{ "atlas_edited": false, "cases": [ { "case_id": "thule-expansion", "event_id": "atlas-thule-expansion", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.7746392465, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.8384210079, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.1659313728, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.617430903, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.617430903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 77.145533792, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 77.145533792, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 77.145533792, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.1213504695, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.8987147883, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.0337617372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 92.6045051906, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 92.6045051906, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 92.6045051906, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "teutonic-prussia", "event_id": "atlas-teutonic-prussia", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 57.6603274638, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 57.6603274638, "label": "Government direction", "low": 57.6603274638, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 71.4337234094, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 71.4337234094, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 71.4337234094, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 76.5605102784, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 76.5605102784, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 76.5605102784, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 33.0422437836, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 33.0422437836, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 33.0422437836, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.59729241, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 71.59729241, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 71.59729241, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.4600076947, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.4600076947, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.4600076947, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "medieval-valencia", "event_id": "atlas-medieval-valencia", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 67.0986315435, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 67.0986315435, "label": "Government direction", "low": 67.0986315435, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.4395292349, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.4395292349, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.4395292349, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.6850036836, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.6850036836, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.6850036836, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 27.6865525903, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 27.6865525903, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 27.6865525903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 49.3470884904, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 49.3470884904, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 49.3470884904, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 83.9804700813, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 83.9804700813, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 83.9804700813, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "nam-tien", "event_id": "atlas-nam-tien", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 67.1897874569, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 67.1897874569, "label": "Government direction", "low": 67.1897874569, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.1645223457, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.1645223457, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.1645223457, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 78.6568184132, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 78.6568184132, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 78.6568184132, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 41.5596302734, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 41.5596302734, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 41.5596302734, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 64.521179368, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 64.521179368, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 64.521179368, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "inca-mitma", "event_id": "atlas-inca-mitma", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.2328047654, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.2328047654, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.2328047654, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 44.1199038964, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 44.1199038964, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 44.1199038964, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.0808025937, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.0808025937, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.0808025937, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 25.7366693461, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 25.7366693461, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 25.7366693461, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 59.0033599451, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.0033599451, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 59.0033599451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 50.0616955437, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 50.0616955437, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 50.0616955437, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "plantations-ireland", "event_id": "atlas-plantations-ireland", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 66.6345618996, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 66.6345618996, "label": "Government direction", "low": 66.6345618996, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.9087424438, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 88.9087424438, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 88.9087424438, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 76.5605102784, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 76.5605102784, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 76.5605102784, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 27.3807855711, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 27.3807855711, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 27.3807855711, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3881871599, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 79.3881871599, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 79.3881871599, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 59.7271937107, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7271937107, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 59.7271937107, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "bashkir-lands", "event_id": "atlas-bashkir-lands", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 65.4681643011, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 65.4681643011, "label": "Government direction", "low": 65.4681643011, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 74.1946377483, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 74.1946377483, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 74.1946377483, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 72.9213670422, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.9213670422, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 72.9213670422, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 46.0641628893, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 46.0641628893, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 46.0641628893, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 72.1111984691, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 72.1111984691, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 72.1111984691, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.683089487, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.683089487, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.683089487, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "circassia", "event_id": "atlas-circassia", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 93.4695480305, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 93.4695480305, "label": "Government direction", "low": 93.4695480305, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 80.5753452051, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 80.5753452051, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 80.5753452051, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 84.5953809049, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 84.5953809049, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 84.5953809049, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 91.9206273087, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 91.9206273087, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 91.9206273087, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.4125757097, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 83.4125757097, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 83.4125757097, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.7718019481, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.7718019481, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.7718019481, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "kazakh-steppe", "event_id": "atlas-kazakh-steppe", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.823999605, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 82.823999605, "label": "Government direction", "low": 82.823999605, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 85.3283227641, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 85.3283227641, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 85.3283227641, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.0113879791, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 86.0113879791, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 86.0113879791, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 56.238335667, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 56.238335667, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 56.238335667, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 77.7650975956, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 77.7650975956, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 77.7650975956, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 34.9645925087, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 34.9645925087, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 34.9645925087, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "russian-far-east", "event_id": "atlas-russian-far-east", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.505532165, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.505532165, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.505532165, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.6746703471, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.6746703471, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.6746703471, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.8331220265, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.8331220265, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.8331220265, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 57.4314244701, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 57.4314244701, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 57.4314244701, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8377125375, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 67.9566849716, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 61.7490325197, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 51.7279387181, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.0598693707, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.0598693707, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.0598693707, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "sapmi", "event_id": "atlas-sapmi", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 72.1994738538, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 72.1994738538, "label": "Government direction", "low": 72.1994738538, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 90.6917653512, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 90.6917653512, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 90.6917653512, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.4496912134, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.4496912134, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.4496912134, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 44.3723764568, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 44.3723764568, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 44.3723764568, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 40.7164818902, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 40.7164818902, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 40.7164818902, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 73.2719000416, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 73.2719000416, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 73.2719000416, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "han-taiwan", "event_id": "atlas-han-taiwan", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 46.1428266783, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 46.1428266783, "label": "Government direction", "low": 46.1428266783, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 76.6994214139, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 76.6994214139, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 76.6994214139, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 67.8957776618, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 67.8957776618, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 67.8957776618, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 42.4224932125, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 42.4224932125, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 42.4224932125, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 55.4146119649, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 55.4146119649, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 55.4146119649, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.9367473479, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 80.9367473479, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 80.9367473479, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "dzungaria", "event_id": "atlas-dzungaria", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 91.9172551937, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.9172551937, "label": "Government direction", "low": 91.9172551937, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.0004042369, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.0004042369, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.0004042369, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.9105684971, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 81.9105684971, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 81.9105684971, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 91.9206273087, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 91.9206273087, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 91.9206273087, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 86.6248556175, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 86.6248556175, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 86.6248556175, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 87.6222089363, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 87.6222089363, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 87.6222089363, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 62.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "inner-mongolia-han", "event_id": "atlas-inner-mongolia-han", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.8803607608, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.8803607608, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.8803607608, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 81.0255716969, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 81.0255716969, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 81.0255716969, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.52934342, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.52934342, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.52934342, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 40.9045705806, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 40.9045705806, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 40.9045705806, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 45.8959876776, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 45.8959876776, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 45.8959876776, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 65.690936805, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.690936805, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 65.690936805, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "tibet-han-migration", "event_id": "atlas-tibet-han-migration", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.082944913, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.082944913, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.082944913, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.474259105, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.474259105, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.474259105, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.1760993474, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.1760993474, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.1760993474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 30.0084225065, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 30.0084225065, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 30.0084225065, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 52.1874967985, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 52.1874967985, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 52.1874967985, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 78.1520356242, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 78.1520356242, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 78.1520356242, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "hokkaido", "event_id": "atlas-hokkaido", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.3718705219, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.3718705219, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.3718705219, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 96.2459318536, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 96.2459318536, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 96.2459318536, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 79.9137880941, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 79.9137880941, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 79.9137880941, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 58.8509349922, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 58.8509349922, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 58.8509349922, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 56.0602104355, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 56.0602104355, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 56.0602104355, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.3107031289, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.3107031289, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.3107031289, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "japanese-korea", "event_id": "atlas-japanese-korea", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 75.4135354623, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 75.4135354623, "label": "Government direction", "low": 75.4135354623, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.6404712459, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.6404712459, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.6404712459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 50.3831928042, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 50.3831928042, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 50.3831928042, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 9.8598802487, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 9.8598802487, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 9.8598802487, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 42.9464171557, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.9464171557, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 42.9464171557, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 17.1647624632, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 17.1647624632, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 17.1647624632, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "japanese-micronesia", "event_id": "atlas-japanese-micronesia", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.8910451418, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.8910451418, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.8910451418, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 72.1582753101, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 72.1582753101, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 72.1582753101, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 68.2265470348, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.2265470348, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 68.2265470348, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 35.8361741337, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 35.8361741337, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 35.8361741337, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 48.3236636643, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 48.3236636643, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 48.3236636643, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 9.7692676538, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 9.7692676538, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.7692676538, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "andaman-islands", "event_id": "atlas-andaman-islands", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 78.4841930205, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.4841930205, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.4841930205, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 76.8212770586, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 76.8212770586, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 76.8212770586, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 87.0652465393, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 87.0652465393, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 87.0652465393, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 72.6232436283, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 72.6232436283, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 72.6232436283, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 81.3759938733, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 81.3759938733, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 81.3759938733, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 84.7639546301, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 84.7639546301, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 84.7639546301, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mindanao", "event_id": "atlas-mindanao", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.4068071394, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 64.4068071394, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.4068071394, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 90.917900617, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 90.917900617, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 90.917900617, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.0602767477, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.0602767477, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.0602767477, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 53.8555261092, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 53.8555261092, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.8555261092, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 42.3615876761, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.3615876761, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 42.3615876761, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.5181440872, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 69.5181440872, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 69.5181440872, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "vietnam-central-highlands", "event_id": "atlas-vietnam-central-highlands", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.3373995173, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.3373995173, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.3373995173, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 82.2913072247, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 82.2913072247, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 82.2913072247, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 84.8977711154, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 84.8977711154, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 84.8977711154, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 53.8555261092, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 53.8555261092, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.8555261092, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 52.0030238721, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 52.0030238721, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 52.0030238721, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.5181440872, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 69.5181440872, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 69.5181440872, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "chittagong-hill-tracts", "event_id": "atlas-chittagong-hill-tracts", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.2275089271, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 89.2275089271, "label": "Government direction", "low": 89.2275089271, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 75.3126311677, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 75.3126311677, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 75.3126311677, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 82.2959616495, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 82.2959616495, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 82.2959616495, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 54.6474254712, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 54.6474254712, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 54.6474254712, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 65.0560481609, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 65.0560481609, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 65.0560481609, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 56.3818030991, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 56.3818030991, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 56.3818030991, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "sri-lanka-irrigation", "event_id": "atlas-sri-lanka-irrigation", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.0794024008, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.0794024008, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.0794024008, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.2625214825, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.2625214825, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.2625214825, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 78.5572906814, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 78.5572906814, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 78.5572906814, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 44.114279645, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 44.114279645, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 44.114279645, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 34.9872720512, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 34.9872720512, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 34.9872720512, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 75.0367609194, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.0367609194, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 75.0367609194, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "west-papua", "event_id": "atlas-west-papua", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 87.7093752032, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 87.7093752032, "label": "Government direction", "low": 87.7093752032, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 80.5604707651, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 80.5604707651, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 80.5604707651, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 77.9329592872, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 77.9329592872, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 77.9329592872, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 47.7919127543, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 47.7919127543, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 47.7919127543, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 45.250389207, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 45.250389207, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 45.250389207, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 71.9214862146, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 71.9214862146, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 71.9214862146, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "namibia", "event_id": "atlas-namibia", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 74.8882719288, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 74.8882719288, "label": "Government direction", "low": 74.8882719288, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 95.1994029273, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 95.1994029273, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 95.1994029273, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 67.6435733578, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 67.6435733578, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 67.6435733578, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 33.0261666621, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 33.0261666621, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 33.0261666621, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.6879969367, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 90.6879969367, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 90.6879969367, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 51.9332604972, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 51.9332604972, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 51.9332604972, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "southern-rhodesia", "event_id": "atlas-southern-rhodesia", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 57.1772206045, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 57.1772206045, "label": "Government direction", "low": 57.1772206045, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.6404712459, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.6404712459, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.6404712459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.6525536921, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.6525536921, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.6525536921, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 19.1691661006, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 19.1691661006, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 19.1691661006, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 61.5143351205, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 61.5143351205, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 61.5143351205, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 29.3222027931, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 29.3222027931, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 29.3222027931, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "kenya-highlands", "event_id": "atlas-kenya-highlands", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 70.2180573435, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 70.2180573435, "label": "Government direction", "low": 70.2180573435, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 91.2880677856, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 91.2880677856, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 91.2880677856, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.6525536921, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.6525536921, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.6525536921, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 26.0976663813, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 26.0976663813, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 26.0976663813, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.6785578783, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 71.6785578783, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 71.6785578783, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 32.3856383817, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 32.3856383817, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 32.3856383817, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "liberia", "event_id": "atlas-liberia", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 43.9544904284, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 43.9544904284, "label": "Government direction", "low": 43.9544904284, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 74.3824293041, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 74.3824293041, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 74.3824293041, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 68.2679047521, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.2679047521, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 68.2679047521, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 12.601662855, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 12.601662855, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 12.601662855, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 46.494084952, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 46.494084952, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 46.494084952, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 34.0573350764, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 34.0573350764, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 34.0573350764, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "argentina-frontiers", "event_id": "atlas-argentina-frontiers", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.4789082022, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.4789082022, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.4789082022, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 87.5376397906, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 87.5376397906, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 87.5376397906, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.6806443325, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.6806443325, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.6806443325, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 58.9482888166, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 58.9482888166, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 58.9482888166, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.5990848913, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 80.5990848913, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 80.5990848913, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 75.9347382383, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.9347382383, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 75.9347382383, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "chile-araucania", "event_id": "atlas-chile-araucania", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 74.0290633814, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 74.0290633814, "label": "Government direction", "low": 74.0290633814, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.9087424438, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 88.9087424438, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 88.9087424438, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 73.3812250771, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 73.3812250771, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 73.3812250771, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 51.9786304287, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 51.9786304287, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 51.9786304287, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.9267255427, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 71.9267255427, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 71.9267255427, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 66.8827161856, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 66.8827161856, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 66.8827161856, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "uruguay", "event_id": "atlas-uruguay", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 57.0363482578, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 57.0363482578, "label": "Government direction", "low": 57.0363482578, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.0765172468, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.0765172468, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.0765172468, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 72.6064174589, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.6064174589, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 72.6064174589, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.517922632, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 76.517922632, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 76.517922632, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 70.2987824298, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 70.2987824298, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 70.2987824298, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 84.5686297752, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 84.5686297752, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 84.5686297752, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mennonite-chaco", "event_id": "atlas-mennonite-chaco", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 46.1017999025, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 46.1017999025, "label": "Government direction", "low": 46.1017999025, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 72.2392249155, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 72.2392249155, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 72.2392249155, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.1861750029, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.1861750029, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.1861750029, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 45.7497026784, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 45.7497026784, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 45.7497026784, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 58.4698405789, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 58.4698405789, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 58.4698405789, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.0957447861, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 62.0957447861, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 62.0957447861, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "bolivian-lowlands", "event_id": "atlas-bolivian-lowlands", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.6159370661, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.6159370661, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.6159370661, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.4102630409, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.4102630409, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.4102630409, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.2207862976, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.2207862976, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.2207862976, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 50.070963577, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 50.070963577, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 50.070963577, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 47.0716857491, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 47.0716857491, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 47.0716857491, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 60.7237187474, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 60.7237187474, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 60.7237187474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "new-caledonia", "event_id": "atlas-new-caledonia", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 78.1685632339, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.1685632339, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.1685632339, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 92.3408672696, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 92.3408672696, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 92.3408672696, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 60.0608298221, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 60.0608298221, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 60.0608298221, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 44.0104304101, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 44.0104304101, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 44.0104304101, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 84.0654872193, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 84.0654872193, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 84.0654872193, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 59.6528399568, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.6528399568, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 59.6528399568, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 62.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "hawaii", "event_id": "atlas-hawaii", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 46.1428266783, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 46.1428266783, "label": "Government direction", "low": 46.1428266783, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.2621542189, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 88.2621542189, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 88.2621542189, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 77.5907809284, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 77.5907809284, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 77.5907809284, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 64.1058571385, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 64.1058571385, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 64.1058571385, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 77.3128525541, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 77.3128525541, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 77.3128525541, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 68.0844225047, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 68.0844225047, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 68.0844225047, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 87.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "guam", "event_id": "atlas-guam", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.4244305762, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.4244305762, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.4244305762, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 83.9769438683, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 83.9769438683, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 83.9769438683, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 68.2265470348, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.2265470348, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 68.2265470348, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 47.3489625053, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 47.3489625053, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 47.3489625053, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 84.0654872193, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 84.0654872193, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 84.0654872193, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 75.1854684273, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.1854684273, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 75.1854684273, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "rapa-nui", "event_id": "atlas-rapa-nui", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.1682116001, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.1682116001, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.1682116001, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 65.5742970112, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 65.5742970112, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 65.5742970112, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 57.0986528768, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 57.0986528768, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 57.0986528768, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 17.2933287056, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 17.2933287056, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 17.2933287056, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 44.435354818, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 44.435354818, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 44.435354818, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.5966578726, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 72.5966578726, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 72.5966578726, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "vanuatu", "event_id": "atlas-vanuatu", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 48.9949042684, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 48.9949042684, "label": "Government direction", "low": 48.9949042684, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.1149180356, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.1149180356, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.1149180356, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 55.7288030424, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 55.7288030424, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 55.7288030424, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 31.7591245939, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.7591245939, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 31.7591245939, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 72.4905922884, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 72.4905922884, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 72.4905922884, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 24.5549442488, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 24.5549442488, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 24.5549442488, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 75.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "banaba-ocean-island", "event_id": "atlas-banaba-ocean-island", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.4633058339, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.4633058339, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.4633058339, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.3620391795, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.3620391795, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.3620391795, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 48.4206930635, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 48.4206930635, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 48.4206930635, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 92.2816243439, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 92.2816243439, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 92.2816243439, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 39.2083507071, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 39.2083507071, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 39.2083507071, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 42.1957252993, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 42.1957252993, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 42.1957252993, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 87.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "posen-west-prussia", "event_id": "atlas-posen-west-prussia", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.465308659, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.465308659, "label": "Government direction", "low": 81.465308659, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 83.1575477633, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 83.1575477633, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 83.1575477633, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 72.1212248228, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.1212248228, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 72.1212248228, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 17.6871021247, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 17.6871021247, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 17.6871021247, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 16.039960267, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 16.039960267, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.039960267, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 22.3423835725, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 22.3423835725, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 22.3423835725, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "generalplan-ost", "event_id": "atlas-generalplan-ost", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 96.0469607786, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.0469607786, "label": "Government direction", "low": 96.0469607786, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 70.959828463, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 70.959828463, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 70.959828463, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.0382008742, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.0382008742, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.0382008742, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.2157816351, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.2157816351, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 60.2157816351, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 88.4447938764, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 88.4447938764, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 88.4447938764, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "french-algeria", "event_id": "atlas-french-algeria", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 70.2180573435, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 70.2180573435, "label": "Government direction", "low": 70.2180573435, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.6404712459, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.6404712459, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.6404712459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 65.6063369827, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 65.6063369827, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 65.6063369827, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 23.1231043196, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 23.1231043196, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 23.1231043196, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 81.1766856884, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 81.1766856884, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 81.1766856884, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 22.8688477226, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 22.8688477226, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 22.8688477226, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "italian-libya", "event_id": "atlas-italian-libya", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.3106672793, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 89.3106672793, "label": "Government direction", "low": 89.3106672793, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 67.0982272685, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 67.0982272685, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 67.0982272685, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 68.092022407, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.092022407, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 68.092022407, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 45.3401636062, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 45.3401636062, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 45.3401636062, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 82.9358549562, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 82.9358549562, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 82.9358549562, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 14.7614203358, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 14.7614203358, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 14.7614203358, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "western-sahara", "event_id": "atlas-western-sahara", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.3106672793, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 89.3106672793, "label": "Government direction", "low": 89.3106672793, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 78.7085795871, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 78.7085795871, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 78.7085795871, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 76.5999782649, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 76.5999782649, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 76.5999782649, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 66.1946040388, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 66.1946040388, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 66.1946040388, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 59.2784450991, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.2784450991, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 59.2784450991, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.7565408148, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.7565408148, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.7565408148, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "northern-cyprus", "event_id": "atlas-northern-cyprus", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.3448357453, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.3448357453, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.3448357453, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.830716, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.830716, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.830716, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 73.6884065398, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 73.6884065398, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 73.6884065398, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 77.5734652049, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 77.5734652049, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 77.5734652049, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 61.5216481594, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 61.5216481594, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 61.5216481594, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.5244550405, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.5244550405, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.5244550405, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "iraqi-kurdistan-kirkuk", "event_id": "atlas-iraqi-kurdistan-kirkuk", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 91.8390807881, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.8390807881, "label": "Government direction", "low": 91.8390807881, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 82.9900818974, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 82.9900818974, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 82.9900818974, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 69.4482480677, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.4482480677, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 69.4482480677, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 62.1878033511, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 62.1878033511, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 62.1878033511, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 75.7357444417, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.7357444417, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 75.7357444417, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 57.1285267285, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 57.1285267285, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.1285267285, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "syrian-arab-belt", "event_id": "atlas-syrian-arab-belt", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 94.4456687025, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 94.4456687025, "label": "Government direction", "low": 94.4456687025, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 71.2224625836, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 71.2224625836, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 71.2224625836, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.5268680354, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.5268680354, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.5268680354, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 44.1514085527, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 44.1514085527, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 44.1514085527, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.2919566679, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 22.2919566679, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 22.2919566679, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 49.5475634918, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 49.5475634918, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 49.5475634918, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "jomon-yayoi", "event_id": "atlas-jomon-yayoi", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 19.6404858288, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 13.0226319799, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 12.0317779551, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8921511443, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 84.6108084497, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 82.7504659392, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 