacement text is present. |
| Editorial synthesis (SYNTH) | Pass | No cross-source historical conclusion is introduced; matching titles and file metadata are bounded editorial identity judgments. |


# UNHCR metadata — LLM Artifact Tells v2.7

Main-agent second round, 2026-09-09, after the Fact-Check findings. The venue and
model-assisted provenance remain as stated in ROUND_1_FACT_CHECK.md. This pass
reviews the proposed typed fields, source links and metadata notes. It does not
edit the preserved historical source labels or the source documents.

## Findings

| Instance | Tell | Tier | Disposition |
|---|---|---|---|
| No additional mandatory defect found in the revised candidates | — | 1–5 inspected | Keep the grounded candidate text and its six unresolved fields. |

Tier 1 searches found no tracking tags, backend citation tokens, placeholder
text, leaked writing blocks or wrong-host source URLs in the proposed output.
No DOI or ISBN was added; there is therefore no new identifier checksum or
resolution claim. Access dates are the actual 2026-09-09 inspection date.
TELLS_MECHANICAL_CHECKS.json records the executed search and its input hash.

The original generic source labels are not fabricated publication titles in
the new fields: the typed titles come from source headings and title pages,
with magazine and chapter containers separated. Bibliographic title assembly
uses ordinary punctuation and retains the displayed strings separately where
needed. It is not presented as a verbatim quotation of historical prose.

Tiers 2 and 3 show no new significance claim, manufactured consensus or causal
join. Discussion of source limits belongs in this metadata apparatus. It is not
a research log inserted into a historical case narrative. Source titles using
words such as emergency or neglected remain attributed titles. They are not
the reviewing model’s own rhetoric.

For Tiers 4 and 5, lists and tables serve the reference-record format. Proper
names, institutional acronyms, supplied spelling and exact source-title wording
were retained. No discretionary style rewrite would improve these records
enough to justify changing source strings.

## Revised artifact

REVISED_IDENTITY_CANDIDATES.json is the resulting candidate text, unchanged
from the fact-checked draft. No replacement historical prose is composed.
The eventual publication carries the main review, exceptions and method notes
as accompanying apparatus. Cleaning the text makes no claim of human authorship.

## Required self-audit

| Required check | Disposition | Evidence or reason |
|---|---|---|
| Checklist vs. heuristic | Pass | Style cues were evaluated in the reference-record genre, not counted as automatic defects. |
| False positives | Pass | Source titles, proper names, necessary date distinctions and reference tables were retained. |
| Hard artifacts | Pass | The required token, tracking, placeholder, wrong-host and date searches ran; no new DOI/ISBN fields exist. |
| Tier coverage | Pass | Tiers 1–5 were considered in order; the prose findings above cover each group. |
| Decay weighting | Pass | Mechanical artifacts received priority; vocabulary was not treated as proof of authorship or defect. |
| Guideline vs. style sort | Pass | No new mandatory source-integrity defect remains; discretionary source-string normalization was declined. |
| Introduced tells | Pass | The revised artifact is byte-identical to the fact-checked candidate; no new prose was added. |
| Writer’s voice | Pass | Existing historical prose is outside this metadata pass. |
| Register homogenization | Pass | Source-title language remains attributed and the metadata apparatus remains descriptive. |
| Quality tradeoffs | Pass | Accurate titles and names were not rewritten to satisfy stylistic preferences. |
| Editorial synthesis (SYNTH) | Pass | No historical or causal connecting sentence was introduced. |
| Venue check | Pass | Craig’s own site and bibliography permit the authorized model-assisted composition. |
| Provenance honesty | Pass | The packet identifies main-agent review, actual source methods, missing originals and unresolved fields. |


# UNHCR metadata — Calibration Review v1.2

Main-agent final editorial round, 2026-09-09. The substantive scope is the complete proposed metadata in DECISIONS.json. This is not an independent historical review.

## Audit table

All 46 records are covered without sampling, including their typed fields, attribution roles, date precision and source limits. The six unavailable field values and two unmerged relations have separate rows. CALIBRATION.json binds every identity row to its full audited fields and source bindings; the compact claim label below identifies that complete record. PDF excerpts preserve the extracted source characters; line breaks are displayed as breaks. Browser excerpts are explicitly recorded source-header transcriptions.

| Claim / record | Load-bearing wording | Source and locator | Verbatim grounding | What the source licenses | Materiality | Verdict | Calibrated wording |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| I00: Report of the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/in/sites/en-in/files/legacy-pdf/4cc039db9.pdf, PDF page 2 | “REPORT <br>OF THE <br>UNITED NATIONS <br>HIGH COMMISSIONER FOR REFUGEES”<br>“THIRTY-FIFTH SESSION”<br>“SUPPLEMENT No. 12 (A/35/12)”<br>“New York, 1980” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I01: Armed attacks kill hundreds, displace 40,000 civilians in northeast DR Congo | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/africa/news/briefing-notes/armed-attacks-kill-hundreds-displace-40-000-civilians-northeast-dr-congo, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/africa/news/briefing-notes/armed-attacks-kill-hundreds-displace-40-000-civilians-northeast-dr-congo, attribution notice | “Armed attacks kill hundreds, displace 40,000 civilians in northeast DR Congo”<br>“19 March 2021”<br>“Babar Baloch”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I02: Democratic Republic of the Congo. IDPs in Plain Savo | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/spotlight/2023/01/no-escape-for-civilians-trapped-in-eastern-dr-congos-cycle-of-violence/democratic-republic-of-the-congo-idps-in-plain-savo/, source header | “Democratic Republic of the Congo. IDPs in Plain Savo” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| UNHCR-F01: A definite value for attachment_publication_date | definite publication or caption-credit value | Inspected metadata evidence | “UNREACHABLE — no supporting value for this requested field was obtained; source pages/PDFs themselves were inspected.” | Identity fields already recorded; not this missing value. | detail | Uncheckable | Leave unfilled and carry FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json. |
| UNHCR-F02: A definite value for caption_author | definite publication or caption-credit value | Inspected metadata evidence | “UNREACHABLE — no supporting value for this requested field was obtained; source pages/PDFs themselves were inspected.” | Identity fields already recorded; not this missing value. | detail | Uncheckable | Leave unfilled and carry FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json. |
| I03: UNHCR warns of mounting needs in DR Congo as forced displacement continues | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-warns-mounting-needs-dr-congo-forced-displacement-continues, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-warns-mounting-needs-dr-congo-forced-displacement-continues, attribution notice | “UNHCR warns of mounting needs in DR Congo as forced displacement continues”<br>“5 May 2023”<br>“Elizabeth Tan, UNHCR’s Director of International Protection”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I04: 2023: A Moment of Truth for Global Displacement | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/spotlight/2023/01/2023-a-moment-of-truth-for-global-displacement/, source header | “2023: A Moment of Truth for Global Displacement” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I05: UN refugee agency appeals for access to returned Lao Hmong | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/news-releases/un-refugee-agency-appeals-access-returned-lao-hmong, source header | “UN refugee agency appeals for access to returned Lao Hmong”<br>“29 December 2009” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I06: Proxy wars in Africa, Asia and Central America | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/sites/en-us/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9baf0.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/ie/publications/state-worlds-refugees-2000-fifty-years-humanitarian-action, book header/chapter list | “Proxy wars in Africa, <br>Asia and Central America”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I07: Flight from Indochina | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9bad0.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/ie/publications/state-worlds-refugees-2000-fifty-years-humanitarian-action, book header/chapter list | “Flight from Indochina”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I08: Thailand: UNHCR calls for end of three-year detention of Lao Hmong | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, attribution notice | “Thailand: UNHCR calls for end of three-year detention of Lao Hmong”<br>“17 November 2009”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I09: UNHCR alarm at recent attacks and rising displacement in eastern DRC | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/my/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-alarm-recent-attacks-and-rising-displacement-eastern-drc, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/my/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-alarm-recent-attacks-and-rising-displacement-eastern-drc, attribution notice | “UNHCR alarm at recent attacks and rising displacement in eastern DRC”<br>“28 September 2018”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I10: Statement of Prince Sadruddin Aga Khan, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, about refugees from East Pakistan, and complete text of Press Conference questions and answers, 5 May 1971 | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/publications/statement-prince-sadruddin-aga-khan-united-nations-high-commissioner-refugees-about, source header | “Statement of Prince Sadruddin Aga Khan, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, about refugees from East Pakistan, and complete text of Press