73.8259228757, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7495305509, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 52.1342777672, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 36.1390644154, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 27.0873328621, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3862508582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.8734974809, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.4816568979, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.4985832995, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "anglo-saxon-britain", "event_id": "atlas-anglo-saxon-britain", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 8.2576331579, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 8.2576331579, "label": "Government direction", "low": 8.2576331579, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 17.4740606604, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 10.6777950169, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 9.8653527867, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 71.7630948679, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.7630948679, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 71.7630948679, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 44.2284253159, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 44.2284253159, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 44.2284253159, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5018029194, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 75.0958944191, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.3707439374, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 25.2761863613, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 95.007847318, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 95.007847318, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 95.007847318, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "numic-spread", "event_id": "atlas-numic-spread", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.4649024872, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.5031764712, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.8561946135, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.617430903, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.617430903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.3401378308, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 68.3401378308, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 68.3401378308, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.1213504695, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.9324765255, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 6.0675234745, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 95.007847318, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 95.007847318, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 95.007847318, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "kayenta-salado", "event_id": "atlas-kayenta-salado", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 2.3517471453, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 2.3517471453, "label": "Government direction", "low": 2.3517471453, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 13.4789153981, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 6.3536372199, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 5.8702075244, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8585638752, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 68.6487552941, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.4840859132, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 54.5051428169, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 28.4058079491, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 28.4058079491, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.4058079491, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1213504695, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 87.864953051, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 9.984305364, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 9.984305364, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.984305364, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "pipil-nicarao", "event_id": "atlas-pipil-nicarao", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 3.0689225092, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 3.0689225092, "label": "Government direction", "low": 3.0689225092, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 21.3351100116, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 14.856813691, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 13.7264021379, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5944436118, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5175598993, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.6369825268, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 44.9619210775, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.4663314238, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 17.8579289426, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 6.855512717, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.1213504695, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.9324765255, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 6.0675234745, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 86.9616304154, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 85.1056280023, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 74.5005315962, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "wari-tiwanaku-moquegua", "event_id": "atlas-wari-tiwanaku-moquegua", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 58.5256864324, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 58.5256864324, "label": "Government direction", "low": 58.5256864324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 28.1307221685, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 22.2120654691, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 20.5220142948, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 77.965013737, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 77.965013737, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 77.965013737, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8152528685, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 61.8690227083, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 53.2280366453, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 43.3943095613, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.1213504695, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.8987147883, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.0337617372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 42.664230867, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 34.5025258946, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 30.2031320478, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "caribbean-saladoid", "event_id": "atlas-caribbean-saladoid", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.7746392465, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.8384210079, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.1659313728, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.617430903, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.617430903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.4767387495, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 74.4767387495, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 74.4767387495, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.2369025307, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3435086646, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 12.8059490456, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.0337617372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.5099170685, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 82.5099170685, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 82.5099170685, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "indonesian-transmigration", "event_id": "atlas-indonesian-transmigration", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.0957648815, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.0957648815, "label": "Government direction", "low": 81.0957648815, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 82.2913072247, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 82.2913072247, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 82.2913072247, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 78.5572906814, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 78.5572906814, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 78.5572906814, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 44.114279645, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 44.114279645, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 44.114279645, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 37.4982472265, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 37.4982472265, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 37.4982472265, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.5181440872, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 69.5181440872, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 69.5181440872, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "yunnan-han", "event_id": "atlas-yunnan-han", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 71.1144995583, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 71.1144995583, "label": "Government direction", "low": 71.1144995583, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 74.7972444455, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 74.7972444455, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 74.7972444455, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.3946017899, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.3946017899, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.3946017899, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 30.3734487411, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 30.3734487411, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 30.3734487411, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 52.1963773013, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 52.1963773013, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 52.1963773013, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 87.3528564394, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 87.3528564394, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 87.3528564394, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "tai-ahom-assam", "event_id": "atlas-tai-ahom-assam", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 26.6862237147, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 26.6862237147, "label": "Government direction", "low": 26.6862237147, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 53.5442067437, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 53.5442067437, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 53.5442067437, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 50.7597010537, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 50.7597010537, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 50.7597010537, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 5.7126829492, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 5.7126829492, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 5.7126829492, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 45.1976654639, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 45.1976654639, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 45.1976654639, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 68.3574544021, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 68.3574544021, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 68.3574544021, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 6.25, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 6.25, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 6.25, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "bamar-pagan", "event_id": "atlas-bamar-pagan", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 1.5181337239, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 1.5181337239, "label": "Government direction", "low": 1.5181337239, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 26.7580750113, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 20.7263765848, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 19.1493671376, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5944436118, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.7597177382, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.6798607304, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 43.2040789164, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 25.2138564324, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 17.3422403743, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 15.6907141481, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.5282014717, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 63.2193833473, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.2803486359, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.5467484988, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 82.5467484988, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 82.5467484988, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "karafuto-sakhalin", "event_id": "atlas-karafuto-sakhalin", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 75.402058006, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 75.402058006, "label": "Government direction", "low": 75.402058006, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 80.0294339222, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 80.0294339222, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 80.0294339222, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.6806443325, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.6806443325, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.6806443325, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 72.0964015152, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 72.0964015152, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 72.0964015152, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 30.8741700453, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 30.8741700453, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.8741700453, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 27.222519155, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 27.222519155, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 27.222519155, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "maasai-expansion", "event_id": "atlas-maasai-expansion", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 5.9058860126, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 5.9058860126, "label": "Government direction", "low": 5.9058860126, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 13.3599699642, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 13.3599699642, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 13.3599699642, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.0210467701, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.0210467701, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.0210467701, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 44.2284253159, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 44.2284253159, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 44.2284253159, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.0608561533, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 55.006075339, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 35.3787481016, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 88.3591673927, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 88.3591673927, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 88.3591673927, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "nandi-uasin-gishu", "event_id": "atlas-nandi-uasin-gishu", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 15.0820689561, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 15.0820689561, "label": "Government direction", "low": 15.0820689561, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 7.9064804039, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 7.9064804039, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.9064804039, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.617430903, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.617430903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.7964647037, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 68.7964647037, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 68.7964647037, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.3687208353, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 66.3687208353, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 66.3687208353, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 90.015694636, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 90.015694636, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 90.015694636, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ndebele-shona", "event_id": "atlas-ndebele-shona", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 27.4628403356, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 27.4628403356, "label": "Government direction", "low": 27.4628403356, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.7839432788, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 15.7839432788, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 15.7839432788, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 71.6399792258, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.6399792258, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 71.6399792258, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 21.5499516716, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 21.5499516716, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.5499516716, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 59.5128787121, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.5128787121, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 59.5128787121, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 43.8212897065, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 43.8212897065, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 43.8212897065, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "oromo-expansion", "event_id": "atlas-oromo-expansion", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 8.5174578737, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 8.5174578737, "label": "Government direction", "low": 8.5174578737, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.3691281375, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 15.3691281375, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 15.3691281375, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 87.2521574219, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 87.2521574219, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 87.2521574219, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 35.4230293547, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 35.4230293547, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 35.4230293547, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.805466382, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 62.9464830265, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 53.9974382535, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 43.4931212283, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 90.9847388667, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 90.9847388667, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 90.9847388667, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "luo-migration", "event_id": "atlas-luo-migration", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 2.3517471453, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 2.3517471453, "label": "Government direction", "low": 2.3517471453, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 9.9156385771, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 9.9156385771, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 9.9156385771, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 79.2057831799, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 79.2057831799, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 79.2057831799, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 40.8219026419, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 40.8219026419, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 40.8219026419, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 73.8046974779, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.3525984079, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 26.5673833025, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 91.9537830974, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 91.9537830974, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 91.9537830974, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "oorlam-namibia", "event_id": "atlas-oorlam-namibia", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 20.1855431151, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 20.1855431151, "label": "Government direction", "low": 20.1855431151, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 18.6396182332, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 18.6396182332, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 18.6396182332, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 68.907930711, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.907930711, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 68.907930711, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 31.4533575747, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.4533575747, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 31.4533575747, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 53.7204403917, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 53.7204403917, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 53.7204403917, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 34.0573350764, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 34.0573350764, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 34.0573350764, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "sokoto-caliphate", "event_id": "atlas-sokoto-caliphate", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 33.1500537015, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 33.1500537015, "label": "Government direction", "low": 33.1500537015, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 50.0353217918, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 50.0353217918, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 50.0353217918, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.5861206655, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.5861206655, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.5861206655, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 10.4601582624, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 10.4601582624, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.4601582624, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 68.7970693864, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 68.7970693864, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 68.7970693864, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 84.3728198608, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 84.3728198608, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 84.3728198608, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 75.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "banu-hilal", "event_id": "atlas-banu-hilal", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8899309195, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 19.2645412128, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 9.2789597231, "label": "Government direction", "low": 8.2576331579, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 9.7583715819, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 9.7583715819, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 9.7583715819, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 68.7284075007, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.7284075007, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 68.7284075007, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 13.7585884517, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 13.7585884517, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 13.7585884517, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 68.027094416, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.2892513802, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 32.3449863643, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.320074497, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.320074497, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.320074497, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-congo-basin", "event_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-congo-basin", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.6221694824, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.6733948885, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.0134616087, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.4571126288, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 86.4571126288, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 86.4571126288, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 46.1783085602, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 46.1783085602, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 46.1783085602, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3656319173, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 78.5001694728, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 41.198157186, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 15.0633611999, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 97.6065143003, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 97.6065143003, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 97.6065143003, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-great-lakes", "event_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-great-lakes", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 19.4832188336, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 12.8524135626, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 11.8745109599, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8921511443, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.0749053304, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 78.7871205553, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.2900197564, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7372998702, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.8134801354, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 46.8513132179, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 34.5434671532, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.250079856, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 84.2777725347, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 37.1311719598, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.2857581381, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 93.7694505904, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 93.7694505904, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 93.7694505904, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-eastern-africa", "event_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-eastern-africa", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 21.0253732523, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 14.5215691543, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 13.4166653786, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8921511443, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.7106457103, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 79.499713241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.9257601363, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 47.8213664997, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 42.32930407, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 38.2982242154, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3656319173, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 81.5339312101, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 49.4954682082, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 18.0971229372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-southern-africa", "event_id": "af-bantu-farmer-settlement-southern-africa", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 21.3351100116, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 14.856813691, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 13.7264021379, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 78.3786839369, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 78.3786839369, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 78.3786839369, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 45.4405809286, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 45.4405809286, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 45.4405809286, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5279193798, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 62.2714232194, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 28.5334499474, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 15.0633611999, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-french-settlement-morocco", "event_id": "af-french-settlement-morocco", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.4529005695, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 64.4529005695, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.4529005695, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 82.1053810193, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 82.1053810193, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 82.1053810193, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 56.7948405273, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 56.7948405273, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 56.7948405273, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 18.8633990813, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 18.8633990813, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.8633990813, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 39.3278259389, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 39.3278259389, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 39.3278259389, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 18.1284936702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 18.1284936702, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 18.1284936702, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-french-settlement-tunisia", "event_id": "af-french-settlement-tunisia", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 59.038524318, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 59.038524318, "label": "Government direction", "low": 59.038524318, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 82.1053810193, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 82.1053810193, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 82.1053810193, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 60.3307436466, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 60.3307436466, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 60.3307436466, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 18.8633990813, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 18.8633990813, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.8633990813, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 24.1215353802, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 24.1215353802, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 24.1215353802, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 14.7712767635, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 14.7712767635, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 14.7712767635, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-sierra-leone-freetown-settler-colony", "event_id": "af-sierra-leone-freetown-settler-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 53.9042400889, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 53.9042400889, "label": "Government direction", "low": 53.9042400889, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 72.9908418268, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 72.9908418268, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 72.9908418268, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.2904051782, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.2904051782, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.2904051782, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 53.464723604, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 53.464723604, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.464723604, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 41.0810404509, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 41.0810404509, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 41.0810404509, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 56.4528700109, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 56.4528700109, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 56.4528700109, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 87.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-portuguese-settlement-angola", "event_id": "af-portuguese-settlement-angola", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 72.9697843572, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 72.9697843572, "label": "Government direction", "low": 72.9697843572, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 84.0366108237, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 84.0366108237, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 84.0366108237, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.6525536921, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.6525536921, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.6525536921, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 21.9109487069, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 21.9109487069, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.9109487069, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 65.5715216838, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 65.5715216838, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 65.5715216838, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 17.8865514683, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 17.8865514683, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 17.8865514683, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-portuguese-settlement-mozambique", "event_id": "af-portuguese-settlement-mozambique", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 66.6509060775, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 66.6509060775, "label": "Government direction", "low": 66.6509060775, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 81.0255716969, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 81.0255716969, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 81.0255716969, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 52.3407769726, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 52.3407769726, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 52.3407769726, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 19.5301631358, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 19.5301631358, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 19.5301631358, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 53.2467196171, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 53.2467196171, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 53.2467196171, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 9.984305364, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 9.984305364, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.984305364, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-british-estates-malawi", "event_id": "af-british-estates-malawi", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 53.1196259067, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 53.1196259067, "label": "Government direction", "low": 53.1196259067, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 74.7786624441, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 74.7786624441, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 74.7786624441, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 49.4406142333, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 49.4406142333, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 49.4406142333, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 12.601662855, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 12.601662855, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 12.601662855, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 27.1948098375, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 27.1948098375, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 27.1948098375, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 32.3856383817, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 32.3856383817, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 32.3856383817, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-eswatini-concession-partition", "event_id": "af-eswatini-concession-partition", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.2324928737, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 64.2324928737, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.2324928737, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.1412126886, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.1412126886, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.1412126886, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 55.7173940567, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 55.7173940567, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 55.7173940567, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 16.7883805295, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 16.7883805295, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 16.7883805295, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 19.442667857, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 19.442667857, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.442667857, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 34.7791240815, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 34.7791240815, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 34.7791240815, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-italian-settlement-eritrea", "event_id": "af-italian-settlement-eritrea", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 77.3861063649, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.3861063649, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.3861063649, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 71.4549916708, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 71.4549916708, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 71.4549916708, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 51.6759896063, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 51.6759896063, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 51.6759896063, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 23.385689245, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 23.385689245, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 23.385689245, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 42.8147247441, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.8147247441, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 42.8147247441, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 9.9645925087, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 9.9645925087, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.9645925087, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-italian-settlement-somalia", "event_id": "af-italian-settlement-somalia", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 70.8082827772, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 70.8082827772, "label": "Government direction", "low": 70.8082827772, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 72.0512941053, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 72.0512941053, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 72.0512941053, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 52.4912531965, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 52.4912531965, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 52.4912531965, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 21.9109487069, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 21.9109487069, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.9109487069, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 52.3808502277, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 52.3808502277, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 52.3808502277, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 17.8865514683, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 17.8865514683, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 17.8865514683, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-ethiopian-southern-conquest-neftenya", "event_id": "af-ethiopian-southern-conquest-neftenya", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 78.1032817288, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.1032817288, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.1032817288, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 73.7507155192, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 73.7507155192, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 73.7507155192, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 59.6427116417, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.6427116417, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 59.6427116417, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 23.355883775, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 23.355883775, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 23.355883775, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 78.0337617372, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 78.0337617372, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 78.0337617372, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 55.6331096022, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 55.6331096022, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 55.6331096022, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-chagos-forced-removal", "event_id": "af-chagos-forced-removal", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.2430146761, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 92.2430146761, "label": "Government direction", "low": 92.2430146761, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 54.5030907383, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 54.5030907383, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 54.5030907383, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 53.0542798284, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 53.0542798284, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 53.0542798284, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 91.8476397449, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 91.8476397449, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 91.8476397449, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 42.2421124443, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.2421124443, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 42.2421124443, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 57.1232137047, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 57.1232137047, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.1232137047, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-bioko-colonial-plantations", "event_id": "af-bioko-colonial-plantations", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 60.4998613481, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 60.4998613481, "label": "Government direction", "low": 60.4998613481, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 76.851891178, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 76.851891178, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 76.851891178, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 50.498943884, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 50.498943884, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 50.498943884, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 42.1356492163, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 42.1356492163, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 42.1356492163, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 69.4157503673, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 69.4157503673, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 69.4157503673, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 24.4833922775, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 24.4833922775, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 24.4833922775, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-gibraltar-conquest-population-replacement", "event_id": "eu-gibraltar-conquest-population-replacement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.1492556975, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.1492556975, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.1492556975, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.5669617439, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 58.5669617439, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 58.5669617439, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 67.2836251921, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 67.2836251921, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 67.2836251921, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 86.162780973, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 86.162780973, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 86.162780973, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 28.2124890884, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 28.2124890884, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.2124890884, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.8352375368, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 82.8352375368, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 82.8352375368, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-spanish-conquest-congregacion-mesoamerica", "event_id": "am-spanish-conquest-congregacion-mesoamerica", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 63.1893766172, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 63.1893766172, "label": "Government direction", "low": 63.1893766172, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 76.410952916, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 76.410952916, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 76.410952916, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 51.3341545193, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 51.3341545193, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 51.3341545193, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 29.7804941652, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 29.7804941652, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 29.7804941652, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.2016540851, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 80.2016540851, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 80.2016540851, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 66.4127258101, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 66.4127258101, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 66.4127258101, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-spanish-conquest-reduccion-andes", "event_id": "am-spanish-conquest-reduccion-andes", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 73.5468045684, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 73.5468045684, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.5468045684, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 84.0366108237, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 84.0366108237, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 84.0366108237, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 56.3129502165, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 56.3129502165, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 56.3129502165, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 30.2843840558, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 30.2843840558, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 30.2843840558, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 87.1403291404, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 87.1403291404, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 87.1403291404, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.4990869135, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.4990869135, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 64.4990869135, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-dutch-guiana-plantation-colonization", "event_id": "am-dutch-guiana-plantation-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 51.5524929436, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 51.5524929436, "label": "Government direction", "low": 51.5524929436, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 79.9075782775, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 79.9075782775, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 79.9075782775, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 56.8991826214, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 56.8991826214, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 56.8991826214, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.5564416091, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.5564416091, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 60.5564416091, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.5970486361, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 83.5970486361, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 83.5970486361, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.341555329, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 77.341555329, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 77.341555329, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-garifuna-deportation-st-vincent", "event_id": "am-garifuna-deportation-st-vincent", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.8859810455, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.8859810455, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.8859810455, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 83.7976451577, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 83.7976451577, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 83.7976451577, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 51.0472639368, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 51.0472639368, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 51.0472639368, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 90.1158606805, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 90.1158606805, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 90.1158606805, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 77.3055395152, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 77.3055395152, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 77.3055395152, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.1717815377, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.1717815377, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.1717815377, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-french-saint-domingue-plantation-colony", "event_id": "am-french-saint-domingue-plantation-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 53.1587689663, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 53.1587689663, "label": "Government direction", "low": 53.1587689663, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 87.4262549804, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 87.4262549804, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 87.4262549804, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.5179575443, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.5179575443, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.5179575443, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 59.8790396424, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 59.8790396424, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 59.8790396424, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 64.3566889429, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 64.3566889429, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 64.3566889429, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 22.6308726104, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 22.6308726104, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 22.6308726104, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-indonesian-occupation-timor-leste", "event_id": "asia-indonesian-occupation-timor-leste", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.2275089271, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 89.2275089271, "label": "Government direction", "low": 89.2275089271, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 67.1763141934, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 67.1763141934, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 67.1763141934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 61.6917836696, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 61.6917836696, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 61.6917836696, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 37.1697022427, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 37.1697022427, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 37.1697022427, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 92.2478580195, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 92.2478580195, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 92.2478580195, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 12.1726097812, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 12.1726097812, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 12.1726097812, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-qing-colonization-xinjiang", "event_id": "asia-qing-colonization-xinjiang", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 87.7093752032, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 87.7093752032, "label": "Government direction", "low": 87.7093752032, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 71.9491101316, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 71.9491101316, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 71.9491101316, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 63.5609058201, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.5609058201, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 63.5609058201, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 33.8773252396, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 33.8773252396, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 33.8773252396, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.0291306713, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 90.0291306713, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 90.0291306713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 86.1879110396, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 86.1879110396, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 86.1879110396, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 62.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-prc-xinjiang-xpcc-settlement", "event_id": "asia-prc-xinjiang-xpcc-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 91.8340968415, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.8340968415, "label": "Government direction", "low": 91.8340968415, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 78.4030536085, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 78.4030536085, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 78.4030536085, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 71.7602498059, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.7602498059, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 71.7602498059, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 49.2920778384, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 49.2920778384, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 49.2920778384, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 59.2236308639, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.2236308639, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 59.2236308639, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 75.7486934968, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.7486934968, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 75.7486934968, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "pacific-papua-new-guinea-colonial-plantations", "event_id": "pacific-papua-new-guinea-colonial-plantations", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 53.8700809759, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 53.8700809759, "label": "Government direction", "low": 53.8700809759, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 75.343245287, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 75.343245287, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 75.343245287, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 35.5048308908, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 35.5048308908, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 35.5048308908, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 4.5222901637, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 4.5222901637, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 4.5222901637, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 67.7706445814, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 67.7706445814, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 67.7706445814, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 35.1697737913, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 35.1697737913, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 35.1697737913, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-japanese-colonial-taiwan", "event_id": "asia-japanese-colonial-taiwan", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.0483932632, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.0483932632, "label": "Government direction", "low": 81.0483932632, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 90.6917653512, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 90.6917653512, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 90.6917653512, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 51.4606392748, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 51.4606392748, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 51.4606392748, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 17.7242310324, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 17.7242310324, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 17.7242310324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 58.1100600667, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 58.1100600667, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 58.1100600667, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 33.871290335, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 33.871290335, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 33.871290335, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-medieval-ostsiedlung", "event_id": "eu-medieval-ostsiedlung", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 43.7728517197, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 43.7728517197, "label": "Government direction", "low": 43.7728517197, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 59.6661936543, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 59.6661936543, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 59.6661936543, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 82.1568944113, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 82.1568944113, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 82.1568944113, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 31.2363116802, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.2363116802, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 31.2363116802, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 28.7352756503, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 28.7352756503, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.7352756503, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 40.9210527119, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 40.9210527119, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 40.9210527119, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-norman-conquest-settlement-wales", "event_id": "eu-norman-conquest-settlement-wales", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 49.3665261835, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 49.3665261835, "label": "Government direction", "low": 49.3665261835, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 63.3747732414, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 63.3747732414, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 63.3747732414, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 66.7073944736, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 66.7073944736, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 66.7073944736, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 17.6395391069, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 17.6395391069, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 17.6395391069, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 37.6827201529, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 37.6827201529, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 37.6827201529, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 74.5005315962, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 74.5005315962, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 74.5005315962, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-iberian-christian-conquest-repopulation", "event_id": "eu-iberian-christian-conquest-repopulation", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 68.0747522155, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 68.0747522155, "label": "Government direction", "low": 68.0747522155, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.8585693627, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.8585693627, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.8585693627, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.514531578, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.514531578, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.514531578, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 37.246719006, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 37.246719006, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 37.246719006, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.4104735836, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 66.4104735836, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 66.4104735836, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 97.5966578726, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 97.5966578726, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 97.5966578726, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-habsburg-military-frontier", "event_id": "eu-habsburg-military-frontier", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.530670379, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.530670379, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.530670379, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 62.4500999599, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 62.4500999599, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 62.4500999599, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 87.0538375536, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 87.0538375536, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 87.0538375536, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 52.2726930864, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 52.2726930864, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 52.2726930864, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 47.7583644035, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 47.7583644035, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 47.7583644035, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.3121566681, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 72.3121566681, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 72.3121566681, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-ottoman-settlement-cyprus", "event_id": "eu-ottoman-settlement-cyprus", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.5655080484, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 89.5655080484, "label": "Government direction", "low": 89.5655080484, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 66.4908233402, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 66.4908233402, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 66.4908233402, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 63.6203208517, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.6203208517, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 63.6203208517, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 30.9144675395, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 30.9144675395, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 30.9144675395, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 49.8566072575, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 49.8566072575, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 49.8566072575, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 65.2727150346, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.2727150346, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 65.2727150346, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-nazi-implemented-polish-expulsions", "event_id": "eu-nazi-implemented-polish-expulsions", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 96.0469607786, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.0469607786, "label": "Government direction", "low": 96.0469607786, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 73.5652890707, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 73.5652890707, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 73.5652890707, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 67.8294731448, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 67.8294731448, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 67.8294731448, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 47.8949095901, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 47.8949095901, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 47.8949095901, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 78.8786683928, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 78.8786683928, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 78.8786683928, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 7.1804570992, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 7.1804570992, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.1804570992, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "danish-norwegian-initial-colonization-west-greenland", "event_id": "danish-norwegian-initial-colonization-west-greenland", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 51.8930925522, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 51.8930925522, "label": "Government direction", "low": 51.8930925522, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8820517642, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.4798698197, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 42.7243023254, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 37.6850462409, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3786989604, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.4474635434, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 48.3691837046, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 18.3173595852, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7238769706, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 27.612302939, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 45.5244198966, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 15.302603283, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.8423118448, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7027097709, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.1819604056, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 46.1825619009, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 32.4529374906, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-arab-conquest-settlement-maghreb", "event_id": "mena-arab-conquest-settlement-maghreb", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 65.5250105821, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 65.5250105821, "label": "Government direction", "low": 65.5250105821, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 53.2937644458, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 53.2937644458, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 53.2937644458, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 49.9362993894, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 49.9362993894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 49.9362993894, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 9.5718707773, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 9.5718707773, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 9.5718707773, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 73.9496576842, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.497518456, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 38.2675496325, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.2566389083, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.2566389083, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 64.2566389083, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-hazara-war-dispossession", "event_id": "mena-hazara-war-dispossession", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.6213455785, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.6213455785, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.6213455785, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 56.2248138249, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 56.2248138249, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 56.2248138249, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 50.9429218427, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 50.9429218427, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 50.9429218427, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 33.5356995642, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 33.5356995642, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 33.5356995642, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 89.5196119042, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 89.5196119042, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 89.5196119042, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 51.1674210704, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 51.1674210704, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 51.1674210704, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-pashtun-resettlement-northern-afghanistan", "event_id": "mena-pashtun-resettlement-northern-afghanistan", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.0125366551, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 82.0125366551, "label": "Government direction", "low": 82.0125366551, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 63.9710756759, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 63.9710756759, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 63.9710756759, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.8610692879, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.8610692879, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.8610692879, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 31.4533575747, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.4533575747, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 31.4533575747, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 31.116125878, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 31.116125878, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 31.116125878, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 58.2586810763, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 58.2586810763, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 58.2586810763, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-zionist-settlement-ottoman-mandate-palestine", "event_id": "mena-zionist-settlement-ottoman-mandate-palestine", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 50.1422332902, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 50.1422332902, "label": "Government direction", "low": 50.1422332902, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 73.491354109, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 73.491354109, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 73.491354109, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 65.0760370679, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 65.0760370679, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 65.0760370679, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 46.5502952321, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 46.5502952321, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 46.5502952321, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 24.3075757704, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 24.3075757704, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 24.3075757704, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.1246583875, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.1246583875, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.1246583875, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-nakba-palestinian-displacement", "event_id": "mena-nakba-palestinian-displacement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 70.7458352459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 70.7458352459, "label": "Government direction", "low": 70.7458352459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 78.5539788687, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 78.5539788687, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 78.5539788687, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.5179344343, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.5179344343, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.5179344343, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 86.0720358614, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 86.0720358614, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 86.0720358614, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 61.5216481594, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 61.5216481594, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 61.5216481594, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.5612159599, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.5612159599, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.5612159599, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-negev-bedouin-dispossession", "event_id": "mena-negev-bedouin-dispossession", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 88.2513882551, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.2513882551, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.2513882551, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.6447377081, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.6447377081, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.6447377081, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.3756475991, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.3756475991, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.3756475991, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 63.1902365071, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 63.1902365071, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 63.1902365071, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 51.5263031187, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 51.5263031187, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 51.5263031187, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 75.7388370692, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.7388370692, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 75.7388370692, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ca-imperial-russian-colonization-crimea", "event_id": "ca-imperial-russian-colonization-crimea", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.0563209502, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 82.0563209502, "label": "Government direction", "low": 82.0563209502, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 81.4359479259, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 81.4359479259, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 81.4359479259, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.4574534208, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 81.4574534208, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 81.4574534208, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 38.9279641386, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 38.9279641386, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 38.9279641386, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 43.3850125022, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 43.3850125022, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 43.3850125022, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.7408461788, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 80.7408461788, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 80.7408461788, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ca-crimean-tatar-deportation-resettlement", "event_id": "ca-crimean-tatar-deportation-resettlement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.6482528547, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 97.6482528547, "label": "Government direction", "low": 97.6482528547, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 66.0972917839, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 66.0972917839, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 66.0972917839, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 84.5953809049, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 84.5953809049, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 84.5953809049, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 64.5344471628, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 64.5344471628, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 64.5344471628, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 51.9509056192, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 51.9509056192, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 51.9509056192, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ca-russian-occupation-crimea-demographic-transfer", "event_id": "ca-russian-occupation-crimea-demographic-transfer", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.2275089271, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 89.2275089271, "label": "Government direction", "low": 89.2275089271, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.9879829952, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.9879829952, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.9879829952, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 54.3608020141, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 54.3608020141, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 54.3608020141, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 28.7962668938, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 28.7962668938, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7962668938, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 34.2873256019, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 34.2873256019, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 34.2873256019, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 66.9293335326, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 66.9293335326, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 66.9293335326, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ca-soviet-chechen-ingush-deportation", "event_id": "ca-soviet-chechen-ingush-deportation", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.6482528547, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 97.6482528547, "label": "Government direction", "low": 97.6482528547, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 65.9400247887, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 65.9400247887, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 65.9400247887, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.4272687837, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.4272687837, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.4272687837, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.7637157109, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 76.7637157109, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 76.7637157109, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 68.0688471643, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 68.0688471643, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 68.0688471643, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 23.1750523935, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 23.1750523935, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 23.1750523935, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-iraq", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-iraq", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 78.716045737, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.716045737, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.716045737, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.2969147275, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 64.2969147275, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 64.2969147275, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 87.7350751094, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.7350751094, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 87.7350751094, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 25.3310005965, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 25.3310005965, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 25.3310005965, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.0649359105, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 62.0649359105, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 62.0649359105, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-yemen-aden", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-yemen-aden", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 58.0292624881, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 58.0292624881, "label": "Government direction", "low": 58.0292624881, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 44.6090364964, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 44.6090364964, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 44.6090364964, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 72.2112724886, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 72.2112724886, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 72.2112724886, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 43.1989721121, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 43.1989721121, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 43.1989721121, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.0649359105, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 62.0649359105, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 62.0649359105, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-morocco", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-morocco", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 49.3930422304, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 49.3930422304, "label": "Government direction", "low": 49.3930422304, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 30.2687391209, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 30.2687391209, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.2687391209, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 13.0576648834, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 13.0576648834, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 13.0576648834, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 78.4435468054, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 78.4435468054, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 78.4435468054, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 25.3310005965, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 25.3310005965, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 25.3310005965, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 58.0358679003, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 58.0358679003, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 58.0358679003, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-algeria", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-algeria", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 33.8912265241, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 33.8912265241, "label": "Government direction", "low": 33.8912265241, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 48.4083803942, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 48.4083803942, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 48.4083803942, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 83.8541244542, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 83.8541244542, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 83.8541244542, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 28.3647623338, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 28.3647623338, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.3647623338, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 68.0913413324, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 68.0913413324, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 68.0913413324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-tunisia", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-tunisia", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6582598764, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.9335778942, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 46.728604673, "label": "Government direction", "low": 30.7595655384, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5368957102, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 62.3597434284, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 29.8927969506, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 16.0493144488, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.1202600352, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 74.1202600352, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 74.1202600352, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 21.2738140331, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 21.2738140331, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 21.2738140331, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.9038663149, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.5170994216, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.0622733221, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.9037309122, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-syria", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-syria", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 56.2853799039, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 56.2853799039, "label": "Government direction", "low": 56.2853799039, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 55.1623285455, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.1623285455, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 55.1623285455, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 63.9883888292, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 63.9883888292, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 63.9883888292, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 37.8745061183, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 37.8745061183, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 37.8745061183, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.7932400014, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.7932400014, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.7932400014, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-lebanon", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-lebanon", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 25.018854707, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 25.018854707, "label": "Government direction", "low": 25.018854707, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.0531766741, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 15.0531766741, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 15.0531766741, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 72.6714969371, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 72.6714969371, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 72.6714969371, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 25.1860403902, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 25.1860403902, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 25.1860403902, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 58.9822670548, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 58.9822670548, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 58.9822670548, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "mena-jewish-departure-iran", "event_id": "mena-jewish-departure-iran", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 38.2521562195, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 38.2521562195, "label": "Government direction", "low": 38.2521562195, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 43.500174338, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 43.500174338, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 43.500174338, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 57.3288821919, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 57.3288821919, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 57.3288821919, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 28.3647623338, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 28.3647623338, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.3647623338, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.5427090162, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.5427090162, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.5427090162, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "modern-chinese-exodus-to-taiwan", "event_id": "modern-chinese-exodus-to-taiwan", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.6076042014, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.6076042014, "label": "Government direction", "low": 81.6076042014, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 78.8972241557, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 78.8972241557, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 78.8972241557, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 55.3509599638, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 55.3509599638, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 55.3509599638, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 27.0157593364, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 27.0157593364, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 27.0157593364, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 46.1779196141, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 46.1779196141, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 46.1779196141, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 65.0058382084, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.0058382084, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 65.0058382084, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "modern-acadian-deportation-planter-replacement", "event_id": "modern-acadian-deportation-planter-replacement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.8859810455, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.8859810455, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.8859810455, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 73.6394002845, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 73.6394002845, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 73.6394002845, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.6704067405, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 89.6704067405, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 89.6704067405, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 94.5894223512, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 94.5894223512, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 94.5894223512, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 77.7102833604, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 77.7102833604, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 77.7102833604, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 68.5589562842, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 68.5589562842, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 68.5589562842, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "modern-panama-canal-zone-removals", "event_id": "modern-panama-canal-zone-removals", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 91.8340968415, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.8340968415, "label": "Government direction", "low": 91.8340968415, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 66.4024429228, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 66.4024429228, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 66.4024429228, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.2683729022, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.2683729022, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.2683729022, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 83.444398926, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 83.444398926, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 83.444398926, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 36.3537797049, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 36.3537797049, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 36.3537797049, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 36.7294533865, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 36.7294533865, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 36.7294533865, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 75.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "modern-moriori-invasion-enslavement-land-seizure", "event_id": "modern-moriori-invasion-enslavement-land-seizure", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 24.8403262246, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 24.8403262246, "label": "Government direction", "low": 24.8403262246, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 68.927036921, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 68.927036921, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 68.927036921, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8585638752, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.5549167796, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 84.3400315244, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 72.4113043024, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 47.9133818629, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 47.9133818629, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 47.9133818629, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 86.6381234123, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 86.6381234123, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 86.6381234123, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 48.4795569948, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 48.4795569948, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 48.4795569948, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "caribbean-french-plantation-colonies", "event_id": "caribbean-french-plantation-colonies", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 58.117104026, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 58.117104026, "label": "Government direction", "low": 58.117104026, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.1146372675, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.1146372675, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.1146372675, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 63.8285477765, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.8285477765, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 63.8285477765, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 79.0066959114, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 79.0066959114, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 79.0066959114, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.6879969367, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 90.6879969367, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 90.6879969367, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.341555329, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 77.341555329, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 77.341555329, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "caribbean-dutch-antilles-colonization-slavery", "event_id": "caribbean-dutch-antilles-colonization-slavery", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 60.4688511713, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 60.4688511713, "label": "Government direction", "low": 60.4688511713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 74.9497142096, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 74.9497142096, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 74.9497142096, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.9003540151, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.9003540151, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.9003540151, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 53.3948183124, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 53.3948183124, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.3948183124, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 63.5505350567, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 63.5505350567, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 63.5505350567, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 90.2208759185, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 90.2208759185, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 90.2208759185, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "pacific-german-samoa-plantation-labor", "event_id": "pacific-german-samoa-plantation-labor", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 57.0726651281, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 57.0726651281, "label": "Government direction", "low": 57.0726651281, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 72.3256716005, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 72.3256716005, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 72.3256716005, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 42.0023970118, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 42.0023970118, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 42.0023970118, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 39.9118284095, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 39.9118284095, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 39.9118284095, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 38.4055748504, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 38.4055748504, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 38.4055748504, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 32.3856383817, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 32.3856383817, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 32.3856383817, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "pacific-sokehs-deportation-pohnpei", "event_id": "pacific-sokehs-deportation-pohnpei", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 93.5185472698, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 93.5185472698, "label": "Government direction", "low": 93.5185472698, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 70.3716122513, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 70.3716122513, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 70.3716122513, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 79.8386784978, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 79.8386784978, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 79.8386784978, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 65.8585913768, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 65.8585913768, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 65.8585913768, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 59.3327930778, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.3327930778, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 59.3327930778, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 17.6143616183, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 17.6143616183, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 17.6143616183, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "south-atlantic-british-falklands-colonization", "event_id": "south-atlantic-british-falklands-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 77.5488430291, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.5488430291, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.5488430291, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.3892434445, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.3892434445, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.3892434445, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 72.7568936828, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.7568936828, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 72.7568936828, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.9828639863, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.9828639863, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 60.9828639863, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 23.2263367301, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 23.2263367301, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 23.2263367301, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.3783162484, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 77.3783162484, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 77.3783162484, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "indian-ocean-maldives-gan-base-relocation", "event_id": "indian-ocean-maldives-gan-base-relocation", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 94.3521606912, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 94.3521606912, "label": "Government direction", "low": 94.3521606912, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 42.1882405513, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 42.1882405513, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.1882405513, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 34.4306589036, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 34.4306589036, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 34.4306589036, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 56.0762834179, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 56.0762834179, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 56.0762834179, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 6.2305494096, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 6.2305494096, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 6.2305494096, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "europe-norse-settlement-faroes", "event_id": "europe-norse-settlement-faroes", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 11.7684671792, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 5.7303365769, "label": "Government direction", "low": 5.3632988747, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8559360647, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 28.8970438377, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 16.9295942838, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 14.4906503084, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 78.3401574207, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 78.3401574207, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 78.3401574207, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2019832245, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 91.9936148725, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.3611381805, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 12.1919373268, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.1155520612, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 94.2223969382, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 5.7776030618, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 92.6045051906, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 91.5517618915, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 80.1434063715, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-las-humanas-famine-raid-abandonment", "event_id": "us-las-humanas-famine-raid-abandonment", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.545883549, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.3035941965, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 63.9183011818, "label": "Government direction", "low": 34.8919490927, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9073203156, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 16.4711652037, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 7.9389788157, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.2031967647, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 45.9990945823, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 45.9990945823, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 45.9990945823, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 55.4968566891, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 30.8075218841, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.8147486374, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 35.4510422407, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 35.4510422407, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 35.4510422407, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-quarai-chilili-to-tajique-relocation", "event_id": "us-quarai-chilili-to-tajique-relocation", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.9322944446, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 66.4070400808, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 63.9674352726, "label": "Government direction", "low": 59.6364845385, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9073203156, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 16.4711652037, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 7.9389788157, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.2031967647, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 49.2726740391, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 49.2726740391, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 49.2726740391, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 13.0061985298, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 13.0061985298, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 13.0061985298, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 31.7670027382, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 31.7670027382, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 31.7670027382, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-sobaipuri-relocation-1762", "event_id": "us-sobaipuri-relocation-1762", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.6808055102, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 92.6808055102, "label": "Government direction", "low": 92.6808055102, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 20.7938220435, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 20.7938220435, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 20.7938220435, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 5.5731394944, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 5.5731394944, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 5.5731394944, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.794580659, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 43.7255728411, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 29.1771999237, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 23.1836387439, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3985281698, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 60.1471830196, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-neolithic-aegean-balkans", "event_id": "prehistory-neolithic-aegean-balkans", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 17.7837974197, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 11.0130395537, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 10.175089546, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.617430903, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.617430903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.832531293, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 69.8580604628, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 63.7948269454, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.1111897649, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.2369025307, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3435086646, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 12.8059490456, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.0337617372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 90.6541758856, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 90.6541758856, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 90.6541758856, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-neolithic-danubian-lbk", "event_id": "prehistory-neolithic-danubian-lbk", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 19.4832188336, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 12.8524135626, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 11.8745109599, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.1533340223, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 89.1533340223, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 89.1533340223, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 63.7214595441, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 63.7214595441, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 63.7214595441, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3656319173, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 78.5001694728, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 41.198157186, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 15.0633611999, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 85.6620232036, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 85.6620232036, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 85.6620232036, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-neolithic-mediterranean-cardial", "event_id": "prehistory-neolithic-mediterranean-cardial", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 17.4740606604, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 10.6777950169, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 9.8653527867, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.617430903, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.617430903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 61.1490526246, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 61.1490526246, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 61.1490526246, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3656319173, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 72.722566411, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 25.3964648585, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.2857581381, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.904260572, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 93.7694505904, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 93.1097853844, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 84.1955077915, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-neolithic-britain-ireland-turnover", "event_id": "prehistory-neolithic-britain-ireland-turnover", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.7746392465, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.8384210079, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.1659313728, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.1533340223, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 89.1533340223, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 89.1533340223, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 72.5268555053, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 72.5268555053, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 72.5268555053, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.2369025307, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3435086646, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 12.8059490456, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.0337617372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 95.007847318, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 95.007847318, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 95.007847318, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-yamnaya-lower-danube-expansion", "event_id": "prehistory-yamnaya-lower-danube-expansion", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 13.6130113091, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 6.4987763428, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 6.0043034355, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 45.0794689474, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 45.0794689474, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 45.0794689474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8447619738, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 40.8041450941, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 29.9259948453, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 25.2803424732, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2369025307, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 91.0436749946, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 62.1940509544, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 14.7339280672, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.1070458965, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 72.1070458965, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 72.1070458965, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-corded-ware-central-northern-europe", "event_id": "prehistory-corded-ware-central-northern-europe", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.4649024872, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.5031764712, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.8561946135, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 57.1119189389, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 57.1119189389, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 57.1119189389, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8447619738, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 51.9903266263, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 43.1678095569, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 36.4665240055, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3730735329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 87.6393999408, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 66.8681936136, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 24.9467532286, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 78.3375953061, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 78.3375953061, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 78.3375953061, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-beaker-britain-ancestry-turnover", "event_id": "prehistory-beaker-britain-ancestry-turnover", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6766902077, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 32.3309792253, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.504595982, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.540401804, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3253797195, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.1533340223, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 66.664591163, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 21.691305975, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.4723905397, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 87.3749365857, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 73.2740976951, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 34.6139905575, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.6835158987, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 97.4111894454, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 96.2125086491, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 65.7627793178, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-west-slavic-settlement-central-europe", "event_id": "eu-west-slavic-settlement-central-europe", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 13.9227480685, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 6.8340208795, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 6.3140401948, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 85.617430903, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 85.617430903, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.3401378308, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 68.3401378308, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 68.3401378308, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.2369025307, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3435086646, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 12.8059490456, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.0337617372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 95.007847318, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 95.007847318, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 95.007847318, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-east-slavic-expansion-state-formation", "event_id": "eu-east-slavic-expansion-state-formation", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 20.6384045375, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 20.6384045375, "label": "Government direction", "low": 20.6384045375, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 19.7974623941, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 19.7974623941, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 19.7974623941, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8921511443, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.8787752618, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 74.832545329, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 35.5371750256, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 28.7521399373, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 26.0140327413, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3730735329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 78.9729953481, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 43.6384444382, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.2803486359, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 87.5389011808, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 87.5389011808, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 87.5389011808, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "eu-south-slavic-balkan-settlement", "event_id": "eu-south-slavic-balkan-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 9.858925234, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 9.858925234, "label": "Government direction", "low": 9.858925234, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 17.3215908963, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 