Conference questions and answers, 5 May 1971”<br>“5 May 1971”<br>“Prince Sadruddin Aga Khan” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I11: Afghanistan 10 years after Soviet pull-out | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/afghanistan-10-years-after-soviet-pull-out, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/afghanistan-10-years-after-soviet-pull-out, attribution notice | “Afghanistan 10 years after Soviet pull-out”<br>“12 February 1999”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I12: UNHCR Archive Gallery Cyprus 1974 | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/africa/publications/unhcr-archive-gallery-cyprus-1974, source header | “UNHCR Archive Gallery Cyprus 1974”<br>“12 June 2009”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I13: UNHCR begins organized repatriation of Kosovar refugees | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/press-releases/unhcr-begins-organized-repatriation-kosovar-refugees, source header | “UNHCR begins organized repatriation of Kosovar refugees”<br>“28 June 1999”<br>“Public Information Section” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I14: Nigeria Situation 2017: Supplementary Appeal | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/legacy-pdf/597704b87.pdf, PDF page 1 | “REVISED, JULY 2017”<br>“Supplementary Appeal”<br>“January – December 2017”<br>“NIGERIA <br>SITUATION  <br>2017” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I15: Money matters: An evaluation of the use of cash grants in UNHCR’s voluntary repatriation and reintegration programme in Burundi | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/sites/en-us/files/legacy-pdf/4a5f436d9.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/us/sites/en-us/files/legacy-pdf/4a5f436d9.pdf, PDF page 2 | “Money matters”<br>“An evaluation of the use of”<br>“cash grants in UNHCR’s”<br>“voluntary repatriation and”<br>“reintegration programme”<br>“in Burundi”<br>“Katherine Haver, Consultant”<br>“Felicien Hatungimana, Consultant”<br>“Vicky Tennant, PDES”<br>“PDES/2009/02”<br>“July 2009”<br>“The views expressed in <br>PDES publications are not necessarily those of UNHCR.” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I16: More than 850,000 people in volatile Central African Republic remain displaced | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/stories/more-850-000-people-volatile-central-african-republic-remain-displaced, source header | “More than 850,000 people in volatile Central African Republic remain displaced”<br>“5 December 2014”<br>“Karin de Gruijl” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I17: UNHCR urges global response to neglected humanitarian crisis in the Sahel | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-urges-global-response-neglected-humanitarian-crisis-sahel, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-urges-global-response-neglected-humanitarian-crisis-sahel, attribution notice | “UNHCR urges global response to neglected humanitarian crisis in the Sahel”<br>“7 June 2024”<br>“Alpha Seydi Ba”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I18: Syria Fact Sheet - Timeline and Figures | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/legacy-pdf/5245a72e6.pdf, PDF page 1 | “FACT SHEET: TIMELINE AND FIGURES”<br>“Chronology of Syria’s Displacement Crisis” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| UNHCR-F03: A definite value for publication_date | definite publication or caption-credit value | Inspected metadata evidence | “UNREACHABLE — no supporting value for this requested field was obtained; source pages/PDFs themselves were inspected.” | Identity fields already recorded; not this missing value. | detail | Uncheckable | Leave unfilled and carry FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json. |
| I19: Colombia | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/where-we-work/countries/colombia, source header | “Colombia” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I20: Culture, context and mental health and psychosocial well-being of refugees and internally displaced persons from South Sudan | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/africa/sites/afr/files/2023-03/63eba35c7.pdf, PDF page 2 | “Tankink, M., Belay, H.T., Mukasa, M.B., Nieuwe Weme, D., Burman, M., Ventevogel, P. (2023).”<br>“Culture, context and mental health and psychosocial well-being of refugees and internally displaced persons from <br>South Sudan.”<br>“Geneva, Switzerland, United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR).”<br>“This document is commissioned by UNHCR”<br>“the views expressed  <br>in this document are those of the authors and not necessarily those of UNHCR” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I21: UNHCR relocation operation for Darfur refugees tops 100,000 | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/press-releases/unhcr-relocation-operation-darfur-refugees-tops-100-000, source header | “UNHCR relocation operation for Darfur refugees tops 100,000”<br>“16 June 2004”<br>“UNHCR” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I22: Displaced in Uganda face psychological barrier to return home | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/uk/news/stories/displaced-uganda-face-psychological-barrier-return-home, source header | “Displaced in Uganda face psychological barrier to return home”<br>“21 May 2007”<br>“Peter-Bastian Halberg” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I23: UNHCR chief says only peace can provide solution for Sri Lanka's displaced | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/unhcr-chief-says-only-peace-can-provide-solution-sri-lankas-displaced, source header | “UNHCR chief says only peace can provide solution for Sri Lanka's displaced”<br>“27 July 2006”<br>“Kitty McKinsey” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I24: Yemen sees fresh displacement after five years of conflict | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/stories/yemen-sees-fresh-displacement-after-five-years-conflict, source header | “Yemen sees fresh displacement after five years of conflict”<br>“27 March 2020”<br>“UNHCR staff in Marib, Yemen” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I25: UNHCR Global Appeal 1999 - Bosnia and Herzegovina | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/uk/publications/unhcr-global-appeal-1999-bosnia-and-herzegovina, source header | “UNHCR Global Appeal 1999 - Bosnia and Herzegovina”<br>“1 December 1998”<br>“Funding and Donor Relations Service” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I26: UNHCR Global Appeal 1999 - Sierra Leone | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/africa/publications/unhcr-global-appeal-1999-sierra-leone, source header | “UNHCR Global Appeal 1999 - Sierra Leone”<br>“1 December 1998”<br>“Funding and Donor Relations Service” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I27: As it happened: Eight accounts of experiences with UNHCR | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/blogs/wp-content/uploads/sites/48/2024/08/AIH-master-8-rfmt.1.