10.5127688974, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 9.7128830226, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.3069982035, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.3069982035, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.3069982035, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 48.4703730064, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 48.4703730064, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 48.4703730064, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 53.2198021274, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 53.2198021274, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 53.2198021274, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 75.9342531787, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.9342531787, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 75.9342531787, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "med-phoenician-trading-enclaves", "event_id": "med-phoenician-trading-enclaves", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 36.1940549872, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 36.1940549872, "label": "Government direction", "low": 36.1940549872, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 42.2645713616, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 42.2645713616, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.2645713616, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 54.4552370517, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 54.4552370517, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 54.4552370517, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 26.4747405381, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 26.4747405381, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 26.4747405381, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 8.8113647991, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 8.8113647991, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 8.8113647991, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 59.4137907921, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.4137907921, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 59.4137907921, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "med-carthage-north-african-settlement", "event_id": "med-carthage-north-african-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 49.3313757877, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 49.3313757877, "label": "Government direction", "low": 49.3313757877, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 50.7386949897, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 50.7386949897, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 50.7386949897, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 63.2309063859, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.2309063859, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 63.2309063859, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 6.9030757348, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 6.9030757348, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 6.9030757348, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 38.8534325998, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 38.8534325998, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 38.8534325998, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 58.9588786133, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 58.9588786133, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 58.9588786133, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "med-carthaginian-western-islands-iberia", "event_id": "med-carthaginian-western-islands-iberia", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.1078091667, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.1078091667, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.1078091667, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 45.9731509487, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 45.9731509487, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.9731509487, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 55.788218074, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 55.788218074, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 55.788218074, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 14.9707440644, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 14.9707440644, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 14.9707440644, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 42.0716672634, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.0716672634, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 42.0716672634, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.5372405032, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.5372405032, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.5372405032, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "med-greek-black-sea-colonies", "event_id": "med-greek-black-sea-colonies", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 44.1931684298, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 44.1931684298, "label": "Government direction", "low": 44.1931684298, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 54.2021636839, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 54.2021636839, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 54.2021636839, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 54.4552370517, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 54.4552370517, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 54.4552370517, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 38.0219191056, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 38.0219191056, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 38.0219191056, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 57.9245326758, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 34.5820174609, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 22.242424624, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 55.3906823408, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 55.3906823408, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 55.3906823408, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "med-greek-cyrene-colonization", "event_id": "med-greek-cyrene-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 44.1931684298, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 44.1931684298, "label": "Government direction", "low": 44.1931684298, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.5573314959, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 58.5573314959, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 58.5573314959, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 59.00917161, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.00917161, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 59.00917161, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 40.4027046767, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 40.4027046767, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 40.4027046767, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5018029194, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 75.0958944191, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.3707439374, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 25.2761863613, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 63.2409980743, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 63.2409980743, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 63.2409980743, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "med-greek-western-emporia-massalia", "event_id": "med-greek-western-emporia-massalia", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 44.943623499, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 44.943623499, "label": "Government direction", "low": 44.943623499, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 50.9272699829, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 50.9272699829, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 50.9272699829, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 58.6883808133, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 58.6883808133, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 58.6883808133, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 21.8560622514, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 21.8560622514, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.8560622514, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 20.4832553562, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 20.4832553562, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 20.4832553562, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 74.5005315962, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 74.5005315962, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 74.5005315962, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-qin-sichuan-colonization", "event_id": "asia-qin-sichuan-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.3629238962, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.3629238962, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.3629238962, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 70.1491171369, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 70.1491171369, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 70.1491171369, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 65.4666250308, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 65.4666250308, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 65.4666250308, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 18.8633990813, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 18.8633990813, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.8633990813, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 27.5817258765, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 27.5817258765, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 27.5817258765, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.5759920337, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.5759920337, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.5759920337, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-qin-han-lingnan-settlement", "event_id": "asia-qin-han-lingnan-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 74.1971400587, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 74.1971400587, "label": "Government direction", "low": 74.1971400587, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 68.9168901368, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 68.9168901368, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 68.9168901368, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 60.6851612163, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 60.6851612163, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 60.6851612163, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 23.4703730064, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 23.4703730064, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 23.4703730064, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 55.0851788322, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 55.0851788322, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 55.0851788322, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.8891721964, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 69.8891721964, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 69.8891721964, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-han-southwest-commandery-settlement", "event_id": "asia-han-southwest-commandery-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.4311495461, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.4311495461, "label": "Government direction", "low": 81.4311495461, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.2933637335, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.2933637335, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.2933637335, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 54.2490953577, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 54.2490953577, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 54.2490953577, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 13.4528214325, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 13.4528214325, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 13.4528214325, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 74.0946178905, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.7228992979, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 38.4125098388, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 65.6541758856, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.6541758856, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 65.6541758856, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "med-roman-caesarian-augustan-veteran-colonies", "event_id": "med-roman-caesarian-augustan-veteran-colonies", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.4789082022, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.4789082022, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.4789082022, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.9010863811, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.9010863811, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.9010863811, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 50.890286946, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 50.890286946, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 50.890286946, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 32.6949750968, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 32.6949750968, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 32.6949750968, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 37.5466404494, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 37.5466404494, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 37.5466404494, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.1148932145, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.1148932145, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.1148932145, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 62.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-brazil-southern-immigrant-colonization", "event_id": "am-brazil-southern-immigrant-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.2275089271, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 64.2275089271, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.2275089271, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.7962361306, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.7962361306, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.7962361306, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 88.5929602699, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 88.5929602699, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 88.5929602699, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 64.1788447024, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 64.1788447024, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 64.1788447024, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 86.9542887502, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 86.9542887502, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 86.9542887502, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 84.7639546301, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 84.7639546301, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 84.7639546301, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-brazil-march-west-xavante-displacement", "event_id": "am-brazil-march-west-xavante-displacement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 71.2773363677, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 71.2773363677, "label": "Government direction", "low": 71.2773363677, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.7962361306, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.7962361306, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.7962361306, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 73.6838639295, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 73.6838639295, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 73.6838639295, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.588886209, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 76.588886209, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 76.588886209, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 78.4739245476, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 78.4739245476, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 78.4739245476, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 56.4067377234, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 56.4067377234, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 56.4067377234, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-brazil-amazon-highway-frontier", "event_id": "am-brazil-amazon-highway-frontier", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 68.1855320951, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 68.1855320951, "label": "Government direction", "low": 68.1855320951, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.7840703609, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.7840703609, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.7840703609, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 82.4540972976, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 82.4540972976, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 82.4540972976, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 63.164811961, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 63.164811961, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 63.164811961, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 84.2515276094, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 84.2515276094, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 84.2515276094, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 56.3450421797, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 56.3450421797, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 56.3450421797, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-tupi-atlantic-coast-expansion", "event_id": "am-tupi-atlantic-coast-expansion", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.6221694824, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.6733948885, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.0134616087, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7104501214, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 79.7556947846, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 56.6624430386, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3716611322, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.4767387495, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.3265255851, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 11.6428519656, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3862508582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.8734974809, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.4816568979, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.4985832995, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 91.9537830974, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 91.9537830974, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 91.9537830974, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "am-guarani-parana-plata-expansion", "event_id": "am-guarani-parana-plata-expansion", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.6221694824, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.6733948885, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.0134616087, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5944436118, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.617430903, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.804990058, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 45.0617920812, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3716611322, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.4767387495, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.3265255851, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 11.6428519656, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.1213504695, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.9324765255, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 6.0675234745, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 87.5389011808, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-tai-central-mainland-settlement", "event_id": "asia-tai-central-mainland-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 19.8047911161, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 19.8047911161, "label": "Government direction", "low": 19.8047911161, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 38.8144072368, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 38.8144072368, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 38.8144072368, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8921511443, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 71.7745038536, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.3624279048, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 60.9896182796, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 22.5450613899, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 14.3925412911, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 13.0219191056, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.805466382, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 58.0503445634, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 47.9188003707, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 38.5969827652, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.4926842782, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.4926842782, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.4926842782, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-shan-tai-western-mainland-settlement", "event_id": "asia-shan-tai-western-mainland-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 12.5274938955, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 12.5274938955, "label": "Government direction", "low": 12.5274938955, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 17.9958570065, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 17.9958570065, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 17.9958570065, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5944436118, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.1421293025, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.640925458, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 42.5864904807, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 26.7317790644, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 19.0199319634, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 17.2086367801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3862508582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.8734974809, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.4816568979, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.4985832995, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 78.0687278687, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 78.0687278687, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 78.0687278687, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "af-zulu-state-formation-displacement", "event_id": "af-zulu-state-formation-displacement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.3163766634, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 82.3163766634, "label": "Government direction", "low": 82.3163766634, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 17.793101452, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 17.793101452, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 17.793101452, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 66.3051332595, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 66.3051332595, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 66.3051332595, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 26.9605293204, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 26.9605293204, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 26.9605293204, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 57.7537094443, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 57.7537094443, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 57.7537094443, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.7467756418, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.7467756418, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.7467756418, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "af-ngoni-tanzania-conquests", "event_id": "af-ngoni-tanzania-conquests", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 16.6833610322, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 16.6833610322, "label": "Government direction", "low": 16.6833610322, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 11.5647742006, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 11.5647742006, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 11.5647742006, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 61.1747109514, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 61.1747109514, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 61.1747109514, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 17.3886585432, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 17.3886585432, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 17.3886585432, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 59.5128787121, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 59.5128787121, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 59.5128787121, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.2203114917, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.2203114917, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.2203114917, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 62.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-egypt-middle-kingdom-lower-nubia", "event_id": "ancient-egypt-middle-kingdom-lower-nubia", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 85.5952452414, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 85.5952452414, "label": "Government direction", "low": 85.5952452414, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 44.5833767354, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 44.5833767354, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 44.5833767354, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 43.8546511005, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 43.8546511005, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 43.8546511005, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 21.8560622514, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 21.8560622514, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.8560622514, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 40.4265614775, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 40.4265614775, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 40.4265614775, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 19.7535730178, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 19.7535730178, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 19.7535730178, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-egypt-new-kingdom-nubia", "event_id": "ancient-egypt-new-kingdom-nubia", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 78.0203543741, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.0203543741, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.0203543741, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 51.3624803896, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 51.3624803896, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 51.3624803896, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 48.3971766731, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 48.3971766731, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 48.3971766731, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 10.78402639, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 10.78402639, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.78402639, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 43.2758502884, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 43.2758502884, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 43.2758502884, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 24.7457256998, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 24.7457256998, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 24.7457256998, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "medieval-seljuk-turkmen-anatolia", "event_id": "medieval-seljuk-turkmen-anatolia", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 25.2301016287, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 25.2301016287, "label": "Government direction", "low": 25.2301016287, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 41.5707931046, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 41.5707931046, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 41.5707931046, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 54.774472214, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 54.774472214, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 54.774472214, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 20.3813217133, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 20.3813217133, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 20.3813217133, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.805466382, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 59.7282483629, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.0019460326, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 40.2748865647, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.7310810058, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 80.7310810058, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 80.7310810058, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-spanish-hispaniola-conquest-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-spanish-hispaniola-conquest-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 68.6999236196, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 68.6999236196, "label": "Government direction", "low": 68.6999236196, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 81.3140401948, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 81.3140401948, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 81.3140401948, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 55.0528784423, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 55.0528784423, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 55.0528784423, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 50.7079221616, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 50.7079221616, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 50.7079221616, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.358563804, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 90.358563804, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 90.358563804, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.8253811092, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 82.8253811092, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 82.8253811092, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 87.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-spanish-puerto-rico-conquest-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-spanish-puerto-rico-conquest-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 56.3125848768, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 56.3125848768, "label": "Government direction", "low": 56.3125848768, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 71.4337234094, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 71.4337234094, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 71.4337234094, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 60.4350857407, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 60.4350857407, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 60.4350857407, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 50.995931633, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 50.995931633, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 50.995931633, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 86.8241638025, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 86.8241638025, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 86.8241638025, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.1466309185, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 69.1466309185, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 69.1466309185, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 87.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-spanish-cuba-conquest-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-spanish-cuba-conquest-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 55.5886905172, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 55.5886905172, "label": "Government direction", "low": 55.5886905172, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.4245652362, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.4245652362, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 69.4245652362, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 61.2850029551, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 61.2850029551, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 61.2850029551, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 53.0887077327, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 53.0887077327, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.0887077327, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.358563804, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 90.358563804, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 90.358563804, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.8253811092, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 82.8253811092, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 82.8253811092, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-new-france-acadian-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-new-france-acadian-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 49.7745345039, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 49.7745345039, "label": "Government direction", "low": 49.7745345039, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 55.5921745541, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.5921745541, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 55.5921745541, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.3117637293, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.3117637293, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.3117637293, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 46.4961235016, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 46.4961235016, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 46.4961235016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 37.070764003, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 37.070764003, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 37.070764003, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 57.2259714344, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 57.2259714344, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.2259714344, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-new-france-st-lawrence-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-new-france-st-lawrence-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.4870596825, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 64.4870596825, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.4870596825, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 70.0421359321, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 70.0421359321, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 70.0421359321, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.2747653631, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.2747653631, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.2747653631, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 56.513331515, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 56.513331515, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 56.513331515, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 62.4697622731, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 62.4697622731, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 62.4697622731, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 78.5432616481, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 78.5432616481, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 78.5432616481, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-british-chesapeake-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-british-chesapeake-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 53.1587689663, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 53.1587689663, "label": "Government direction", "low": 53.1587689663, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 76.5421544187, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 76.5421544187, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 76.5421544187, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.8397654865, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.8397654865, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.8397654865, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 73.8471036027, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 73.8471036027, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 73.8471036027, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 76.7900659923, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 76.7900659923, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 76.7900659923, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.7816583757, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.7816583757, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.7816583757, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-british-new-england-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-british-new-england-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 48.918083395, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 48.918083395, "label": "Government direction", "low": 48.918083395, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 70.5213799529, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 70.5213799529, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 70.5213799529, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.1468948282, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 93.1468948282, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 93.1468948282, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 73.8471036027, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 73.8471036027, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 73.8471036027, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.2811270721, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 71.2811270721, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 71.2811270721, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 71.1477668388, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 71.1477668388, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 71.1477668388, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-british-middle-colonies-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-british-middle-colonies-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 52.8989442506, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 52.8989442506, "label": "Government direction", "low": 52.8989442506, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.7962361306, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.7962361306, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.7962361306, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 84.8295278945, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 84.8295278945, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 84.8295278945, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 78.0338212771, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 78.0338212771, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 78.0338212771, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 62.6147224794, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 62.6147224794, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 62.6147224794, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.7816583757, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.7816583757, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.7816583757, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-british-carolinas-georgia-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-british-carolinas-georgia-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 52.8989442506, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 52.8989442506, "label": "Government direction", "low": 52.8989442506, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 83.5091766598, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 83.5091766598, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 83.5091766598, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.15133794, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.15133794, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.15133794, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 56.3992824564, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 56.3992824564, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 56.3992824564, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.083142577, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 83.083142577, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 83.083142577, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.7816583757, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.7816583757, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.7816583757, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 87.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-british-barbados-leewards-plantation-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-british-barbados-leewards-plantation-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 55.505532165, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 55.505532165, "label": "Government direction", "low": 55.505532165, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 84.4152158536, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 84.4152158536, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 84.4152158536, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 63.8285477765, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.8285477765, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 63.8285477765, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 81.6754909539, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 81.6754909539, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 81.6754909539, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.0626486345, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 80.0626486345, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 80.0626486345, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 65.3352981777, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.3352981777, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 65.3352981777, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-british-jamaica-conquest-plantation", "event_id": "atlantic-british-jamaica-conquest-plantation", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 67.0986315435, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 67.0986315435, "label": "Government direction", "low": 67.0986315435, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 82.5130388852, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 82.5130388852, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 82.5130388852, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 52.431838165, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 52.431838165, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 52.431838165, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.6259103403, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 76.6259103403, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 76.6259103403, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.9482755078, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 71.9482755078, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 71.9482755078, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 60.6614676331, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 60.6614676331, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 60.6614676331, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 100.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-bahamas-turks-post-lucayan-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-bahamas-turks-post-lucayan-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 58.2002623782, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 58.2002623782, "label": "Government direction", "low": 58.2002623782, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 71.4274191467, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 71.4274191467, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 71.4274191467, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.8353223747, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.8353223747, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.8353223747, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 86.5100496599, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 86.5100496599, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 86.5100496599, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 74.8078321346, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 74.8078321346, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 74.8078321346, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 90.2208759185, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 90.2208759185, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 90.2208759185, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 75.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-loyalist-maritimes-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-loyalist-maritimes-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.6451122324, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.6451122324, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.6451122324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 75.5963024344, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 75.5963024344, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 75.5963024344, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 82.8321027777, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 82.8321027777, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 82.8321027777, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.1424632962, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 68.1424632962, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 68.1424632962, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 48.4318567469, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 48.4318567469, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 48.4318567469, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 66.1556141568, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 66.1556141568, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 66.1556141568, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-loyalist-upper-canada-settlement", "event_id": "atlantic-loyalist-upper-canada-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.6451122324, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.6451122324, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.6451122324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.7941051763, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.7941051763, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.7941051763, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 91.6077721119, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 91.6077721119, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 91.6077721119, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 65.4736682537, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 65.4736682537, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 65.4736682537, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 44.3746701835, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 44.3746701835, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 44.3746701835, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 71.1477668388, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 71.1477668388, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 71.1477668388, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlantic-british-mass-immigration-canadas", "event_id": "atlantic-british-mass-immigration-canadas", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.684255292, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.684255292, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.684255292, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.3124400093, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 88.3124400093, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 88.3124400093, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.4529108104, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 81.4529108104, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 81.4529108104, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 69.6603859282, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 69.6603859282, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 69.6603859282, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 58.564848955, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 58.564848955, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 58.564848955, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.1652876478, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 82.1652876478, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 82.1652876478, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-old-northwest-settlement-dispossession", "event_id": "us-old-northwest-settlement-dispossession", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.914630881, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 61.914630881, "label": "Government direction", "low": 61.914630881, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 87.0568512657, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 87.0568512657, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 87.0568512657, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 91.2297666319, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 91.2297666319, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 91.2297666319, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 73.8471036027, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 73.8471036027, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 73.8471036027, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 60.1173969989, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 60.1173969989, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 60.1173969989, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.1652876478, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 82.1652876478, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 82.1652876478, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-southeast-removal-cotton-frontier", "event_id": "us-southeast-removal-cotton-frontier", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.2330983211, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 64.2330983211, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.2330983211, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.7716727486, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.7716727486, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.7716727486, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.15133794, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.15133794, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.15133794, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 84.9921270279, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 84.9921270279, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 84.9921270279, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 68.7144456349, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 68.7144456349, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 68.7144456349, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.7619455205, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.7619455205, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.7619455205, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 75.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-great-plains-conquest-homesteading", "event_id": "us-great-plains-conquest-homesteading", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 67.6114694291, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 67.6114694291, "label": "Government direction", "low": 67.6114694291, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.2348927267, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.2348927267, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.2348927267, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.15133794, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.15133794, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.15133794, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.588886209, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 76.588886209, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 76.588886209, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 72.7716321983, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 72.7716321983, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 72.7716321983, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.7619455205, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.7619455205, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.7619455205, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-southwest-conquest-navajo-apache", "event_id": "us-southwest-conquest-navajo-apache", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 69.1622582144, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 69.1622582144, "label": "Government direction", "low": 69.1622582144, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.3124400093, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 88.3124400093, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 88.3124400093, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 71.6794472122, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.6794472122, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 71.6794472122, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 65.4027046767, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 65.4027046767, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 65.4027046767, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 77.7102833604, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 77.7102833604, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 77.7102833604, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 71.1996972095, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 71.1996972095, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 71.1996972095, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-california-genocide-settlement", "event_id": "us-california-genocide-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 60.6448003407, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 60.6448003407, "label": "Government direction", "low": 60.6448003407, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 92.8200775854, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 92.8200775854, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 92.8200775854, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 66.2175877072, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 66.2175877072, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 66.2175877072, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 75.3767305963, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 75.3767305963, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 75.3767305963, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.358563804, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 90.358563804, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 90.358563804, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.1731349659, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 77.1731349659, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 77.1731349659, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "us-alaska-colonial-settlement", "event_id": "us-alaska-colonial-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 57.2165505857, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 57.2165505857, "label": "Government direction", "low": 57.2165505857, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 77.9550101575, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.9550101575, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 77.9550101575, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 69.9101960654, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.9101960654, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 69.9101960654, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 36.1429994384, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 36.1429994384, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 36.1429994384, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3881871599, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 79.3881871599, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 79.3881871599, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 66.3930129548, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 66.3930129548, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 66.3930129548, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "canada-red-river-metis-dispossession", "event_id": "canada-red-river-metis-dispossession", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 70.2180573435, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 70.2180573435, "label": "Government direction", "low": 70.2180573435, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.6404712459, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.6404712459, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.6404712459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.532563017, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 81.532563017, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 81.532563017, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.6390029648, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 74.6390029648, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 74.6390029648, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 63.3356316625, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 63.3356316625, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 63.3356316625, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.9425855563, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.9425855563, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.9425855563, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "canada-prairie-treaties-railway-settlement", "event_id": "canada-prairie-treaties-railway-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 72.9989595235, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 72.9989595235, "label": "Government direction", "low": 72.9989595235, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.6404712459, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.6404712459, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.6404712459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 79.9137880941, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 79.9137880941, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 79.9137880941, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.588886209, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 76.588886209, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 76.588886209, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 82.7365467712, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 82.7365467712, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 82.7365467712, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 75.7388370692, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.7388370692, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 75.7388370692, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "canada-british-columbia-land-settlement", "event_id": "canada-british-columbia-land-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 59.0776673776, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 59.0776673776, "label": "Government direction", "low": 59.0776673776, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.9289397438, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.9289397438, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.9289397438, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.15133794, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 83.15133794, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 83.15133794, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 65.4438627838, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 65.4438627838, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 65.4438627838, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.8472525557, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 80.8472525557, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 80.8472525557, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.0500129431, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.0500129431, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.0500129431, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "canada-northern-state-settlement", "event_id": "canada-northern-state-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.072683431, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 84.072683431, "label": "Government direction", "low": 84.072683431, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 89.927580527, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 89.927580527, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 89.927580527, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 67.3880388061, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 67.3880388061, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 67.3880388061, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 48.2634473364, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 48.2634473364, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 48.2634473364, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 57.6448980276, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 57.6448980276, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 57.6448980276, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 57.7109994283, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 57.7109994283, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.7109994283, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "russia-west-siberian-conquest-settlement", "event_id": "russia-west-siberian-conquest-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 73.1021757634, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 73.1021757634, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.1021757634, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 57.1505217517, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 57.1505217517, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 57.1505217517, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 66.2720658194, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 66.2720658194, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 66.2720658194, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 31.9358842106, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.9358842106, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 31.9358842106, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 63.7494464722, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 63.7494464722, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 63.7494464722, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 73.5045268746, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 73.5045268746, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 73.5045268746, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "russia-lena-yakutia-colonization", "event_id": "russia-lena-yakutia-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 54.3717896278, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 54.3717896278, "label": "Government direction", "low": 54.3717896278, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 50.2947727607, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 50.2947727607, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 50.2947727607, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 48.810846873, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 48.810846873, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 48.810846873, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 22.563984413, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 22.563984413, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 22.563984413, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.1975157037, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 66.1975157037, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 66.1975157037, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.683089487, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.683089487, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.683089487, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "russia-baikal-buryat-colonization", "event_id": "russia-baikal-buryat-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 67.8199114464, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 67.8199114464, "label": "Government direction", "low": 67.8199114464, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 65.2478431221, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 65.2478431221, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 65.2478431221, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.3754643399, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.3754643399, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.3754643399, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 35.854989967, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 35.854989967, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 35.854989967, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 48.1391907379, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 48.1391907379, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 48.1391907379, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.683089487, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 70.683089487, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 70.683089487, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 37.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "russia-northeast-siberia-kamchatka-colonization", "event_id": "russia-northeast-siberia-kamchatka-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 62.5720520059, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 62.5720520059, "label": "Government direction", "low": 62.5720520059, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 47.0363301066, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 47.0363301066, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 47.0363301066, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 53.3533724456, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 53.3533724456, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 53.3533724456, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 27.1826626997, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 27.1826626997, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 27.1826626997, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.2016540851, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 80.2016540851, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 80.2016540851, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.1095400657, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 77.1095400657, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 77.1095400657, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "south-africa-xhosa-frontier-wars-settlement", "event_id": "south-africa-xhosa-frontier-wars-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 64.2663780263, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 64.2663780263, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.2663780263, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 78.0721381466, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 78.0721381466, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 78.0721381466, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 70.9405382353, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 70.9405382353, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 70.9405382353, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 27.2368344302, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 27.2368344302, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 27.2368344302, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 75.1449602063, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.1449602063, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 75.1449602063, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 46.7603760975, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 46.7603760975, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 46.7603760975, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "south-africa-great-trek-interior-settlement", "event_id": "south-africa-great-trek-interior-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 30.4138712937, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 30.4138712937, "label": "Government direction", "low": 30.4138712937, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 81.6572854818, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 81.6572854818, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 81.6572854818, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 79.7184079177, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 79.7184079177, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 79.7184079177, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 21.5499516716, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 21.5499516716, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.5499516716, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 62.16724663, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 62.16724663, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 62.16724663, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 65.262858607, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.262858607, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 65.262858607, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "australia-new-south-wales-frontier", "event_id": "australia-new-south-wales-frontier", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 56.6917611193, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 56.6917611193, "label": "Government direction", "low": 56.6917611193, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 80.2444297431, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 80.2444297431, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 80.2444297431, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 77.9912239317, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 77.9912239317, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 77.9912239317, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 69.9661529475, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 69.9661529475, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 69.9661529475, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.7360540866, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 83.7360540866, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 83.7360540866, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 76.6663836709, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 76.6663836709, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 76.6663836709, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "australia-van-diemens-land-frontier", "event_id": "australia-van-diemens-land-frontier", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 66.0933357052, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 66.0933357052, "label": "Government direction", "low": 66.0933357052, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 82.2535879163, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 82.2535879163, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 82.2535879163, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 73.4486983591, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 73.4486983591, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 73.4486983591, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 83.444398926, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 83.444398926, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 83.444398926, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.5767984676, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 93.5767984676, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 93.5767984676, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.3861635664, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 72.3861635664, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 72.3861635664, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 75.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "australia-port-phillip-southeast-pastoral-frontier", "event_id": "australia-port-phillip-southeast-pastoral-frontier", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 55.7156404474, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 55.7156404474, "label": "Government direction", "low": 55.7156404474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 85.5284816173, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 85.5284816173, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 85.5284816173, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 75.3026388524, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.3026388524, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 75.3026388524, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 79.5634482708, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 79.5634482708, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 79.5634482708, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.7360540866, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 83.7360540866, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 83.7360540866, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.3861635664, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 72.3861635664, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 72.3861635664, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 75.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 25.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "australia-queensland-northern-frontier", "event_id": "australia-queensland-northern-frontier", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 58.5036047116, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 58.5036047116, "label": "Government direction", "low": 58.5036047116, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 94.2367736804, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 94.2367736804, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 94.2367736804, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 82.4540972976, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 82.4540972976, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 82.4540972976, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 57.0406219649, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 57.0406219649, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 57.0406219649, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.358563804, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 90.358563804, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 90.358563804, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 81.4533550704, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 81.4533550704, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 81.4533550704, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "australia-western-australia-frontiers", "event_id": "australia-western-australia-frontiers", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 58.0183883534, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 58.0183883534, "label": "Government direction", "low": 58.0183883534, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.2348927267, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 93.2348927267, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 93.2348927267, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 76.2219727848, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 76.2219727848, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 76.2219727848, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 50.4731187193, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 50.4731187193, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 50.4731187193, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.5767984676, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 93.5767984676, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 93.5767984676, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.0500129431, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 79.0500129431, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 79.0500129431, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "new-zealand-company-crown-colonization", "event_id": "new-zealand-company-crown-colonization", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 52.1435052348, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 52.1435052348, "label": "Government direction", "low": 52.1435052348, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 80.742811071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 80.742811071, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 80.742811071, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.532563017, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 81.532563017, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 81.532563017, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 59.7158219181, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 59.7158219181, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 59.7158219181, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 63.6381473055, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 63.6381473055, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 63.6381473055, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.1246583875, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.1246583875, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.1246583875, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "new-zealand-wars-confiscation-military-settlement", "event_id": "new-zealand-wars-confiscation-military-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 65.8676701024, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 65.8676701024, "label": "Government direction", "low": 65.8676701024, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.3032818361, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.3032818361, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.3032818361, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.6872410593, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 86.6872410593, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 86.6872410593, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 67.7834902478, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 67.7834902478, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 67.7834902478, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 68.2317701256, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 68.2317701256, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 68.2317701256, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.633418792, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 72.633418792, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 72.633418792, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "new-zealand-south-island-ngai-tahu-dispossession", "event_id": "new-zealand-south-island-ngai-tahu-dispossession", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 60.6951222214, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 60.6951222214, "label": "Government direction", "low": 60.6951222214, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 86.3032818361, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 86.3032818361, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 86.3032818361, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 80.8353223747, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 80.8353223747, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 80.8353223747, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 59.4100548988, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 59.4100548988, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 59.4100548988, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 51.8570945345, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 51.8570945345, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 51.8570945345, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 58.2488246486, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 58.2488246486, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 58.2488246486, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 25.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 12.5, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 12.5, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 12.5, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-jewish-departure-following-the-1955-pogrom-1955-1957", "event_id": "prospective-jewish-departure-following-the-1955-pogrom-1955-1957", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5355386676, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F1", "high": 75.5766906601, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 54.3948722676, "label": "Government direction", "low": 29.1305574166, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7259592863, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 30.1635641077, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 3.8011673511, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 2.7594927373, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 39.4481556679, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 39.4481556679, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 39.4481556679, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8844479388, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 28.4663179715, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 19.1205283055, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.9111118478, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3795605923, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.0439407719, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-libyan-jewish-remnant-expulsion-property-sequestration-1967-1970", "event_id": "prospective-libyan-jewish-remnant-expulsion-property-sequestration-1967-1970", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.9322944446, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.8145841008, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.7117812001, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.0440285585, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7132850011, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 71.1215444134, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 59.5134405704, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4500445218, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.4013147875, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 74.4013147875, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 74.4013147875, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 52.0925816353, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 25.514632222, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.4104735836, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.9511807345, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 77.9511807345, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 77.9511807345, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-1967-palestinian-cross-border-war-exodus", "event_id": "prospective-1967-palestinian-cross-border-war-exodus", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7608082058, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 95.5925701426, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 94.2069107251, "label": "Government direction", "low": 71.6733907255, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.6020974821, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 54.1508729881, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 23.8509902938, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 14.3606212026, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6504684088, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.4013147875, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.6457671641, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 39.4481556679, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5018029194, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.1000566936, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 32.4437104802, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.2803486359, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.2682468569, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.8402105205, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 36.0298581849, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.6648962139, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-suez-era-jewish-expulsion-and-departure-from-egypt-1956-1957", "event_id": "prospective-suez-era-jewish-expulsion-and-departure-from-egypt-1956-1957", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.6808055102, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 92.6808055102, "label": "Government direction", "low": 92.6808055102, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8820517642, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.3019153244, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.7260344942, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 46.5070917455, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 48.1864454478, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 48.1864454478, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 48.1864454478, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8638289978, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 23.2190236911, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.1155373343, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.601923476, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3795605923, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.0439407719, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-egyptian-jewish-wartime-detention-and-compelled-departure-1967-1971", "event_id": "prospective-egyptian-jewish-wartime-detention-and-compelled-departure-1967-1971", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.895449456, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.895449456, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.895449456, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8307718247, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 47.2695311121, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 36.5283374795, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.3467135805, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6504684088, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.6788150179, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 51.8482611021, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 33.7256558984, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 41.2239669368, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 41.2239669368, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 41.2239669368, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.6168880115, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.0439407719, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 38.4717185006, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 23.7327419266, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The opened source establishes departure from Egypt and an explicit no-return condition only for the final approximately 80 citizen detainees and their families. It does not establish the modal destination or event-wide return outcome for the full arrested cohort.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v5/F7_1967_EGYPT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-saint-pierre-miquelon-british-deportation-1778", "event_id": "prospective-saint-pierre-miquelon-british-deportation-1778", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8951170479, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 88.5323237711, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 87.188629402, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.0440285585, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8820517642, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 16.0997056004, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 4.8805321822, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 4.3048820216, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.4013147875, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 74.4013147875, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 74.4013147875, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8586239999, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 27.3841869046, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 15.4276923304, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 13.2465868986, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-saint-pierre-miquelon-british-deportation-1793-1815", "event_id": "prospective-saint-pierre-miquelon-british-deportation-1793-1815", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.6676635836, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.6482528547, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.477646523, "label": "Government direction", "low": 64.4146112183, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6349301058, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 40.8118714444, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 6.7800880482, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 4.3048820216, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7272621861, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 36.753904718, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 13.0353585153, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 9.4801233308, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7574432403, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 78.1302737101, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 71.1269107349, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.8745977383, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5807844762, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 58.5724143355, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 28.6696057413, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.6508619524, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 22.0744673286, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-circassian-danube-serbian-border-settlement", "event_id": "prospective-circassian-danube-serbian-border-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.0004135459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.4529613343, "label": "Government direction", "low": 85.5952452414, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.9320231434, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6594883998, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 45.9879167655, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.8618027442, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6347085099, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 77.2751277829, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 49.0471812085, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2619898279, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 89.5693036471, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.1866361141, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 15.7682864379, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.52182845, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 54.755830056, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 13.296850824, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 6.9386750553, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 25.525887836, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 14.9245522169, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 13.0647890168, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-circassian-danube-dobruja-agricultural-settlement", "event_id": "prospective-circassian-danube-dobruja-agricultural-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.6486664006, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.9402722224, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.2434980962, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.9320231434, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6594883998, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 45.9879167655, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.8618027442, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6347085099, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.7186170523, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 74.3482516881, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 47.1894680437, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.4428814345, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 85.0470134834, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 66.2370437023, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 29.335156929, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3930990634, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 67.6287687105, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 17.65121238, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 6.9386750553, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7144646738, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 41.6183216412, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 18.2861231586, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 13.0647890168, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-circassian-uzunyayla-collective-settlement", "event_id": "prospective-circassian-uzunyayla-collective-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.4966367455, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.0934877674, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.0914684411, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 44.5612241581, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 44.5612241581, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 44.5612241581, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6347085099, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.7186170523, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 74.3482516881, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 47.1894680437, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8377125375, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 33.1398581013, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 20.1872493147, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.9111118478, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.4200365235, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 57.9963476539, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-circassian-wadi-al-sir-settlement-1880", "event_id": "prospective-circassian-wadi-al-sir-settlement-1880", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.2401621119, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.9563314039, "label": "Government direction", "low": 74.8349938074, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.9259243529, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.7073709512, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 61.8838958722, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 57.2998062392, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5690139966, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 74.6514675043, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 42.4777298755, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.2876434082, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 3.4042750538, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 3.4042750538, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.4042750538, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.337479145, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 66.2520854975, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-bikini-nuclear-test-displacement", "event_id": "prospective-bikini-nuclear-test-displacement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.9322944446, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.0882353677, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.876775734, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.3176798254, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9073203156, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 40.2724373687, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 34.1714699828, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 31.0044689296, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 80.1238145571, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 80.1238145571, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 80.1238145571, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.1544046723, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 47.3776358296, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.4722966205, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8219600229, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.9143849796, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.88148573, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 45.1103872647, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-enewetak-nuclear-test-displacement", "event_id": "prospective-enewetak-nuclear-test-displacement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.9322944446, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.0882353677, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.876775734, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.3176798254, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7763245676, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 50.0971184719, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 35.7190489482, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 27.7295752286, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 80.1238145571, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 80.1238145571, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 80.1238145571, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.1544046723, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 47.3776358296, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.4722966205, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8219600229, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 32.8407934698, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 18.2938285767, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 15.0367957549, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-enjebi-nuclear-test-displacement-and-land-claim", "event_id": "prospective-enjebi-nuclear-test-displacement-and-land-claim", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.9322944446, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.0882353677, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.876775734, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.3176798254, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7763245676, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 50.0971184719, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 35.7190489482, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 27.7295752286, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 80.1238145571, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 80.1238145571, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 80.1238145571, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.1544046723, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 47.3776358296, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.4722966205, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8219600229, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 66.3609950075, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.0746458984, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 48.5569972926, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 100.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-rongelap-and-ailinginae-fallout-evacuation-and-return-chain", "event_id": "prospective-rongelap-and-ailinginae-fallout-evacuation-and-return-chain", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8158238593, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.5117047874, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 87.1439219468, "label": "Government direction", "low": 71.0940907158, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8759044518, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 14.6850333471, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 2.5978615871, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 2.2754785294, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 80.1238145571, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 80.1238145571, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 80.1238145571, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5070079173, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 66.1544046723, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 33.2444441777, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.8551964054, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.88148573, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.88148573, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.88148573, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": "not_applicable", "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "", "status": "structural_not_applicable", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "af-ngoni-mbelwa-northern-malawi-conquests", "event_id": "af-ngoni-mbelwa-northern-malawi-conquests", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 14.3316138869, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 14.3316138869, "label": "Government direction", "low": 14.3316138869, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 7.8561946135, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 7.8561946135, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.8561946135, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.2340767474, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 95.7668562384, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 81.9155733794, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 19.1745309766, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5525527387, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 58.2346764693, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 24.4138692927, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 13.4899503401, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5144495329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.9041953451, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 45.3866650544, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 23.3491486389, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2954255353, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 85.023541954, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 49.30547208, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 14.5660954809, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "south-africa-cape-khoekhoe-land-labor-dispossession-1652-1806", "event_id": "south-africa-cape-khoekhoe-land-labor-dispossession-1652-1806", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6306728102, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 69.7020309152, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 51.959290788, "label": "Government direction", "low": 32.7693119395, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3341830377, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 89.9460026447, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 69.9146987656, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 23.3643064103, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1390595235, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 94.9047369893, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.3591221796, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 8.8106893402, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2905629108, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 82.7300718537, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 40.5638933794, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 11.7863629337, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.5282014717, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 63.2193833473, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.2803486359, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.095739428, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 95.2130286005, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 4.7869713995, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "correctionEvidence": "Guelke and Shell, ‘Landscape of Conquest,’ pp. 803–824, especially the loss of watered Khoikhoi land and survivor incorporation as settler clients and laborers; Adhikari, The Anatomy of a South African Genocide, chapter 1; frozen successor boundary in second_pass_v5_676/events_enriched.json", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "publicDisplayCorrected": true, "reviewReason": "The positive frozen cells describe dispossessed Khoikhoi incorporated as servants within their own homeland. They do not establish a distinct population brought from elsewhere as unfree labor. Imported African and Asian slave labor existed at the Cape but is outside this Khoikhoi-bounded successor and cannot be borrowed into its public trait.", "status": "supported_point", "underlyingRecodeFollowup": "Review scs_exogenous_labor_triad=4 and pel_unfree_incomer_share=3 against the successor boundary in the next statistical release; the current positive referents are local affected people, not imported incomers. Do not mutate v5.", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "south-africa-cape-san-commando-clearance-1700s-1806", "event_id": "south-africa-cape-san-commando-clearance-1700s-1806", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6985700877, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 60.1167405961, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 42.907290039, "label": "Government direction", "low": 29.9737493651, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6515227114, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 40.8520322929, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 9.2158006623, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 6.0043034355, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5525527387, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.3479014413, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 42.7166017986, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 23.6031753121, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5144495329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 86.8636765225, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 74.4652825273, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 38.3086298163, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2954255353, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 87.6320653639, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 58.1351875191, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 17.1746188908, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-han-hexi-conquest-tuntian-121-bce-onward", "event_id": "asia-han-hexi-conquest-tuntian-121-bce-onward", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7707600936, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.6482528547, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.948794878, "label": "Government direction", "low": 74.7242622106, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.1483431835, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 91.1931561711, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 40.6319614966, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 6.0274745196, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.0647509969, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 84.4606779972, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 39.6581500419, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 10.2128251614, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.095739428, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 97.6065143003, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.1804570992, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-han-western-regions-oasis-garrisons-tuntian", "event_id": "asia-han-western-regions-oasis-garrisons-tuntian", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.9351189079, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 94.6970159395, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 94.3290804883, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.2089067291, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.4189474744, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 70.1548053318, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 28.7614880364, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 12.0495527733, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.0738863241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 3.849039502, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 3.849039502, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.849039502, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1093678658, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 97.2658033543, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 8.202589937, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-magna-graecia-sybaris-foundation-chora", "event_id": "prospective-magna-graecia-sybaris-foundation-chora", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8138744566, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 49.269130917, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 37.6674514453, "label": "Government direction", "low": 30.6565765763, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5307116815, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 46.9288318535, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.1468948282, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 67.268471581, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.0842158236, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5991573487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 49.6582079325, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 15.9790125587, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.573942799, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-magna-graecia-siris-polieium-seizure", "event_id": "prospective-magna-graecia-siris-polieium-seizure", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.875222968, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 23.2895374393, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 12.3532341295, "label": "Government direction", "low": 10.8118342392, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6349301058, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 40.8118714444, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 6.7800880482, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 4.3048820216, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.0647509969, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 6.4750996917, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7089831509, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 42.3482718065, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 18.683923421, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 13.2465868986, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.095739428, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.573942799, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-sicily-himera-foundation-chora", "event_id": "prospective-sicily-himera-foundation-chora", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7317262251, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 55.5203487408, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 39.212714081, "label": "Government direction", "low": 28.6929712502, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3997804966, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.0402666864, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 10.051306606, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 4.0183163464, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 91.2891816634, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.2936935502, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 19.657355318, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 81.0264844472, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 12.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 2.6687950425, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 10.2128251614, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 10.2128251614, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 10.2128251614, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7027097709, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 47.0693973778, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 24.6764385272, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 17.3403744629, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-magna-graecia-metapontium-achaean-resettlement", "event_id": "prospective-magna-graecia-metapontium-achaean-resettlement", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 44.2591031964, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 44.2591031964, "label": "Government direction", "low": 44.2591031964, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6959189414, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 37.4253665417, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 10.083445444, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.0172606788, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.1468948282, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.8422757304, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 21.5150684828, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.578431582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 42.1568418022, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 10.2128251614, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 10.2128251614, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 10.2128251614, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2203504162, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 87.5389011808, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 43.4487166617, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.573942799, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "south-africa-1913-land-act-reserve-dispossession", "event_id": "south-africa-1913-land-act-reserve-dispossession", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8577187195, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.4564101281, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.2144533788, "label": "Government direction", "low": 66.2282820818, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.4627348249, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.0624076777, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 74.2020879352, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 34.3358901686, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7018361081, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 29.8163891906, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3361296328, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 70.9093268881, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 13.4540062018, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 4.5222901637, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.4062763888, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.8163055099, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 50.3202867588, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 20.4439443855, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1059221108, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 97.3519472291, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.9441583128, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "south-africa-group-areas-urban-forced-removals", "event_id": "south-africa-group-areas-urban-forced-removals", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.1556366246, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 84.1556366246, "label": "Government direction", "low": 84.1556366246, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7276097902, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.9956965645, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 91.7479073033, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 66.7566755808, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8839934904, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 13.4583641222, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 2.1015009555, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 1.8577131648, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3116545288, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.9139198118, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 25.9241305511, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 8.0793726913, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 69.0021260193, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 51.8052084083, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 33.3200179676, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2204881927, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 94.2716959091, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 74.0199054566, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 16.3205151746, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "south-africa-bantustan-consolidation-removals", "event_id": "south-africa-bantustan-consolidation-removals", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.9285857578, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.5117047874, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.7050871455, "label": "Government direction", "low": 82.3702805703, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.6233913659, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.0438256763, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 80.8207572665, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 50.3829622619, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9256914734, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 7.4308526592, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.0952314228, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 90.4768577157, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3862508582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 87.3099668081, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 67.1456181315, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 25.9350526267, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1059221108, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 10.5922110837, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlas-cahokia-aztalan-colonial-settlement", "event_id": "atlas-cahokia-aztalan-colonial-settlement", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7924406156, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 28.8956800432, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 10.2717370188, "label": "Government direction", "low": 8.1397416068, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.819694497, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 26.6828508703, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 10.5555186696, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.652300566, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.0647509969, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 6.4750996917, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1096713043, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 89.0328695747, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5034179207, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 49.6582079325, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlas-cahokia-trempealeau-colony", "event_id": "atlas-cahokia-trempealeau-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3726535238, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F1", "high": 68.0979464902, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 14.3921861234, "label": "Government direction", "low": 5.3632988747, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6529391654, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 38.7243998019, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 6.1541971428, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 4.0183163464, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2649093305, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 85.1519189195, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 43.950328006, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 11.6428519656, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7852540975, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 21.4745902503, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5034179207, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 49.6582079325, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-japanese-south-manchuria-railway-zone-settlement-1905-1931", "event_id": "asia-japanese-south-manchuria-railway-zone-settlement-1905-1931", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.832851807, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 61.3345283045, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 53.5746079086, "label": "Government direction", "low": 44.6197090078, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.627670614, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 72.5108365173, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 56.2044759345, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 35.2778979221, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.2340767474, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 84.0630188693, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 31.9155733794, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 7.4706936075, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5676071509, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 43.239284914, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.095739428, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 95.2130286005, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 4.7869713995, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 50.