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/blogs/wp-content/uploads/sites/48/2024/08/AIH-master-8-rfmt.1.pdf, PDF page 2 | “As it happened:”<br>“Eight accounts of experiences with UNHCR”<br>“Nicholas Morris”<br>“The first six accounts were prepared in 2016 and 2017 and the last two in <br>2023 and 2024.”<br>“The views expressed herein are those of the author and are <br>not necessarily shared by the United Nations or UNHCR.” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| UNHCR-F04: A definite value for publication_date | definite publication or caption-credit value | Inspected metadata evidence | “UNREACHABLE — no supporting value for this requested field was obtained; source pages/PDFs themselves were inspected.” | Identity fields already recorded; not this missing value. | detail | Uncheckable | Leave unfilled and carry FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json. |
| I28: So close, yet so far | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/publications/refugees-magazine-issue-103-idps-so-close-yet-so-far, source header | “Refugees Magazine Issue 103 (IDPs) - So close, yet so far<br>Refugees (103, I - 1996)”<br>“1 March 1996”<br>“Francis Kpatindé” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I29: UNHCR concerned as recent waves of sectarian violence threatens new internal displacement of Iraqis | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-concerned-recent-waves-sectarian-violence-threatens-new-internal, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/unhcr-concerned-recent-waves-sectarian-violence-threatens-new-internal, attribution notice | “UNHCR concerned as recent waves of sectarian violence threatens new internal displacement of Iraqis”<br>“24 September 2013”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I30: Thailand: UNHCR calls for end of three-year detention of Lao Hmong | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, attribution notice | “Thailand: UNHCR calls for end of three-year detention of Lao Hmong”<br>“17 November 2009”<br>“Andrej Mahecic”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I31: Home Sweet Home | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/africa/publications/refugees-magazine-issue-112-going-home-mozambique-revisited-home-sweet-home, source header | “Refugees Magazine Issue 112 (Going Home : Mozambique Revisited) - Home Sweet Home<br>Refugees (112, II - 1998)”<br>“1 June 1998”<br>“Ray Wilkinson” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I32: Two years of political and social crisis in Nicaragua force more than 100,000 to flee | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/two-years-political-and-social-crisis-nicaragua-force-more-100000-flee, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/two-years-political-and-social-crisis-nicaragua-force-more-100000-flee, attribution notice | “Two years of political and social crisis in Nicaragua force more than 100,000 to flee”<br>“10 March 2020”<br>“Shabia Mantoo”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I33: UNHCR begins programme to resolve situation of 1972 Burundian refugees | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/stories/unhcr-begins-programme-resolve-situation-1972-burundian-refugees, source header | “UNHCR begins programme to resolve situation of 1972 Burundian refugees”<br>“11 March 2008”<br>“Eveline Wolfcarius, Millicent Mutuli” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I34: UNHCR Global Appeal 1999 - Regional Overview: Central America | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/in/publications/unhcr-global-appeal-1999-regional-overview-central-america, source header | “UNHCR Global Appeal 1999 - Regional Overview: Central America”<br>“1 December 1998”<br>“Funding and Donor Relations Service” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I35: UNHCR helps returnees rebuild their lives as stability returns to Chechnya | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/uk/news/stories/unhcr-helps-returnees-rebuild-their-lives-stability-returns-chechnya, source header | “UNHCR helps returnees rebuild their lives as stability returns to Chechnya”<br>“5 September 2007”<br>“William Spindler” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I36: Cautious return for Nepal's displaced people | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/uk/news/stories/cautious-return-nepals-displaced-people, source header | “Cautious return for Nepal's displaced people”<br>“28 December 2007”<br>“Nini Gurung” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I37: Rohingya emergency | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/emergencies/rohingya-emergency, source header | “Rohingya emergency” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I38: 70 years of protecting people forced to flee | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/spotlight/2020/12/70-years-of-protecting-people-forced-to-flee/, source header | “70 years of protecting people forced to flee”<br>“14 December 2020” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I39: Somali refugee displacements in the near region: Analysis and Recommendations | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/legacy-pdf/55152c699.pdf, PDF page 1 | “Somali refugee displacements in the near region: Analysis and Recommendations”<br>“Paper for the UNHCR Global Initiative on Somali Refugees”<br>“By Laura Hammond”<br>“to be convened by UNHCR in August 2014.” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| UNHCR-F05: A definite value for publication_date | definite publication or caption-credit value | Inspected metadata evidence | “UNREACHABLE — no supporting value for this requested field was obtained; source pages/PDFs themselves were inspected.” | Identity fields already recorded; not this missing value. | detail | Uncheckable | Leave unfilled and carry FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json. |