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "asia-manchukuo-state-agricultural-colonization-1932-1945", "event_id": "asia-manchukuo-state-agricultural-colonization-1932-1945", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 91.8390807881, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.8390807881, "label": "Government direction", "low": 91.8390807881, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 72.5897543064, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 66.0754258526, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 53.3873660155, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.3373919752, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 67.6327468193, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.6381406762, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 91.8476397449, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 62.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 13.4899503401, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.561963209, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.3141103731, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 24.6632778833, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 3.3221595873, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 2.5888105546, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-ariminum-integrated-colony", "event_id": "gr-roman-ariminum-integrated-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 76.2765550474, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 76.2765550474, "label": "Government direction", "low": 76.2765550474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7200214457, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.9489139305, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 45.7639959151, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 32.9510584993, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-senones-expulsion-sena", "event_id": "gr-roman-senones-expulsion-sena", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 85.2101368607, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 85.2101368607, "label": "Government direction", "low": 85.2101368607, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 67.3652108313, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 59.6092155717, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 48.1628225404, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 87.4340433819, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.2610398758, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 32.7347920829, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5647834195, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 95.1454265268, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.7365593416, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8844479388, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 63.5176628112, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 58.7512892621, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 51.9624566876, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.8047152702, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 64.8047152702, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-friniates-lowland-transfer", "event_id": "gr-roman-friniates-lowland-transfer", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.482279822, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.482279822, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.482279822, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 37.3926330449, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 22.5133446018, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 18.1902447541, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.0738863241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.6423105953, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8844479388, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 31.5544276874, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 22.6120958478, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.9992215637, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6742324678, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.4112295705, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 44.2495396954, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 29.8344763458, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-q-fulvius-ligures-lowlands", "event_id": "gr-roman-q-fulvius-ligures-lowlands", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.482279822, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.482279822, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.482279822, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 37.3926330449, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 22.5133446018, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 18.1902447541, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.0738863241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.6423105953, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8844479388, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 31.5544276874, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 22.6120958478, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.9992215637, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6742324678, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.4112295705, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 44.2495396954, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 29.8344763458, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-cremona-placentia-twin-colonies", "event_id": "gr-roman-cremona-placentia-twin-colonies", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.4230007978, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.6991631797, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.6050563708, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 48.7671197779, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 39.4026680799, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6347085099, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 77.2751277829, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 49.0471812085, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 94.662409915, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 5.337590085, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 76.8912397299, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.0684213127, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.3856785068, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 68.4547999568, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 59.9245796877, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-bononia-boii-land", "event_id": "gr-roman-bononia-boii-land", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.4230007978, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.6991631797, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.2529336787, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.7572735565, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.0505453878, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 76.8912397299, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.0684213127, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-mutina-parma-boii-land", "event_id": "gr-roman-mutina-parma-boii-land", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.4230007978, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.6991631797, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 65.6657894174, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 57.5059090779, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 46.4634011265, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-transalpine-gauls-aquileia", "event_id": "gr-roman-transalpine-gauls-aquileia", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 87.8217087217, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 87.8217087217, "label": "Government direction", "low": 87.8217087217, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 65.069486983, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 56.767889201, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.8670986921, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.2917565467, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 76.3618841622, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 34.5925052477, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7495305509, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 94.5894223512, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 92.7813781013, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 69.5424774461, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 16.7809869001, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 16.7809869001, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.3935258248, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 67.3935258248, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 67.3935258248, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 87.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 87.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-salassian-land-eporedia", "event_id": "gr-roman-salassian-land-eporedia", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.2204166456, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.2204166456, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.2204166456, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8820517642, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 56.1568627583, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 50.294144833, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 44.3620391795, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 76.6186916789, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 39.0940167687, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 15.0078729721, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 70.7709357406, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 44.6027740958, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 23.5336215652, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.9823363795, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.7093438282, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.5212375603, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 12.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-pisaurum-ager-gallicus-colony-184", "event_id": "gr-roman-pisaurum-ager-gallicus-colony-184", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.8481099305, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.6058841704, "label": "Government direction", "low": 75.442941626, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3786989604, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.2917565467, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.7235995538, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-ager-gallicus-lex-flaminia-232", "event_id": "gr-roman-ager-gallicus-lex-flaminia-232", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.0004135459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.4529613343, "label": "Government direction", "low": 85.5952452414, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.2529336787, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.7572735565, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.0505453878, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 87.4340433819, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.2610398758, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 32.7347920829, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.4112295705, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 57.0604954797, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 49.9501307513, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-ager-ligustinus-gallicus-allotment-173", "event_id": "gr-roman-ager-ligustinus-gallicus-allotment-173", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.6486664006, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.9402722224, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.2434980962, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3786989604, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.2917565467, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.7235995538, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6742324678, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.4112295705, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 44.2495396954, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 29.8344763458, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-ager-gallicus-picenum-allotment-132", "event_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-ager-gallicus-picenum-allotment-132", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.94517211, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.9148939987, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.5400038056, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.0776098405, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 18.1776476332, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.0245980799, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.0998258709, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 49.9501307513, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-salassi-enslavement-augusta-praetoria-25", "event_id": "gr-roman-salassi-enslavement-augusta-praetoria-25", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.4230007978, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 89.4230007978, "label": "Government direction", "low": 89.4230007978, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.9259243529, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.8288299065, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.535060758, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 51.4212651945, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 87.4340433819, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.2610398758, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 32.7347920829, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 95.8132823255, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 89.0940167687, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 34.2024636187, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5144495329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 77.4067132528, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 56.0825983879, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.8516665466, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.8047152702, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 64.8047152702, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-roman-apuan-ligures-resettlement", "event_id": "ancient-roman-apuan-ligures-resettlement", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 87.0712536525, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 87.0712536525, "label": "Government direction", "low": 87.0712536525, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.9259243529, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 54.9174947649, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 51.3108116285, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 47.5099300528, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7761446347, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 88.1312840242, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 84.7081130947, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 65.7457474928, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5647834195, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 77.7241216707, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.5585476468, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 34.2024636187, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 16.7809869001, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 16.7809869001, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 61.6894405654, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 61.6894405654, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 61.6894405654, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 62.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 62.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 62.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-latin-war-viritane-distribution-340", "event_id": "gr-roman-latin-war-viritane-distribution-340", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.0004135459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.4529613343, "label": "Government direction", "low": 85.5952452414, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.4112295705, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 57.0604954797, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 49.9501307513, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-antium-338-colony-integration", "event_id": "gr-roman-antium-338-colony-integration", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.4996987695, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.4996987695, "label": "Government direction", "low": 81.4996987695, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 37.3926330449, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 22.5133446018, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 18.1902447541, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 38.2874831091, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.7919317171, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 16.7809869001, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 16.7809869001, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 57.1305878505, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 57.1305878505, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.1305878505, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-cales-ausonian-colony", "event_id": "gr-roman-cales-ausonian-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.0178324934, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.0178324934, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.2529336787, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.7572735565, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.0505453878, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7200214457, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.9489139305, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 45.7639959151, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 32.9510584993, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 64.0183010755, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 31.8046487548, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-tarracina-colony-329", "event_id": "gr-roman-tarracina-colony-329", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 77.7946887713, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.7946887713, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 72.2859988768, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 27.8077828451, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-fregellae-contested-colony", "event_id": "gr-roman-fregellae-contested-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.4230007978, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.6991631797, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 55.9995957631, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 45.5424445028, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 36.7972074722, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 59.7758016688, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.049916336, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 47.3147028497, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-saticula-capture-colony-316-313", "event_id": "gr-roman-saticula-capture-colony-316-313", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.6817233519, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.4965459797, "label": "Government direction", "low": 76.2765550474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 35.693211631, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 20.410038108, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 16.4908233402, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 73.8574779927, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 34.4630541383, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 13.7472251629, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.4563498733, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 22.8765322676, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 10.4397026023, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-auruncian-destruction-colonial-reorganization-315-296", "event_id": "gr-roman-auruncian-destruction-colonial-reorganization-315-296", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.8114289368, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 85.908868231, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.4062606324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 57.699017177, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 47.6457509966, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 38.4966288861, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.3312049575, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 8.0063851275, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.4594014687, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 58.5342106563, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 23.3491486389, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.7968679522, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 65.4974741054, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.335769133, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sora-contested-colony-315-303", "event_id": "gr-roman-sora-contested-colony-315-303", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 77.7946887713, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.7946887713, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 69.6172038343, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 20.8558371338, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 8.0063851275, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 76.8912397299, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.0684213127, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.9324270057, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.9324270057, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9324270057, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-luceria-314-destruction-colony", "event_id": "gr-roman-luceria-314-destruction-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.8114289368, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 85.908868231, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.4062606324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 65.9523550926, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 57.8605800503, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 46.7499668017, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7950972729, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 66.4334448445, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 57.7830835303, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 45.943172135, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.9250014672, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 49.6737884871, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.8147486374, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-pontiae-volscian-colony-313", "event_id": "gr-roman-pontiae-volscian-colony-313", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 76.2765550474, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 76.2765550474, "label": "Government direction", "low": 76.2765550474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 35.693211631, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 20.410038108, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 16.4908233402, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 89.0328695747, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 49.3255104302, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 6.9386750553, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 6.9386750553, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 6.9386750553, "status": "supported_point", "value": 5.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-interamna-lirenas-colony-312", "event_id": "gr-roman-interamna-lirenas-colony-312", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.1998570758, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.1185732823, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 68.2712500251, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 60.730584353, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 49.0688617342, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-alba-colony-and-aequian-land-sequence", "event_id": "prospective-alba-colony-and-aequian-land-sequence", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7409412487, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.711494558, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.1631803396, "label": "Government direction", "low": 66.8056194237, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3031910289, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 73.9857791311, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 14.19857981, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 4.3048820216, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.144622213, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7557185522, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.960039733, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 78.7752196635, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 59.5318949549, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.2954255353, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.6379035723, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 24.30547208, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.1804570992, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-carseoli-colony-and-marsic-land-sequence", "event_id": "prospective-carseoli-colony-and-marsic-land-sequence", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7811530822, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 94.3127866341, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 92.7194637062, "label": "Government direction", "low": 72.4280948529, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5669532492, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.5730899013, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.5135248847, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 21.2684148229, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.0738863241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1361710022, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 96.5957249462, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 10.2128251614, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.2954255353, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 77.6379035723, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 24.30547208, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.1804570992, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-narnia-nequinum-capture-colony-300-299", "event_id": "gr-roman-narnia-nequinum-capture-colony-300-299", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.6817233519, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.4965459797, "label": "Government direction", "low": 76.2765550474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 35.693211631, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 20.410038108, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 16.4908233402, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 73.8574779927, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 34.4630541383, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 13.7472251629, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-venusia-291-conquest-colony", "event_id": "gr-roman-venusia-291-conquest-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 77.7946887713, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.7946887713, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 62.5535122647, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 53.6539670627, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 43.3511239739, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 42.4742007835, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 36.4193223894, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 32.9510584993, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 60.9845393382, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 26.0548244427, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 13.7472251629, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-curius-sabine-allotment-290", "event_id": "gr-roman-curius-sabine-allotment-290", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.9073889546, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 81.7376550225, "label": "Government direction", "low": 76.5022206502, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6742324678, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.4112295705, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 44.2495396954, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 29.8344763458, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-hadria-praetuttian-land-colony-290-286", "event_id": "gr-roman-hadria-praetuttian-land-colony-290-286", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 73.9248079021, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 73.9248079021, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.9248079021, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3786989604, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.2917565467, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.7235995538, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 86.3640745322, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 36.9941328227, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 8.0063851275, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.9324270057, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.9324270057, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9324270057, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-cosa-vulci-land", "event_id": "gr-roman-cosa-vulci-land", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.4230007978, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.6991631797, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 68.2712500251, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 60.730584353, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 49.0688617342, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.3312049575, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 8.0063851275, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 76.8912397299, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 42.0684213127, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.3935258248, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 62.7520179768, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9324270057, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-beneventum-samnite-colony", "event_id": "gr-roman-beneventum-samnite-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 76.2765550474, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 76.2765550474, "label": "Government direction", "low": 76.2765550474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 35.6186880666, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 28.842232634, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 26.0955457823, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 16.7809869001, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 16.7809869001, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "supported_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.9324270057, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.9324270057, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9324270057, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-paestum-integrated-colony", "event_id": "gr-roman-paestum-integrated-colony", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 73.9248079021, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 73.9248079021, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.9248079021, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 38.2874831091, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.7919317171, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-picentes-paestum", "event_id": "gr-roman-picentes-paestum", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.482279822, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.482279822, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.482279822, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 41.4109493914, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 27.4866553982, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 22.2085611005, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 87.4340433819, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.2610398758, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 32.7347920829, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.6423105953, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8844479388, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 28.3361930238, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 18.9734026896, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 30.9832941839, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 21.1588163832, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 18.5221953648, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-brundisium-capture-colony-267-244", "event_id": "gr-roman-brundisium-capture-colony-267-244", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 76.2765550474, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 76.2765550474, "label": "Government direction", "low": 76.2765550474, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7200214457, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 58.280118888, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 42.057446536, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 30.2822634568, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 64.0183010755, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 31.8046487548, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.9324270057, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.9324270057, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9324270057, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-aesernia-samnite-land", "event_id": "gr-roman-aesernia-samnite-land", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.1998570758, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.1185732823, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 55.9995957631, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 45.5424445028, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 36.7972074722, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-spoletium-colony-land-allotment-241", "event_id": "gr-roman-spoletium-colony-land-allotment-241", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 77.7946887713, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.7946887713, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 38.2874831091, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.7919317171, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-capua-punishment-confiscation-dispersal-211-210", "event_id": "gr-roman-capua-punishment-confiscation-dispersal-211-210", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 93.4353889176, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 93.4353889176, "label": "Government direction", "low": 93.4353889176, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.9259243529, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 65.67588195, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 62.9298895279, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 58.2683172379, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 35.9829711761, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 35.9829711761, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 35.9829711761, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.926568931, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 61.9552516039, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 32.6892547556, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8621355989, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 40.3050301178, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 30.759186885, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 26.5185900064, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-scipio-veteran-allotments-samnium-apulia-201-200", "event_id": "gr-roman-scipio-veteran-allotments-samnium-apulia-201-200", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 87.2969192553, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.4275831106, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.8917509509, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6742324678, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.4112295705, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 44.2495396954, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 29.8344763458, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-campanian-coastal-colonies-197-194", "event_id": "gr-roman-campanian-coastal-colonies-197-194", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.1998570758, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.1185732823, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-croton-greek-city-colony-194", "event_id": "gr-roman-croton-greek-city-colony-194", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 73.9248079021, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 73.9248079021, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.9248079021, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 37.3926330449, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 22.5133446018, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 18.1902447541, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7200214457, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 56.762196256, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 39.9492834513, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-tempsa-bruttian-land-colony-194", "event_id": "gr-roman-tempsa-bruttian-land-colony-194", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.3299762066, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.9838568679, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.9248079021, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-sipontum-colony-on-former-arpian-land-194-bce", "event_id": "prospective-sipontum-colony-on-former-arpian-land-194-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7409412487, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 82.6844746076, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 76.6303665456, "label": "Government direction", "low": 56.7785994733, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.0679768566, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 93.2023143444, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.144622213, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1096713043, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 89.0328695747, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8165098753, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 18.3490124655, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.2203504162, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 85.1454154811, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 32.5865374963, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.1804570992, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-buxentum-pyxus-colony-194-186", "event_id": "gr-roman-buxentum-pyxus-colony-194-186", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.3299762066, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.9838568679, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.9248079021, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 49.6642873069, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 37.7014844519, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.461899016, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.3312049575, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 8.0063851275, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.3935258248, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 62.7520179768, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9324270057, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-copia-thurii-land-allotment-193", "event_id": "gr-roman-copia-thurii-land-allotment-193", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.8481099305, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.6058841704, "label": "Government direction", "low": 75.442941626, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.2529336787, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.7572735565, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.0505453878, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-vibo-valentia-bruttian-land-colony-192", "event_id": "gr-roman-vibo-valentia-bruttian-land-colony-192", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 75.442941626, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 75.442941626, "label": "Government direction", "low": 75.442941626, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.2529336787, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.7572735565, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.0505453878, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7200214457, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.9489139305, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 45.7639959151, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 32.9510584993, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-potentia-picene-land-colony-184", "event_id": "gr-roman-potentia-picene-land-colony-184", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.8481099305, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.6058841704, "label": "Government direction", "low": 75.442941626, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 66.2620918519, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 58.2439289547, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 47.059703561, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 83.7186170523, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.059351303, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 29.0193657533, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-saturnia-caletran-land-colony-183", "event_id": "gr-roman-saturnia-caletran-land-colony-183", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 75.442941626, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 75.442941626, "label": "Government direction", "low": 75.442941626, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7200214457, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 56.762196256, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 39.9492834513, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-graviscae-tarquinian-land-colony-181", "event_id": "gr-roman-graviscae-tarquinian-land-colony-181", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.1998570758, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.1185732823, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.7946887713, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-vallo-diano-lucania-allotment-132-130", "event_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-vallo-diano-lucania-allotment-132-130", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.94517211, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.9148939987, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.5400038056, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 64.2529336787, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 55.7572735565, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 45.0505453878, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.0776098405, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 18.1776476332, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 72.0245980799, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.0998258709, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 49.9501307513, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-northern-campania-land-division-131", "event_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-northern-campania-land-division-131", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.94517211, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.9148939987, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.5400038056, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.0940476491, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 50.9804454801, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 61.5486196177, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 50.6562495448, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 39.4741522891, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-northern-apulia-allotment-130", "event_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-northern-apulia-allotment-130", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.94517211, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.9148939987, "label": "Government direction", "low": 78.5400038056, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.0776098405, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 18.1776476332, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 61.5486196177, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 50.6562495448, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 39.4741522891, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-hirpinian-land-adjudication-130-123", "event_id": "gr-roman-gracchan-hirpinian-land-adjudication-130-123", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.4633058339, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 85.5369213013, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.0581375295, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.9501866148, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 62.8085375923, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 50.747798324, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.0776098405, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 18.1776476332, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6757029045, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.3798402985, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 73.9232145023, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 49.9501307513, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-fregellae-destruction-fabrateria", "event_id": "gr-roman-fregellae-destruction-fabrateria", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.3991214698, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.3991214698, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.3991214698, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.6050563708, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 48.7671197779, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 39.4026680799, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8152528685, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 68.0245548141, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.7784941088, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 49.5498416672, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 71.0871010785, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 45.2019955588, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 23.8497869031, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 62.1559618214, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 62.1559618214, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 62.1559618214, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 37.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 37.5, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "supported_point", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-scolacium-minervia-gracchan-colony-123-122", "event_id": "gr-roman-scolacium-minervia-gracchan-colony-123-122", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 87.0712536525, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.1864740678, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.6660853481, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 68.2712500251, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 60.730584353, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 49.0688617342, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 10.67518017, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-tarentum-neptunia-gracchan-colony-123-122", "event_id": "gr-roman-tarentum-neptunia-gracchan-colony-123-122", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.6660853481, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.6660853481, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.6660853481, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 38.2874831091, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.7919317171, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-narbo-martius-colony-volcae-land-118", "event_id": "gr-roman-narbo-martius-colony-volcae-land-118", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.0178324934, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.0178324934, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 68.2712500251, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 60.730584353, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 49.0688617342, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 85.5763302171, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 68.1601955894, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 30.8770789181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 38.2874831091, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.7919317171, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 28.7643408248, "status": "supported_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 52.343616451, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 52.343616451, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-pompeii-80", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-pompeii-80", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.6660853481, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.6660853481, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.6660853481, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7200214457, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 58.280118888, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 42.057446536, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 30.2822634568, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 40.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 9.9724367925, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 9.9724367925, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 54.9324270057, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 54.9324270057, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9324270057, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "atlas-canary-lanzarote-fuerteventura-conquest-1402-1405", "event_id": "atlas-canary-lanzarote-fuerteventura-conquest-1402-1405", "traits": [ { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7317152667, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 44.3708999298, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 23.9743892148, "label": "Government direction", "low": 17.5424265978, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2793389315, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 84.0238952504, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 42.8074537902, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 11.9577884031, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3786989604, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.2993822279, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 63.8218764664, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 24.1692782698, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 94.5164347874, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 74.6627552151, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 16.1587453826, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3730735329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 91.0436749946, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.9931375021, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.3510282824, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5780987827, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.2050551791, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.0287344574, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 37.014933445, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "atlas-canary-gran-canaria-conquest-1478-1483", "event_id": "atlas-canary-gran-canaria-conquest-1478-1483", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.6376453809, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 94.1908279334, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.8896508296, "label": "Government direction", "low": 57.9553660203, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.377266676, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 85.5940179844, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 61.8148568875, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 23.320685587, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3786989604, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.677387708, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.8200452483, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 24.5472837498, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 91.8476397449, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 62.