| I40: Rupture in South Asia | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/in/sites/en-in/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9bab0.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/ie/publications/state-worlds-refugees-2000-fifty-years-humanitarian-action, book header/chapter list | “Rupture in South Asia”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I41: Democratic Republic of the Congo, Rwanda and UNHCR discuss returns | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/democratic-republic-congo-rwanda-and-unhcr-discuss-returns, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/democratic-republic-congo-rwanda-and-unhcr-discuss-returns, attribution notice | “Democratic Republic of the Congo, Rwanda and UNHCR discuss returns”<br>“17 April 2009”<br>“Ron Redmond”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I42: Sudan Situation: UNHCR Appeal 2026 | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/2026-02/UNHCR%20Sudan%20Situation%20Appeal%202026.pdf, PDF page 1 | “SUDAN SITUATION”<br>“UNHCR APPEAL 2026” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| UNHCR-F06: A definite value for exact_publication_date | definite publication or caption-credit value | Inspected metadata evidence | “UNREACHABLE — no supporting value for this requested field was obtained; source pages/PDFs themselves were inspected.” | Identity fields already recorded; not this missing value. | detail | Uncheckable | Leave unfilled and carry FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json. |
| I43: Cameroon Situation: Responding to the needs of IDPs and Cameroonian refugees in Nigeria | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/2021-12/UNHCR%2520Cameroon%25202019%2520Supplementary%2520Appeal%2520%2528March%25202019%2529.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/2021-12/UNHCR%2520Cameroon%25202019%2520Supplementary%2520Appeal%2520%2528March%25202019%2529.pdf, PDF page 24 | “January - December 2019”<br>“Supplementary Appeal”<br>“RESPONDING TO THE NEEDS OF IDPs AND CAMEROONIAN REFUGEES IN NIGERIA”<br>“CAMEROON SITUATION”<br>“Published in March 2019” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I44: Update on voluntary repatriation movements | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/publications/update-voluntary-repatriation-movements, source header | “Update on voluntary repatriation movements<br>EC/1995/SC.2/CRP.12”<br>“20 March 1995”<br>“UNHCR” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| I45: The Rwandan genocide and its aftermath | as supplied / as reported / displayed; identity only | https://www.unhcr.org/africa/sites/afr/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9bb60.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/ie/publications/state-worlds-refugees-2000-fifty-years-humanitarian-action, book header/chapter list | “The Rwandan genocide <br>and its aftermath”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)” | These bounded source metadata fields, with the recorded access, credit, component and date limits. No historical support or original-page-byte equivalence is asserted. | detail | Matched | Retain reviewed fields and explicit limits. |
| R1: same_displayed_article_title_and_date_on_distinct_regional_access_routes | same displayed title/date or shared container; unmerged | https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/us/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, attribution notice<br>https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, source header<br>https://www.unhcr.org/news/briefing-notes/thailand-unhcr-calls-end-three-year-detention-lao-hmong, attribution notice | “Thailand: UNHCR calls for end of three-year detention of Lao Hmong”<br>“17 November 2009”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed”<br>“Thailand: UNHCR calls for end of three-year detention of Lao Hmong”<br>“17 November 2009”<br>“Andrej Mahecic”<br>“to whom quoted text may be attributed” | same_displayed_article_title_and_date_on_distinct_regional_access_routes; US route lacks a named spokesperson; global route names Andrej Mahecic. No collapse of IDs or occurrences. | detail | Matched | Retain unmerged relation and its limits. |
| R2: distinct_chapters_of_shared_book_container | same displayed title/date or shared container; unmerged | https://www.unhcr.org/us/sites/en-us/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9baf0.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/ie/publications/state-worlds-refugees-2000-fifty-years-humanitarian-action, book header/chapter list<br>https://www.unhcr.org/sites/default/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9bad0.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/in/sites/en-in/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9bab0.pdf, PDF page 1<br>https://www.unhcr.org/africa/sites/afr/files/legacy-pdf/3ebf9bb60.pdf, PDF page 1 | “Proxy wars in Africa, <br>Asia and Central America”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)”<br>“Flight from Indochina”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)”<br>“Rupture in South Asia”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)”<br>“The Rwandan genocide <br>and its aftermath”<br>“The State of The World's Refugees 2000: Fifty Years of Humanitarian Action”<br>“1 January 2000”<br>“United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR)” | distinct_chapters_of_shared_book_container; Four distinct chapters remain four work/access records. No original imprint or first-publication day inferred. | detail | Matched | Retain unmerged relation and its limits. |