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 13.4899503401, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3730735329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 91.0436749946, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.9931375021, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.3510282824, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5780987827, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 81.7938657338, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 68.5068801174, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 39.6037439996, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "atlas-canary-la-gomera-revolt-repression", "event_id": "atlas-canary-la-gomera-revolt-repression", "traits": [ { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6620573775, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 67.6304692552, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 51.1076655234, "label": "Government direction", "low": 33.836207008, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5885641878, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 79.7821199538, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 65.6488103343, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 38.6385387357, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.0647509969, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 95.1436752312, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 1.6187749229, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.9324765255, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 76.4387666946, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.6846236896, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.2178825944, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 21.7882594432, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "atlas-canary-la-palma-conquest-1492-1493", "event_id": "atlas-canary-la-palma-conquest-1492-1493", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7924406156, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 88.0523582711, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 84.9229816176, "label": "Government direction", "low": 67.2964198348, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5009383692, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 80.1852335461, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 60.4447020362, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 30.2790704628, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3786989604, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 86.677387708, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.8200452483, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 24.5472837498, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3730735329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 91.0436749946, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.9931375021, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 28.3510282824, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5780987827, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.2050551791, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.0287344574, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 37.014933445, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "atlas-canary-tenerife-conquest-1494-1496", "event_id": "atlas-canary-tenerife-conquest-1494-1496", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7407418908, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 95.7921200095, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 94.3193708324, "label": "Government direction", "low": 69.8663090886, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6349301058, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 74.2392161455, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 59.4273706345, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 37.7322267227, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 95.1436752312, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 76.805414743, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 16.0809962266, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.9324765255, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 76.4387666946, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.6846236896, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 79.2050551791, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 73.3143372807, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 57.1305878505, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-israeli-settlements-golan-heights", "event_id": "prospective-israeli-settlements-golan-heights", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7421082553, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 93.1805481485, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.8107047688, "label": "Government direction", "low": 67.3913736794, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5187677889, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 81.9511230374, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 65.208177244, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 33.8279019265, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.4332285753, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.5472910984, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 75.8725312725, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 32.8701486251, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.4791232358, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 85.3531240631, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 69.4298359102, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 33.2654476406, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3862508582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 87.3099668081, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 67.1456181315, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 25.9350526267, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 78.1520356242, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 78.1520356242, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 78.1520356242, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-israeli-settlements-west-bank-east-jerusalem", "event_id": "prospective-israeli-settlements-west-bank-east-jerusalem", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.6780565723, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.4930228909, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 80.0798669882, "label": "Government direction", "low": 54.2986801175, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5349909297, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 88.2006990457, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 77.9448579402, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 41.6997920114, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 98.3812250771, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 92.268471581, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 19.3185460724, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 89.32481983, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.9250014672, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 49.6737884871, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 19.8147486374, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 88.1363409882, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 84.775645921, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 66.0618736596, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-neolithic-southern-scandinavia-turnover", "event_id": "prehistory-neolithic-southern-scandinavia-turnover", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8955371256, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 12.0475795202, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 1.7880800588, "label": "Government direction", "low": 1.6012920761, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9239129213, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 15.7746392465, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 8.8384210079, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.1659313728, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.1533340223, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 89.1533340223, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 89.1533340223, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 71.0819204371, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 71.0819204371, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 71.0819204371, "status": "supported_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.2369025307, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3435086646, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 12.8059490456, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 3.0337617372, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.904260572, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 82.5466779879, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 80.6987913082, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 72.9727351889, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-initial-neolithic-farmer-expansion-from-southern-china-into-mainland-southeast-asia", "event_id": "prospective-initial-neolithic-farmer-expansion-from-southern-china-into-mainland-southeast-asia", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 6.0725348956, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.5725728385, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 42.7427161483, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3996882461, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.1533340223, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 72.8621842573, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 29.1221586342, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.582061844, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 60.0757525038, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 31.4089251688, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.2819369009, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1213504695, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 87.864953051, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.4119430796, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 90.8084099822, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 77.6872328388, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 32.0027179376, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "prehistory-iberia-steppe-ancestry-turnover", "event_id": "prehistory-iberia-steppe-ancestry-turnover", "traits": [ { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Government direction", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.819694497, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 25.6001792427, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 9.2346953242, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.5696289384, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8921511443, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 56.907977593, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 51.6987422095, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 46.123092019, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.9047685772, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F4", "high": 27.0673515536, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 19.3908251373, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 17.5442092693, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.2369025307, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 88.0099132573, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 49.3881019089, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 11.70016633, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 74.6958564511, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 74.6958564511, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 74.6958564511, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The reviewed studies identify no bounded displaced cohort or destination against which separation from homeland can be measured. A supported zero would falsely imply demonstrated continued homeland access.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v5/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_19_INDEPENDENT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F8", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "", "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-egypt-thutmose-iii-megiddo-captive-communities", "event_id": "ancient-egypt-thutmose-iii-megiddo-captive-communities", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.5292406006, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.5292406006, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.5292406006, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 10.7815207969, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 10.7815207969, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 10.7815207969, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Capture and arrival in Egyptian custody do not establish a self-reproducing settler community or durable implantation for this cohort.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v5/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_20_INDEPENDENT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5144495329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 72.2747086616, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 46.1068782004, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 23.7196619554, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The reviewed cohort sources do not establish long-term residence, return, descendants, or the durability of the removal outcome.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v5/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_20_INDEPENDENT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "correctionEvidence": "Breasted, Ancient Records of Egypt, vol. 2, §§435–437; Langer, ‘Forced Labour and Deportations in Ancient Egypt,’ printed pp. 10–13; ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_20_INDEPENDENT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md, section 2.", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "publicDisplayCorrected": true, "reviewReason": "The Year 23 annals directly establish military capture and transport into Egyptian custody, but the reviewed cohort-specific sources do not establish assignment to a temple, estate, household, or labor institution. The frozen applicability-gate zero therefore cannot support a public zero for imported unfree labor: applicability and intensity remain unknown for this cohort.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "underlyingRecodeFollowup": "Re-review scs_exogenous_labor_triad=0 and the cohort-versus-system labor referent in the next statistical release; preserve frozen v5 and display full uncertainty publicly.", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-amenhotep-ii-year-7-campaign-captive-removal", "event_id": "prospective-amenhotep-ii-year-7-campaign-captive-removal", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.5292406006, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.5292406006, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.5292406006, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7430974325, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 34.6756584791, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 12.0918217936, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 8.9854017291, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Arrival at Memphis does not establish durable community implantation or a self-reproducing incoming population.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v5/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_20_INDEPENDENT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The source establishes removal but not source-community population share, total clearance, incorporation, or demographic replacement.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v5/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_20_INDEPENDENT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.8987147883, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 64.6581500419, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.6508619524, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The source ends at arrival in Memphis and does not establish later residence, return, descendants, or a durable territorial outcome.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v5/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_20_INDEPENDENT_SOURCE_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-amenhotep-ii-year-9-campaign-captive-removal", "event_id": "prospective-amenhotep-ii-year-9-campaign-captive-removal", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8014672397, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 93.8443067522, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 92.319469914, "label": "Government direction", "low": 73.9910307269, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.3108192668, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 76.6885549897, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 25.0, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.7704816701, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.0647509969, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5144495329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 72.2747086616, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 46.1068782004, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 23.7196619554, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1992918502, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.0708149825, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 87.5, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 37.5, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-hittite-mursili-arzawa-deportation", "event_id": "ancient-hittite-mursili-arzawa-deportation", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.5292406006, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.5292406006, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.5292406006, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.6812438722, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 63.6208142797, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 46.5988800717, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 31.7452015007, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.0738863241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3716611322, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 81.7344147729, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 50.8541958075, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 86.8636765225, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 67.0684213127, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 26.7534236927, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1992918502, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.0708149825, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 75.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 50.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 25.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-nipur-pasate", "event_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-nipur-pasate", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 88.8809877459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.8809877459, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.8809877459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5502481242, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 60.4308121013, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 28.0884638025, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 15.4556245181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.1390595235, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 26.7182443592, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 3.7154263296, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.398076524, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.9288434819, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.2878236942, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1992918502, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.0708149825, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-tumme-habhu", "event_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-tumme-habhu", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 88.8809877459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.8809877459, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.8809877459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5502481242, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 60.4308121013, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 28.0884638025, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 15.4556245181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.1390595235, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 26.7182443592, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 3.7154263296, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.398076524, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.9288434819, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.2878236942, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1992918502, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.0708149825, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-upper-tigris-nirbu-882", "event_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-upper-tigris-nirbu-882", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 88.8809877459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.8809877459, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.8809877459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.6306144511, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.4216539281, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 34.0669310708, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 21.4830990378, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 64.0776098405, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 18.1776476332, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.398076524, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.9288434819, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.2878236942, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1992918502, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.0708149825, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-zamua-881", "event_id": "early-neo-assyrian-ashurnasirpal-zamua-881", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 88.8809877459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.8809877459, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.8809877459, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.5502481242, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 60.4308121013, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 28.0884638025, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 15.4556245181, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 30.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.1390595235, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 89.8094739787, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 26.7182443592, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 3.7154263296, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 87.3313776076, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.398076524, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 75.9288434819, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 30.2878236942, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.1992918502, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.0708149825, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The applicability gate is unknown; unfree-incomer share cannot establish imported labor by itself.", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-paeonian-deportation-to-phrygia-approximately-512-bce", "event_id": "prospective-paeonian-deportation-to-phrygia-approximately-512-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8452047652, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 95.7871360629, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 95.0155700601, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.3076125861, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "unresolved", "coverage": 0.2645055004, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 83.1731265994, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 9.623676636, "reviewReason": "A royal written order is supported, but the source does not establish title transfer, parcel expropriation, surveying, registration, or comparable machinery; the fitted center is therefore not shown as an observed point.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_26_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.0738863241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 92.8579289426, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 35.6473986869, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3730735329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 79.3435086646, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 44.6315819403, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.6508619524, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.4171744446, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 63.7296204001, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 13.0570434772, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 5.4470648608, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "unresolved", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Forced movement and communal residence do not establish labor obligations or economic status; no labor claim or fitted public center is authorized.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_26_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-achaemenid-barcaeans-bactria", "event_id": "ancient-achaemenid-barcaeans-bactria", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.7685756207, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 82.7191925586, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.6960407251, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_low", "coverage": 0.342378498, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 73.0723281685, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.3101779694, "reviewReason": "Royal assignment of residence is supported, but title, parcel transfer, surveying, registration, and comparable machinery are not documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "unresolved_broad", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "reviewReason": "Assigned residence is explicit, but cohort scale, household composition, reproduction, prior destination residents, and descendant continuity are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 93.0714997192, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 81.9519457113, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 31.4606810124, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5144495329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 83.9748749916, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 68.8499571243, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 35.4198282854, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_broad", "coverage": 0.2954255353, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.4574464731, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Herodotus says the assigned place remained inhabited, but does not prove continuing Barcaean identity, descendants, permanent residence, or later reversal.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high_but_unresolved", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "Long-distance forced removal is secure, but the source provides no legal return prohibition, return history, or proof of permanent foreclosure.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Enslavement and imposed residence do not establish a destination labor assignment, economic institution, or imported-labor stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-pometia-destruction-503-495", "event_id": "gr-roman-pometia-destruction-503-495", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 84.7512821609, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 84.7512821609, "label": "Government direction", "low": 84.7512821609, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 48.5494945282, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 48.5494945282, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 48.5494945282, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-pometia-destruction-503-495/F3", "reviewReason": "No incoming settlement stream is established for this bounded destruction and captive-export event. Buyers and later land use remain unknown; this is not a measured zero implantation score.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "high_but_source_critical", "coverage": 0.5525527387, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 79.0656197304, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 34.3208936012, "reviewReason": "Livy narrates near-total sale and destruction, but the retrospective totalizing account is not a recovered population census.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.4318382612, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 87.5515022859, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 46.1945240859, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_broad", "coverage": 0.2204881927, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 80.81533278, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 2.8641520454, "reviewReason": "Pometia disappears from later attestation, but the site, successor use, resident survival, and return history remain unresolved.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "The captives' destinations, distance from Pometia, return history, and any return prohibition are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-pometia-destruction-503-495/F8", "reviewReason": "The reviewed event describes captives leaving Pometia, not imported unfree labor there. An inward labor stream is not evidenced; the unknown applicability gate is not a zero score.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-velitrae-conquest-colony-494-492", "event_id": "gr-roman-velitrae-conquest-colony-494-492", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.8579761695, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.2669322329, "label": "Government direction", "low": 84.7854412739, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "low_to_moderate_unresolved", "coverage": 0.3554260103, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 76.1842570452, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 11.7268580716, "reviewReason": "Senatorial organization, leaders, territory-taking, and expected allotment are supported, but exact legal form and parcels are not.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low_to_moderate_unresolved", "coverage": 0.4, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 55, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 0, "reviewReason": "Incoming colonists are documented, but local and Volscian continuity is positive evidence against the release's high-centered elimination estimate; resident removal shares are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 100, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 0, "reviewReason": "Dionysius's plague mortality is not Roman lethal coercion, and the conquest narrative does not supply a bounded casualty share.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 43.8527583459, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 35.8602393944, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 31.3916595267, "status": "supported_point", "value": 35.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-velitrae-conquest-colony-494-492/F7", "reviewReason": "No prior-resident removal cohort or destination is established. Incoming Roman colonists did move, but their movement does not measure prior residents' separation from homeland.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-velitrae-conquest-colony-494-492/F8", "reviewReason": "Compulsory recruitment of civic colonists does not establish a distinct imported unfree-labor population. That labor stream is not evidenced here; applicability remains unknown rather than a measured zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_27_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-miletus-destruction-ampe-deportation-and-land-redistribution-494-bce", "event_id": "prospective-miletus-destruction-ampe-deportation-and-land-redistribution-494-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.9059301142, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 89.7146011672, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 88.6465868927, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.3076125861, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6515227114, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 46.837753727, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 18.4030804442, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 11.9900248696, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_broad", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 79.0626790046, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "A captive cohort was implanted at Ampe, but its size, household composition, reproduction, persistence, and destination share are unknown; Persian or Carian household settlement at Miletus is not established.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_critical_broad", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "reviewReason": "Severe treatment of captured urban cohorts and land disposition are explicit, but zone-wide removal, replacement share, successor ancestry, and incorporation are not.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.3730735329, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 93.9324765255, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 83.7363872272, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 31.2398298133, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_broad", "coverage": 0.1992918502, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 87.2512720817, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.1804570992, "reviewReason": "The source-land order was later reversed, while the duration and reversal history of the Ampe community are unknown; one narrow low range cannot combine those outcomes.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Enslavement and coerced settlement do not establish an imported-labor institution or labor assignment at Ampe.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-achaemenid-eretria-ardericca", "event_id": "ancient-achaemenid-eretria-ardericca", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.3801474817, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 85.4996059958, "label": "Government direction", "low": 80.3076125861, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_low", "coverage": 0.2244302622, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 85.1768885066, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 7.6199147288, "reviewReason": "A royal-domain assignment is explicit, but title instruments, expropriation procedure, survey, registry, tenure, and parcels are not.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "unresolved_broad", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "reviewReason": "A durable language-bearing enclave is attested, but size, family completeness, reproduction, destination share, and saturation are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_critical_broad", "coverage": 0.216423106, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 18.900527989, "reviewReason": "The captured-cohort removal is explicit, but its source-population share, source replacement, local incorporation, destination ancestry, and saturation are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.2575214716, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 90.8987147883, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 64.6581500419, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.6508619524, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_broad", "coverage": 0.2954255353, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F6", "high": 70.4574464731, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Eretria recovered while the Ardericca community persisted to Herodotus's time; one low point wrongly combines opposite source and destination outcomes.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "high_but_unresolved", "coverage": 0.5, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 50.0, "reviewReason": "Long-distance forced transfer is secure, but return foreclosure and a legal return ban are not documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F8", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "Captivity and coerced settlement do not establish an imported-labor system, labor assignment, or economic institution at Ardericca.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_28_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-antium-conquest-integrated-colony-468-467", "event_id": "gr-roman-antium-conquest-integrated-colony-468-467", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.0540999412, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 85.1524790504, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.9815650456, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "source_critical_partial", "coverage": 0.7152964327, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 59.8901573373, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 31.4198006073, "reviewReason": "State allocation of captured land is narrated, but title instruments, parcel boundaries, totals, and shares are not. The range is an editorial uncertainty envelope, not a confidence interval.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_29_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": null }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7238769706, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 42.4742007835, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 20.5309720407, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 14.8618978445, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 52.4630949518, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 26.0906979253, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 20.9156810645, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 20.9156810645, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 20.9156810645, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-antium-conquest-integrated-colony-468-467/F8", "reviewReason": "Crop-sharing by continuing Antiates is local labor incorporation, not evidence of unfree labor imported from elsewhere. The reviewed event supplies no positive imported-labor finding or numerical estimate.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_29_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-ardea-taking-restitution-reorganization-446-442", "event_id": "gr-roman-ardea-taking-restitution-reorganization-446-442", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 77.0218700817, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.0218700817, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.0218700817, "status": "supported_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 55.9502201348, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 45.4813342456, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 36.7478318439, "status": "supported_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "unresolved_low", "coverage": 0.2836817365, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 71.6318263455, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "reviewReason": "A colony is narrated, but the incoming Roman component, if any, and its size, household form, persistence, and share are not known.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_29_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-ardea-taking-restitution-reorganization-446-442/F4", "reviewReason": "The reviewed episode establishes legal land taking and locally weighted restitution, not a measured resident-removal or demographic-replacement outcome. No numeric elimination-versus-incorporation estimate is authorized.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_29_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.6431789195, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 45.6545448443, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 15.5049186011, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 8.9019988575, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 8.9019988575, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 8.9019988575, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F7", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-ardea-taking-restitution-reorganization-446-442/F8", "reviewReason": "No distinct unfree-labor population brought from outside the affected community is established for this bounded appropriation-and-restitution episode. This is not a measured zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_29_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-athenian-aegina-expulsion-settlement-431-406-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-athenian-aegina-expulsion-settlement-431-406-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8361781411, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 93.4353889176, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 92.1492672918, "label": "Government direction", "low": 77.0532030297, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.3031910289, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 73.9857791311, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 14.19857981, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 4.3048820216, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 15.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.20937321, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 93.5249003083, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 69.0738863241, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 14.4622213036, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5647834195, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.2582173937, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 95.1454265268, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 53.7365593416, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Thucydides reports coercive expulsion in the 431 source-island action but no killing. The separate 424 Thyrea executions are excluded; no casualty census supports a measured zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.7792553267, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F6", "high": 29.2549244278, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 9.2145114099, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 7.1804570992, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "One short-distance branch to broad Thyreatis is supported, while the wider distribution, cohort share, return history, and modal separation remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Neither the family-inclusive expulsion nor the successor Athenian settlement establishes a coerced outside-labor stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-fidenae-exile-land-reallocation-428", "event_id": "gr-roman-fidenae-exile-land-reallocation-428", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 86.3035749978, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 86.3035749978, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.3035749978, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.0299023751, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 51.7682555208, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 41.8275140842, "status": "supported_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.453007487, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 59.9585070167, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 27.1616525885, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.3838918129, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 84.6980643703, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 60.1399792486, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 23.0872456634, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Deaths in prior war identify the land later assigned, but killing is not evidenced as part of the bounded 428 inquiry, exile, reinforcement, and assignment.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 33.3767798837, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 23.8930130289, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 20.9156810645, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Ostia is a supported short-distance destination for an unquantified subset; duration, legal status, return, and the modal experience of all Fidenates remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Colonist reinforcement and forced relegation to Ostia do not establish a coerced labor stream brought from outside the affected community.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-fidenae-conquest-enslavement-426", "event_id": "gr-roman-fidenae-conquest-enslavement-426", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.4251091327, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.9353824157, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.352574237, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded 426 event reports conquest and political incorporation but no title transfer, survey, registration, parcel reallocation, or successor allotment program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F3", "high": 0.0, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 0.0, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 0.0, "status": "supported_point", "value": 0.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.466892555, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.9530550949, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 46.3539423864, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 21.6423105953, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 45.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5276268582, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 86.3630382582, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 74.154155482, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 39.1257240829, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8621355989, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 69.0491818771, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 64.0998258709, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 55.2627417657, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Allocation and sale of captives establish coerced labor, while cohort size, destinations, duration, and institutional extent are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_30_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-athenian-scione-destruction-plataean-settlement-421-406-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-athenian-scione-destruction-plataean-settlement-421-406-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.7421082553, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.388428139, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.4808748018, "label": "Government direction", "low": 71.5992536699, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "An authoritative land grant to Plataeans is explicit, but no title system, parcel survey, registry, or tenure machinery is preserved.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Plataean successor residence is directly documented, while origin, scale, household completeness, reproduction, and population share are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Adult-male killing, enslavement of women and children, and successor residence establish a strongly eliminatory direction, but no complete resident denominator survives.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7089831509, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F5", "high": 78.4659360714, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 69.6268325973, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 49.3642511635, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The successor tenure lasted roughly sixteen years and was then reversed. It was short-lived, but a literal zero would erase a real interval of residence and control.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The source establishes outward enslavement, not coerced or unfree labor brought into Scione.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-labici-colony-418-scope-control", "event_id": "gr-roman-labici-colony-418-scope-control", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.0178324934, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.0178324934, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Livy reports 1,500 allottees, but whether that is Rome's contribution or the full body is disputed and household composition, local share, reproduction, and continuity are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The reviewed sources do not identify the post-conquest disposition or demographic share of Labici's prior residents.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Capture and plunder establish coercive violence, but the source does not state killing or supply a casualty denominator.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Roman political absorption became durable, while the constitutional form and continuity of the reported settler body remain uncertain.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-labici-colony-418-scope-control/F7", "reviewReason": "No displaced Labican cohort, destination or return history is established. Allottee movement does not measure prior-resident removal; no numerical separation estimate is authorized.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The sources do not establish coerced or unfree labor brought from outside into Labici.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-athenian-destruction-colonization-melos-416-bce", "event_id": "prospective-athenian-destruction-colonization-melos-416-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8452047652, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.388428139, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.9101311677, "label": "Government direction", "low": 81.9089046622, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Island takeover is explicit, but no title transfer, parceling, surveying, registration, or tenure instrument is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Five hundred incoming Athenian men are explicit, but household completeness, affected-zone share, reproduction, and durable growth are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.5647834195, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 100.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 56.478341948, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 100.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Killing and sale into slavery are explicit, but the number and share killed and the complete affected-population denominator are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Athenian settlement and control lasted about eleven years before reversal. It was short-lived, but a literal zero would erase the interval.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The source establishes outward sale of Melian captives, not coerced or unfree labor brought into Melos.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_31_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-bola-contested-land-taking-415-414", "event_id": "gr-roman-bola-contested-land-taking-415-414", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8957364834, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 79.9474059326, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.6132886865, "label": "Government direction", "low": 69.5210542751, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 36.6511132223, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 21.5955949221, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 17.4487249314, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Livy reports Aequian fresh colonists after the 414 countercapture, but their origin, number, household composition, land share, reproduction, and duration are unknown; the failed Roman colony was a different, unimplemented proposal.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The reviewed sources do not establish resident elimination, incorporation, or a demographic replacement ratio at Bola.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Capture and plunder establish coercive violence, but the sources do not report resident killing or supply a casualty denominator.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The 415 Roman taking and 414 Aequian reinforcement were quickly reversed; the duration of Roman control after the 414 recapture is unknown and the separate 389 event is excluded.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-bola-contested-land-taking-415-414/F7", "reviewReason": "No displaced Bola cohort, destination, distance or return restriction is established. The unquantified incoming reinforcement does not supply that missing resident-removal history.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Aequian colonist reinforcement is not evidence of coerced or unfree labor brought from outside; no such labor stream is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-scionaean-restoration-405-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-scionaean-restoration-405-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.6780565723, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.388428139, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.1484454722, "label": "Government direction", "low": 65.1940853655, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Restoration of a city does not establish title instruments, surveying, parcel restitution, registration, or individual property machinery.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Scionaean return and reoccupation are explicit, while returnee number, household composition, completeness, reproduction, and diaspora origins are unknown; public prose calls this restoration rather than generic settlement.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Athenian control ended and Scionaeans were restored, but the source supplies no resident-share, total-clearance, or replacement ratio.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded restoration source reports no killing or casualty share; the separately bounded 421 violence must not be imported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Implemented restoration and civic reoccupation are positive outcomes, but the reviewed packet does not measure their later demographic or political persistence.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Return reversed separation for the restored cohort, while individual diaspora origins, distances, routes, and the position of nonreturnees remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The reviewed restoration sources do not establish a coerced or unfree labor stream brought from outside into Scione.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-lysandrian-aeginetan-restoration-405-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-lysandrian-aeginetan-restoration-405-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7090970085, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.9373500448, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.3477397841, "label": "Government direction", "low": 54.8470508962, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No title, survey, parcel, registry, or individual restitution procedure is documented for the 405 restoration.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Xenophon reports an implemented but expressly incomplete gathering and restoration; number, households, diaspora share, reproduction, and duration remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The restoration reversed civic and territorial tenure, but the source does not establish the identity, number, route, or fate of every outgoing resident or a replacement ratio.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Neither restoration passage reports killing in the bounded 405 action; the 431 expulsion and 424 Thyrea executions are separate events and source silence is not a casualty measurement.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Civic restoration and reoccupation occurred, while later demographic and political persistence is not measured in the reviewed packet.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Return reversed separation for the gathered cohort, but individual origins, distances, routes, and barriers facing nonreturnees are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The reviewed restoration sources do not establish a coerced or unfree labor stream brought from outside into Aegina.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_32_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-spartan-restoration-melos-405-bce", "event_id": "prospective-spartan-restoration-melos-405-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.8274114925, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 97.0882353677, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 96.4808748018, "label": "Government direction", "low": 79.8293846128, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded 405 sources do not describe title, survey, parcel, registration, transport, or individual restitution machinery.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Melian return and reoccupation are implemented, but returnee number, household composition, completeness, reproduction, and diaspora origins are unknown; this is restoration, not a measured novel-settler share.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Athenian-settler removal and Melian restoration establish a substantial population reordering, but no cohort denominator or replacement ratio survives.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded 405 sources report no killing or measurable life-threatening share; the 416 killings belong to the separate predecessor event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Civic-territorial restoration and reoccupation were implemented, while later demographic and political persistence is not measured in the reviewed packet.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "An outgoing settler cohort and returning exile cohort are known, but their origins, destinations, distances, completeness, and later return barriers are not.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coerced or unfree labor stream was brought from outside into Melos in the bounded 405 event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-veii-conquest-allotment-incorporation-396-387", "event_id": "gr-roman-veii-conquest-allotment-incorporation-396-387", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 90.3991214698, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 90.3991214698, "label": "Government direction", "low": 90.3991214698, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 69.6609346797, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 62.4505419423, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 50.4585463888, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6347085099, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F3", "high": 81.8609038875, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": 71.4213755934, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": 45.3317548789, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 70.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Captive sale and household land assignment coexist with continued habitation, selective incorporation, and a mixed successor community; no elimination or replacement ratio is measurable.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Sack and sale into captivity establish severe coercion, but deaths, survival, and affected-population shares are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 67.4033822525, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 62.7632774597, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 54.9422834333, "status": "supported_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The sale of inhabitants establishes an outgoing captive cohort, while destinations, distances, numbers, and return conditions remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Veii's outgoing captives are not imported outside labor at Veii, and no incoming coerced labor cohort is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-circeii-latin-refoundation-393", "event_id": "gr-roman-circeii-latin-refoundation-393", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 80.8309562191, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 79.5916521759, "label": "Government direction", "low": 74.7584213235, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No Circeii-specific parcel schedule, title system, survey, settler total, household rule, or implementing board is securely attested for 393; the unnamed 395 notice may not supply them.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Diodorus's colony notice establishes positive settlement, but size, household composition, reproduction, persistence of the entrant cohort, and resident share are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded evidence does not establish prior-resident removal, survival, incorporation, or a replacement ratio; affected-land admission is not a proxy for elimination.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No bounded 393 source reports killing or a measurable life-threatening act; Volscian-control context and the held early-fifth-century episode cannot be imported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 64.8047152702, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 59.7946921254, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 52.343616451, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No displaced resident cohort, destination, distance, or return barrier is established for the named 393 colony, so zero is not a measurement.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coerced outside-labor stream into Circeii is documented; colonists are not automatically coerced labor.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_33_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-vitellia-aequian-capture-flight-393", "event_id": "gr-roman-vitellia-aequian-capture-flight-393", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The source establishes a coordinated Aequian armed attack, not the attackers' centralized administrative structure, planning chain, or continuity.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No title transfer, expropriation, survey, registration, parcel system, or other legal-proprietary machinery is reported for the bounded capture.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded event is outward colonist flight and contains no incoming settlement stream; zero would misdescribe the held earlier foundation as measured within this event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Livy's majority-flight statement applies to colonists; non-colonist residents, successor incorporation, and any replacement denominator are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Night capture and compelled flight establish severe threat, while most colonists were reported uninjured and no casualty or confinement share survives.