## Coverage and concentration

The 54 claim groups comprise 48 Matched and six Uncheckable verdicts. Gaps concern unavailable publication dates and caption credit, not silently rejected source identities. The three accessible exact-title matches are accepted only at the stated work/component level; no claim of original-page redirection or byte identity is made. Website dates remain displayed dates where the source provides no stronger publication statement.

Historical event claims, causal explanations, scores, geometry, case classification and source-occurrence passage support were not audited in this metadata round. The Iraq period mismatch remains a separate passage follow-up. New institutional endorsement or modern legal refugee-status claims were neither made nor accepted. Private captures preserve the downloaded PDFs and observed metadata records; there is no claim of complete raw HTML or public archive snapshots.

## Reverse check

Actively checked for underclaims in titles, author names, report numbers and date fields. None found: the printed Nicholas Morris, Katherine Haver, Felicien Hatungimana, Vicky Tennant and Laura Hammond credits are retained without unwarranted hedging. Dates that actually appear on sources remain usable at their displayed precision. Missing precision is left unfilled.

## Required self-audit

| Required check | Disposition | Evidence or reason |
|---|---|---|
| Direction of changes | Pass | 48 claims match the evidence; six missing values stay unresolved. No blanket downward adjustment. |
| Lane discipline | Pass | No stylistic rewrite or historical adjudication was performed. |
| Deletion vs. flagging | Pass | No source or historical claim was deleted; missing values and the Iraq passage question remain explicit. |
| Mandatory re-cite flags in deliverable | Pass | No Unsupported-but-sound verdict was assigned; all six Uncheckable values travel in FIELD_EXCEPTIONS.json. |
| Grounding passages | Pass | Every Matched row has observed header strings or exact PDF spans with locators; the extraction script checks each PDF quotation. |
| Coverage and skips | Pass | All 46 metadata records, six field claims and two relations are covered; excluded historical and passage work is stated above. |