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Later disappearance supports settlement loss as a specialist inference, while immediate use, return, vacancy, successor rule, and duration are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Rome is the named destination, but Vitellia's precise location and route and any return foreclosure are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The event is outward flight; no coerced or unfree labor stream entered Vitellia from elsewhere.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-bola-final-capture-destruction-389", "event_id": "gr-roman-bola-final-capture-destruction-389", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.4251091327, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.9353824157, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.352574237, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The 389 evidence reports no title, survey, registration, confiscation, parcel, or allotment act.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming settler stream belongs to the bounded 389 capture.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Later disappearance cannot determine resident killing, flight, survival, incorporation, or replacement.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Armed assault is direct, but the source supplies no Bola casualty total or affected-population share.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The city disappears from later records and no reversal is reported, but this is an attributed specialist inference rather than a measured demographic or land-use endpoint.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No displaced cohort, destination, route, or return bar is documented for the 389 capture.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coerced or unfree labor stream entered Bola from elsewhere in the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_34_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-satricum-roman-conquest-colony-386-385", "event_id": "gr-roman-satricum-roman-conquest-colony-386-385", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 1.0, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.0178324934, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 83.0178324934, "label": "Government direction", "low": 83.0178324934, "status": "supported_point", "value": 85.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 61.647473071, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 52.5325982814, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 42.4450847801, "status": "supported_point", "value": 55.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Livy reports an incoming citizen-colonist body, while implementation, households, resident share, and entrant persistence are unresolved.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Volscian removal, survival, incorporation, and successor shares are not measured by the conquest, order, or archaeology.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Storming and surrender establish coercive conquest, but no death, destruction, or affected-population casualty share is reported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 22.9008014215, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 11.9257866634, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 10.4397026023, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No displaced cohort, destination, distance, or return barrier is identified in the bounded capture-and-order event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-satricum-roman-conquest-colony-386-385/F8", "reviewReason": "The identified incoming cohort is Roman citizen colonists. No distinct imported unfree-labor population is established within the bounded event, and no numeric estimate is warranted.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-pomptine-division-settlement-383-358", "event_id": "gr-roman-pomptine-division-settlement-383-358", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.935948317, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.0004135459, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.4529613343, "label": "Government direction", "low": 85.5952452414, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.8079761171, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F2", "high": 66.2620918519, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 58.2439289547, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 47.059703561, "status": "supported_point", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Regional Roman settlement is supported, while recipient number, origin, households, timing, and precise rural footprint are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No source identifies prior rural resident removal, survival, incorporation, ancestry, or replacement shares.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8712706135, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 22.845375447, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 11.4458546387, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 9.9724367925, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Durability depends on Chiaba's interpretation that the 358 Pomptina organization consolidated beneficiaries of earlier distributions.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No displaced rural cohort, destination, distance, or return barrier is identified.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "mainDisplayDecision": "analysis/second_pass/v6/post_v6_correction_application_v1/release_assembly/display_application/MAIN_DECISIONS.json#gr-roman-pomptine-division-settlement-383-358/F8", "reviewReason": "Roman settlement is identified at regional level, but no distinct imported unfree-labor population is established in the bounded notices. No numerical imported-labor estimate is authorized.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-satricum-countercapture-382", "event_id": "gr-roman-satricum-countercapture-382", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "State-organized armed action is direct, while several inherited high agency inputs presuppose population-transfer or settlement administration absent from this event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No legal transfer, land commission, allotment, title, parcel, or property procedure is reported after the capture.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming resident or settler stream is identified in the bounded counter-conquest.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Brutal captive treatment is direct, while death, removal, survival, incorporation, and replacement shares are unspecified.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Severe coercion is direct, but Livy does not specify treatment type, lethality, number, or population share.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The later 377 destruction supplies only an outer chronological context; the 382 control duration and demographic persistence are not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No displaced cohort, route, destination, distance, or return barrier is identified.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming coerced or unfree labor stream exists; captives at the target are not imported outside labor there.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_35_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-satricum-latin-burning-377", "event_id": "gr-roman-satricum-latin-burning-377", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The source establishes organized Latin armed action, not a continuing administrative program or measured degree of central direction.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_36_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No legal transfer, expropriation, survey, registration, parcel, title, or other property machinery is documented in the bounded burning.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_36_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded event is destruction and settlement break; it contains no incoming settler stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_36_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.6477841616, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F4", "high": 74.9530550949, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 61.334428361, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 39.7314712501, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 60.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.3988974717, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F5", "high": 80.9262779957, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 52.1838984767, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 20.8160251659, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.8621355989, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 34.2786246959, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 23.7690968926, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 20.4921845845, "status": "supported_point", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coerced or unfree third-population labor stream entered Satricum from elsewhere in the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_36_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-athenian-samos-expulsion-cleruchy-365-323-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-athenian-samos-expulsion-cleruchy-365-323-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7376149146, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.3699666765, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.4543152598, "label": "Government direction", "low": 57.1314581333, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.5310811464, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F2", "high": 81.0071364036, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 64.2373604734, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 34.1152510389, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 65.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A durable incoming cleruch community is direct, while total settlers, household composition, population share, and reproductive completeness are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_36_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.1067518017, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F4", "high": 97.3312049575, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": 75.0, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": 8.0063851275, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8844479388, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F5", "high": 28.3361930238, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": 18.9734026896, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": 16.7809869001, "status": "supported_point", "value": 20.0 }, { "band": "minimal", "coverage": 0.8753890118, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F6", "high": 22.2402229006, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": 11.1711752713, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": 9.7791240815, "status": "supported_point", "value": 10.0 }, { "band": "not_applicable_or_unknown", "coverage": 0.0, "coverageBand": "low", "factor": "F7", "high": 100.0, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": 0.0, "status": "insufficient_evidence_do_not_show_solid_point", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coerced or unfree third-population labor stream is documented as entering Samos in the bounded cleruchic program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_36_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-satricum-roman-destruction-enslavement-346", "event_id": "gr-roman-satricum-roman-destruction-enslavement-346", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 92.4251091327, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 91.9353824157, "label": "Government direction", "low": 86.352574237, "status": "supported_point", "value": 90.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No title transfer, parcel allocation, legal-property instrument, or successor land administration is documented in the bounded 346 event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded event removes captives from Satricum and contains no incoming settler stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Captive removal and destruction are direct, but the resident denominator, surviving population, and degree of clearance are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Warfare, confinement, city destruction, and sale are direct; deaths and a mortality share are not documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The rebuilt civic site was destroyed, but resident outcomes, later land use, and duration beyond the immediate destruction are unresolved.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Captives are directly attested at Rome, while post-sale destinations, duration, and return are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Captive sale out of Satricum does not establish a receiving labor system inside the bounded source-land event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-achaemenid-sidonians-susa-babylon", "event_id": "ancient-achaemenid-sidonians-susa-babylon", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 95.0366809937, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 94.7157958529, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.9641460981, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Conquest and seizure do not establish a legal-property apparatus, title transfer, parcel system, or registration machinery.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Prisoners entering royal custody are not a family-complete incoming settler community.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Executions, fires, and prisoner removal are direct; no source-population or survivor share is known.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Executions, burning, capture, and confinement are direct, while the ancient total and population denominator are not census-quality evidence.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Sidon's source-city recovery is direct context but does not establish release, return, or duration for the transferred prisoners.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Babylon and Susa establish long-distance separation, while destination shares, duration, and return remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The contemporary chronicle supports destination-side coerced custody, especially the women entering the Babylonian palace, but not a universal occupation, labor regime, or workforce share.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-macedonian-alexander-thebes-destruction-distribution-335-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-macedonian-alexander-thebes-destruction-distribution-335-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "very_high", "coverage": 0.939274651, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 95.0366809937, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 94.7157958529, "label": "Government direction", "low": 88.9641460981, "status": "supported_point", "value": 95.0 }, { "band": "moderate", "coverage": 0.7893720798, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 58.6393658248, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 47.6031199576, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 37.5765738069, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 50.0 }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The 335 event documents destruction, enslavement, and land disposition but no incoming resident or settler community.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Killing, enslavement, and dispersal are direct, but named personal exemptions and missing population shares prevent a precise clearance claim.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Killing and life-threatening coercion are direct; Diodorus's ancient figures do not establish a precise mortality intensity.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The civic destruction persisted for nineteen years before Cassander's separate 316 restoration; resident and land-use persistence within that interval remain incomplete.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Refuge denial and dispersal are direct, while modal destination, distance, duration, and return shares are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Captive sale does not identify a receiving labor territory, labor regime, or workforce share within the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_37_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-samian-exile-restoration-322-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-samian-exile-restoration-322-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.832851807, "coverageBand": "high", "factor": "F1", "high": 81.9089046622, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 78.2781340149, "label": "Government direction", "low": 65.1940853655, "status": "supported_point", "value": 80.0 }, { "band": "low", "coverage": 0.7399992605, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F2", "high": 43.9935950683, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": 24.3155933816, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": 17.9935211218, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 25.0 }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The incoming cohort consists of returning Samians, not a novel settler population.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_38_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Athenian cleruchic tenure ended, but the number or share of cleruchs who remained or departed is unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_38_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No lethal coercion is reported, but the implementation evidence does not support an asserted numerical zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_38_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "City and territory were restored, but the duration of the restored order is not measured in the bounded source packet.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_38_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The event ends the returning Samians' separation; their dispersed origins and route lengths are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_38_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No imported coerced third-population labor stream is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_38_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-macedonian-cassander-theban-restoration-316-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-macedonian-cassander-theban-restoration-316-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "high", "coverage": 0.7090970085, "coverageBand": "medium", "factor": "F1", "high": 83.9373500448, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": 77.3477397841, "label": "Government direction", "low": 54.8470508962, "status": "partial_evidence_show_range", "value": 75.0 }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Civic recovery is explicit, but the bounded sources do not measure deeds, surveys, registries, parcels, or title transfers.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The moving cohort is surviving Thebans returning home, not a novel settler population.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The event restores survivors, but resident composition and return share are not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No killing is evidenced in the bounded restoration; source silence is not a measured zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The city was rebuilt and recovered, while later demographic duration and completeness are unmeasured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The event documents return rather than continuing separation; origins, distances, and nonreturners remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No imported coerced third-population labor stream is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-lysimachos-skepsis-withdrawal-reconstitution", "event_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-lysimachos-skepsis-withdrawal-reconstitution", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Lysimachos's permission is direct state action, but the sources do not measure a continuing administrative apparatus.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No charter, survey, title, parcel, compensation, or proprietary instrument is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The Skepsians returned to their homeland and are not a novel settler population.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded event releases Skepsis from incorporation; it does not document population removal or replacement at either endpoint.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No lethal coercion is evidenced in the release passages; narrative silence is not a numerical zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Return was implemented, while later demographic and territorial persistence is unmeasured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The documented return ends separation for the returnees; route distance is not continued separation.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coerced third-population labor stream entered Skepsis in the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_39_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-mauryan-kalinga-war-removal", "event_id": "ancient-mauryan-kalinga-war-removal", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A named ruler's inscription attributes the conquest and captive removal to his own government, but the bounded evidence does not measure administrative continuity or license a numerical center.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Later administration is attested, but event-specific title transfer, confiscation, survey, cadastral registration, and allocation machinery are not measured; only a source-limited minimal-to-low description is warranted.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming replacement-settler stream is demonstrated for the bounded conquest and captive-removal event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Claimed killing and captive removal coexist with continuing Kalingan residence and administration; no denominator or population distribution supports a point estimate.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The inscription supports qualitatively high severity, while its large rounded royal claims are not independent mortality counts and cannot support a numerical center.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Territorial incorporation endured, but captive duration, return, and the persistence of individual removal outcomes are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The inscription directly supports outward captive separation, while destination, distance, duration, and return are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The event does not establish an incoming coerced third-population labor stream or a bounded labor deployment.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-lysimachos-astakos-destruction", "event_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-lysimachos-astakos-destruction", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Strabo names Lysimachos as the ruler who razed Astakos, but no decree, administrative chain, or continuing program supports a precise very-high center.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No law, title transfer, survey, confiscation, parceling, or property instrument is attested for the razing.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming settler population is demonstrated in the destruction phase; the later Astakian transfer cannot be inherited.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Loss of the urban base is attested, but resident death, flight, incorporation, and demographic replacement are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Razing supports destructive force in kind, while no deaths, casualty magnitude, confinement, or subsistence effects are measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The city was razed yet later separate Astakos identity survived; durability of the bounded outcome is mixed and incompletely known.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No resident movement, destination, distance, or return is directly attested for the razing phase.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded destruction event contains no incoming coerced third-population labor stream, so the labor trait is not applicable.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-nikomedes-astakian-transfer-nikomedeia", "event_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-nikomedes-astakian-transfer-nikomedeia", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Strabo attributes the transfer to Nikomedeia's founder, supporting high royal direction without administrative detail or a precise numerical center.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No decree, title, survey, confiscation, parceling, or property machinery is documented for the transfer.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Transfer into a durable royal foundation supports population concentration, but scale, household completeness, and totality are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Synoecism and civic inheritance favor incorporation over demographic elimination, while transfer totality and the destination population's fate remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The transfer wording does not attest killing, threats, confinement, or destruction of subsistence; Lysimachos's earlier razing cannot be inherited.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Nikomedeia endured while a separate Astakos identity also survived, yielding positive but mixed durability rather than a point estimate.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The sites are physically close, while route, travel mode, permanence, return, and the share transferred remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded civic transfer is not an incoming coerced third-population labor stream, so the labor trait is not applicable.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_40_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "ancient-qin-eastern-elites-xianyang-resettlement", "event_id": "ancient-qin-eastern-elites-xianyang-resettlement", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The First Emperor directly ordered the household relocation, supporting high qualitative state direction without a measured numerical center.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded order does not establish confiscation, title transfer, survey, parcels, registration, or successor use at the origins.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Households were concentrated at Xianyang, while share, composition, reproduction, and persistence are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Removal of a selected powerful and wealthy cohort does not measure population-wide elimination, replacement, or incorporation.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The relocation wording does not establish killing, confinement, or life-threatening enforcement in this bounded order.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Continued concentration was intended, but later residence, return, and lineage continuity are not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Broad movement toward the western capital supports real separation, while household origins, distances, and return foreclosure vary and remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The selected-household concentration is not an incoming coerced-labor program; separate Qin captive and convict programs cannot be inherited.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-lysimacheia-thracian-sack-dispersal", "event_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-lysimacheia-thracian-sack-dispersal", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The sources identify Thracian attackers but no named ruler, polity, administrative chain, or continuing state program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Capture, plunder, and burning do not establish legal title conversion, survey, registration, or property bureaucracy.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No successor settler stream belongs to the bounded destruction and dispersal event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A deserted ruined city and dispersed or enslaved inhabitants establish severe community loss, while completeness and totals are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Burning, captivity, and enslavement establish violent coercion, while killing and casualty magnitude are not stated.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The vacancy was brief and reversed by the 196 BCE restoration; the approximate sack date prevents a precise duration.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Regional refugees and captives of unknown destination establish mixed separation without one distance, duration, or blocked-return measure.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Captivity is a removal mechanism here, not evidence of coerced outside labor brought into the bounded Lysimacheia territory.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-antiochos-lysimacheia-restoration", "event_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-antiochos-lysimacheia-restoration", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Antiochos initiated rebuilding and repopulation and left Seleukos to continue it, supporting high qualitative royal direction.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Rebuilding walls and houses does not prove title rules, cadastral allocation, confiscation, or parceling.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Returning refugees, redeemed captives, and new colonists form a positive mixed stream, but shares, origins, and household completeness are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The program is restorative and incorporative, while the demographic balance between former residents and newcomers is unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No killing, threat-driven recruitment, or lethal coercion by Antiochos is documented in the restoration program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The restoration was implemented, but Appian records renewed family flight in 190 BCE, limiting the demonstrated outcome to roughly six years.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The defining movement is return toward the homeland; unknown newcomer origins do not create an outward-separation measure.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Ransom, return, inducements, rebuilding, and recruitment do not establish an incoming coerced-labor stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_41_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-carthage-destruction-enslavement-land-seizure-149-146", "event_id": "gr-roman-carthage-destruction-enslavement-land-seizure-149-146", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Roman command and senatorial territorial settlement establish state direction without a historical percentage.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Land assignment, restrictions, taxation, and provincial rule are positive, while parcel-by-parcel title machinery is unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming successor-settler stream belongs to the bounded destruction and removal event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Urban destruction and guarded removal establish severe community loss, while completeness and the wider provincial population are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The assault, fire, bodies, and killings establish lethal coercion, while exact deaths and mortality share are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Immediate closure and territorial rule were durable enough to matter, but Junonia and later reuse reverse any claim of permanent vacancy.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Guarded departure and Orosius-attributed captive sale establish separation, while destinations, distance, return, and totals are unresolved.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Outgoing captives are not an incoming coerced-labor stream within the bounded Carthage territory.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-junonia-carthage-land-allotment-123-111", "event_id": "gr-roman-junonia-carthage-land-allotment-123-111", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The Gracchan program, commission, and later statute establish state direction without a numerical historical centre.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Allotment, continued possession, transfer, buyer protection, and legal confirmation provide strong qualitative evidence.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Appian reports colonist recruitment and allotment, while household composition, reproduction, denominator, and long-term scale are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded program does not identify prior holders or demonstrate resident removal; it cannot inherit Carthage's 146 BCE destruction.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No killing or life-threatening coercion is evidenced in the bounded allotment program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Continued holding, transfer, and legal protection are evidenced through 111 BCE; later institutional duration is unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Recruitment from all Italy does not establish town origins, travel distances, coercion, or return foreclosure.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming coerced-labor stream belongs to the Junonia allotment program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-marian-africa-veteran-allotment-program-103-100", "event_id": "gr-roman-marian-africa-veteran-allotment-program-103-100", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A late source reports a Saturninian law, supporting state direction with uncertain implementation.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Legislated land assignment is positive evidence, while parcels, registry, title form, and prior holders are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The assignment program gives a qualified placement signal, but beneficiary identity, origin, households, magnitude, and site implementation are unresolved.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No resident removal, replacement share, or prior-holder fate is demonstrated.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No killing or life-threatening coercion is evidenced in the bounded land-allotment program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Later Marian civic titles do not measure continuity from the 103 BCE program.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Beneficiary origin is disputed and no route, distance, coercion, or return evidence exists.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The program is not a documented coerced-labor importation.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_42_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-alban-hills-veteran-occupation", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-alban-hills-veteran-occupation", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The late notices report a Sullan legal frame, qualified by informal soldier execution and source lateness; no historical percentage is supported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Appropriation is explicit, while formal public-law allotment, exact title machinery, parcels, and magnitude are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Soldiers or veterans are explicit at Bovillae and Gabii, while origin, scale, household composition, equality, and the Castrimoenium cohort remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Resident movement and replacement are not demonstrated, and all three municipalities continued.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The notices contain no event-specific killing evidence; source silence is not a measured zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Duration of the appropriations is unknown, and municipal continuity does not measure tenure durability.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Soldier origins, movement distance, and separation outcomes are absent; no origin route is supported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming coerced-labor stream belongs to the bounded three-site occupation evidence.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_43_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-arretium-82-60", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-arretium-82-60", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Sullan publicatio and a colonist community establish state direction, while the local implementation chain and magnitude remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Legal conversion to public land and incomplete division are direct, while the distributed share, parcels, survey, registration, and title outcomes are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A Sullan colonist community is attested by 63 BCE, but its origin, size, household composition, territorial share, and demographic proportion are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Continued possession and civic continuity support an incorporation-leaning mixed outcome, but individual losses, departures, and resident-colonist balance cannot be centered numerically.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No event-specific killing or life-threatening coercion is evidenced for the bounded Arretine transition; source silence is not a measured zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Colonist presence persisted to 63 BCE while undivided possession remained unresolved in 60 BCE; the durable land and demographic outcome is only partially known.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No colonist origin, resident destination, movement distance, or return outcome is evidenced; absence of a route is not a numerical zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming coerced or unfree third-population labor stream belongs to the bounded Arretine event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-neapolis-massacre-82", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-neapolis-massacre-82", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Appian reports organized Sullan-aligned military action, while personal Sullan direction, command structure, and sustained program magnitude are not established.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The seizure of triremes is movable-property capture, not evidence of land confiscation, title transfer, surveying, registration, or allotment.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The bounded night attack contains no incoming settler or replacement-population stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Appian's reported extensive killing indicates severe immediate elimination, but the implicit victim noun, affected denominator, survivor balance, and later population composition are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Extensive killing is strongly evidenced as Appian's report, but the totalizing language is not a census and supports no numerical casualty proportion.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Immediate military seizure and later urban continuity are both supported, producing a mixed qualitative outcome rather than a measured durable-vacancy value.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A few escapees are reported, but their destinations, distance, duration away, and return are unknown; no separation magnitude is evidenced.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming coerced or unfree third-population labor stream belongs to the bounded Neapolitan attack.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_44_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-norba-destruction-82", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-norba-destruction-82", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "An organized armed force under Aemilius Lepidus entered by treachery, but no sustained state plan to destroy Norba's population or town is demonstrated.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No confiscation, allotment, title transfer, survey, registration, or other legal-property program is documented for the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming settler or replacement-population stream belongs to the bounded Norban event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Appian reports catastrophic resident self-destruction and urban abandonment, but his totalizing language supplies no denominator or reliable survivor share.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Lethal coercion is severe, but the armed seizure is the causal context while residents perform the immediate self- and mutual killing in Appian's narrative; no numerical rate survives.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The ancient urban site was not durably restored, while later use in the neighboring landscape prevents a whole-region permanent-vacancy claim.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Survivor movement, distance, destinations, duration away, and return are not documented; absence of a route is not a numerical zero.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming coerced or unfree third-population labor stream belongs to the event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-praeneste-82-80", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-praeneste-82-80", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Sulla directly supervised the punishment and the veteran colony was state-directed, but the complete implementation chain and magnitude are not recoverable.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Confiscated holdings and regulated veteran allotments are supported, while a complete cadastre, parcel map, and whole-territory transfer are not.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A Sullan veteran colony is secure, but veteran number, origin, household composition, territorial share, and demographic proportion are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Severe group-specific killing and a veteran colony coexist with spared women and children and later local-family continuity; no population denominator permits a numerical center.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Appian reports severe killing after surrender, but his totalizing language and Plutarch's incompatible figure do not supply a trustworthy victim proportion.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The colony and concentrated ownership persisted while local families and earlier urban fabric also remained, producing a mixed qualitative outcome.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Survivor destinations, movement distance, duration away, and return paths are not documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No imported coerced or unfree third-population labor stream is demonstrated for the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_45_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-proscriptions-82-81", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-proscriptions-82-81", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Public lists, rewards, concealment penalties, civic sanctions, and state confiscation make government direction qualitatively high, while implementation through agents, informers, purchasers, private enemies, and opportunists prevents a precise supervision score.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Confiscation, records, sale, and transfer are strongly evidenced, but the exact statute, title, complete property inventory, parcels, and execution of individual transactions are not.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coherent incoming settler or replacement-population stream belongs to this person-and-property event; purchasers and transferees are not demonstrated settlers.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Killing, banishment, civic disability, and estate loss are secure, but the exposed population, survivor, incorporation, return, and replacement denominators are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "State-authorized lethal coercion is integral and severe, but incompatible ancient list totals are not a death census and no affected-population denominator survives.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Property transfers and descendant disabilities persisted, but political disability was later reversed and exile, return, and estate outcomes varied; no precise durability center is supported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Banishment and flight are attested, but collective origins, destinations, routes, distances, duration abroad, and return histories are not documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coherent incoming coerced or unfree third-population labor stream belongs to the bounded proscription event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_46_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "gr-roman-sulla-volaterrae-82-45", "event_id": "gr-roman-sulla-volaterrae-82-45", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The state enactment is secure and qualitatively high, but implementation and continuity were incomplete.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Formal title changed to Roman public land, while distribution remained incomplete and individual outcomes are not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No completed incoming settlement is measurable; limited individual allotments remain possible but disputed.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Possessors largely remained and citizenship deprivation did not endure, supporting a low or mixed outcome toward incorporation without a measurable denominator.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No event-specific lethal coercion is evidenced inside the bounded legal-land event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Formal title, continuing possession, legal protection, and renewed threats coexist, so durability is mixed and uncertain.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No displaced population stream belongs to the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No coerced third-population labor stream belongs to the bounded event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-roman-sulla-nola-veteran-allotment-81-78-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-roman-sulla-nola-veteran-allotment-81-78-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "An official Sullan assignment framework is reported, making direction qualitatively high without a complete execution record.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Survey limits and land assignment are reported, but parcels, prior holders, and the exact legal execution are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Colonists are independently attested and assignment recipients are reported; scale, origin, household form, and demographic share remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The immediate treatment and demographic share of Nolan residents are not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No event-specific killing or lethal implementation is established within the bounded assignment event.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Early colonial status is attested, but the duration attributable to the Sullan assignment is not quantified.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No removed resident population stream is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Military land recipients are not a coerced outside-labor stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-roman-sulla-suessula-veteran-foundation-81-78-bce", "event_id": "prospective-gr-roman-sulla-suessula-veteran-foundation-81-78-bce", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A late source reports state-law foundation and assignment; direction is qualitatively high but source coverage is low.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The late report explicitly links legal foundation, Sullan limits, and veteran assignment, while local contemporary documentation is absent.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Veterans are named as recipients, but realized settlement, numbers, household composition, and durability are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Prior-holder and resident treatment is not reported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No local killing or lethal implementation is reported.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The durability of the reported Sullan outcome is not established.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No removed resident population stream is documented.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Veteran recipients are not a coerced outside-labor stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_47_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-tigranes-tigranokerta-forced-concentration", "event_id": "prospective-gr-hellenistic-tigranes-tigranokerta-forced-concentration", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Tigranes directly compelled the movement and populated his capital; administrative continuity is not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No reviewed source establishes a legal instrument, title transfer, survey, or formal property allocation.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Incoming residents populated the new capital; scale, household completeness, and long-run durability remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Source-city destruction or depopulation and incorporation into the new capital coexist without a denominator.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Compulsion and source-city destruction are attested; killing and mortality intensity are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The unfinished capital's outcome was substantially reversed by release and partial return in 69 BCE.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Movement into Mesopotamia establishes separation; distance, duration, and return share remain unresolved.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Forced settlement does not establish a destination labor regime or household-incomplete labor stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "late-antique-sasanian-hatra-depopulation", "event_id": "late-antique-sasanian-hatra-depopulation", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A royal Sasanian army under Ardashir conquered the city; implementation structure is not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No reviewed source documents title, survey, confiscation, registration, or allocation machinery.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No incoming successor settlement at Hatra is demonstrated.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The resident city and polity ended permanently, but death, departure, and captivity shares cannot be apportioned.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Final military conquest is violent coercion; no defensible casualty total or massacre evidence survives.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Specialist synthesis describes permanent abandonment of the inhabited settlement.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Deportation is reported and the resident city did not reconstitute; destination, distance, and individual fates are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No destination labor stream belongs to this bounded event; captivity alone is insufficient.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "late-antique-sasanian-shapur-antioch-captivity", "event_id": "late-antique-sasanian-shapur-antioch-captivity", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Shapur's imperial campaign and capture are clear; the administrative chain is not measured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Plunder does not establish formal property transfer, registration, survey, or allocation.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Durable family settlement of this first-capture cohort at a particular destination is not evidenced.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Later accounts report killing and captivity while Antioch survived and recovered; the magnitude is unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Killing and captivity are reported, but the accounts do not supply a population proportion or measured severity.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The source city recovered; destination durability for this cohort is unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Movement into Sasanian custody is supported; distance, destination allocation, and return remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Broader captive-labor practices do not identify this first-capture cohort as a labor stream.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_48_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "late-antique-sasanian-shapur-dura-europos-deportation", "event_id": "late-antique-sasanian-shapur-dura-europos-deportation", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A royal Sasanian siege, capture, and reported deportation establish strong state direction without a measured administrative chain.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "No reviewed source establishes title transfer, survey, registration, confiscation procedure, or property allocation.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_structural_na", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "This bounded source-site event has no demonstrated incoming successor settlement.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_structural_na", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The urban community ended, while the shares deported, killed, escaped, or otherwise absent are not recoverable.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A violent final siege and coercive removal are supported; population-wide severity is not measurable.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Urban abandonment at Dura was durable; this does not establish deportees' later outcomes.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Deportation establishes coerced removal, but distance, destination, route, and return conditions are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The removed cohort is an applicable referent, but no destination labor assignment or occupational role is evidenced.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "late-antique-sasanian-shapur-third-campaign-provincials", "event_id": "late-antique-sasanian-shapur-third-campaign-provincials", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Shapur's royal campaign and aggregate resettlement claim establish strong state direction without a measured administrative chain.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Settlement in royal domains does not establish individual title, cadastral, confiscation, or registration machinery.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The royal inscription says transported Roman people were settled in named Sasanian regions; magnitude and household form are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Aggregate removal is supported, while city-level shares and destination composition are not recoverable.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Forced transfer followed conquest and seizure; civilian severity cannot be measured across the campaign.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The inscription does not provide comparable long-term outcomes across source places or destination communities.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Cross-frontier forced movement is explicit, but distances, shares, return rules, and city-region pairings are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_not_evidenced", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Coerced settlement does not by itself establish a labor regime for this bounded cohort.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_not_evidenced", "value": null } ] }, { "case_id": "late-antique-sasanian-antioch-weh-antioch", "event_id": "late-antique-sasanian-antioch-weh-antioch", "traits": [ { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F1", "high": null, "highMeans": "More centralized, explicit, and continuously state-directed organization.", "id": "state_orchestration", "intensity": null, "label": "Government direction", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Khosrow is credited with capture, construction, transfer, provisioning, and direct royal jurisdiction; administrative continuity is unmeasured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F2", "high": null, "highMeans": "More formal title transfer, expropriation, surveying, registration, and legal instrumentation.", "id": "legal_proprietary_machinery", "intensity": null, "label": "Legal and property machinery", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Direct royal subordination and special rules are supported, while title transfer and individual property effects are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F3", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger, more family-complete, self-reproducing, and durable incoming resident population.", "id": "settler_implantation", "intensity": null, "label": "Settler implantation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A named purpose-built receiving community is supported; cohort size, household completeness, and exact site remain unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F4", "high": null, "highMeans": "More removal and demographic replacement, with less incorporation of the prior population.", "id": "elimination_vs_incorporation", "intensity": null, "label": "Elimination over incorporation", "low": null, "reviewReason": "A coerced cohort was implanted near Ctesiphon while Antioch survived and rebuilt; source and destination shares are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F5", "high": null, "highMeans": "More killing, life-threatening coercion, confinement, and destruction of subsistence.", "id": "lethal_coercion", "intensity": null, "label": "Lethal coercion", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Sack, capture, and forced removal establish strong coercion, but population-wide intensity and exceptions are unmeasured.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F6", "high": null, "highMeans": "A more persistent territorial, sovereign, and demographic result with less reversal or return.", "id": "durability_of_outcome", "intensity": null, "label": "Durability of outcome", "low": null, "reviewReason": "The receiving community endured while the source city recovered; a single unqualified scalar would hide that split.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F7", "high": null, "highMeans": "Displaced people were carried farther from home and return remained more completely blocked.", "id": "separation_from_homeland", "intensity": null, "label": "Separation from homeland", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Long-range coerced movement is supported; the exact itinerary and return conditions are unknown.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null }, { "band": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "coverage": null, "coverageBand": null, "factor": "F8", "high": null, "highMeans": "A larger distinct population was brought from elsewhere as enslaved, indentured, or otherwise unfree labor.", "id": "imported_unfree_labor", "intensity": null, "label": "Imported unfree labor", "low": null, "reviewReason": "Procopius names transported charioteers and musicians, supporting coerced occupational transfer for a subset only.", "sourceReview": "analysis/second_pass/v6/ATLAS_AUTHORING_BATCH_49_INDEPENDENT_REVIEW.md", "status": "source_review_partial_qualitative", "value": null } ] } ], "pending_factors": 0, "release_activated": false, "release_id": "second_pass_v7_676", "status": "MAIN_ACCEPTED_DISPLAY_CONTENT_NOT_EMBEDDED", "trait_cells": 2960 }