{ "status": "READOUT_PENDING_INDEPENDENT_VERIFICATION_AND_MAIN_DISPOSITION", "run_manifest_sha256": "e04666c721603cc5111d0421331be9855254c314364000dbc2fed37037d35100", "results_sha256": "91cd3d38aaf3bae80a4d7972c935d020bd48c56e4e78d0cada34104ecd5008f9", "canonical": { "baseline": { "scenario": "baseline", "category": "effect_separation", "events": 675, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 9, "horn_margin_8": 0.11095718574023739, "horn_margin_9": 0.06487897761572459, "horn_margin_10": -0.05656532384459645, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 1.148751313502521e-13, "angle_8_vs_successor": 18.689066772609852, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 1.2683566617307778e-13, "angle_9_vs_successor": 11.784825032329367, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.9999999999999998, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.0, "eligible_nominal_dates": 628 }, "successor": { "scenario": "successor", "category": "effect_separation", "events": 676, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 9, "horn_margin_8": 0.15387470687524907, "horn_margin_9": 0.0840767430991256, "horn_margin_10": -0.05845566216270037, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 18.689066772609834, "angle_8_vs_successor": 1.2046990495879039e-13, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 11.784825032329376, "angle_9_vs_successor": 8.35562024247675e-14, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.07752198555521075, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.1797583081570997, "eligible_nominal_dates": 627 } }, "effect_separation": [ { "scenario": "baseline", "category": "effect_separation", "events": 675, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 9, "horn_margin_8": 0.11095718574023739, "horn_margin_9": 0.06487897761572459, "horn_margin_10": -0.05656532384459645, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 1.148751313502521e-13, "angle_8_vs_successor": 18.689066772609852, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 1.2683566617307778e-13, "angle_9_vs_successor": 11.784825032329367, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.9999999999999998, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.0, "eligible_nominal_dates": 628 }, { "scenario": "retirement_only", "category": "effect_separation", "events": 662, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 9, "horn_margin_8": 0.1073037734522948, "horn_margin_9": 0.04119593973441771, "horn_margin_10": -0.07337562485047977, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 10.64686405998669, "angle_8_vs_successor": 11.810357555799396, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 4.88763340927793, "angle_9_vs_successor": 10.549287718453783, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.04080016493089185, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.030211480362537766, "eligible_nominal_dates": 615 }, { "scenario": "retained_corrections_only", "category": "effect_separation", "events": 675, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 9, "horn_margin_8": 0.17032734211565215, "horn_margin_9": 0.08011167400210173, "horn_margin_10": -0.045563350960398985, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 22.429916003991025, "angle_8_vs_successor": 12.089195566796374, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 9.411755167476072, "angle_9_vs_successor": 6.074773054155285, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.005375016004307502, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.12444444444444444, "eligible_nominal_dates": 630 }, { "scenario": "qualified_successors_without_retained_corrections", "category": "effect_separation", "events": 676, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 9, "horn_margin_8": 0.11930898009771873, "horn_margin_9": 0.0659553794850587, "horn_margin_10": -0.07086751210885289, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 8.422042167588476, "angle_8_vs_successor": 16.0669879281594, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 5.450432199890446, "angle_9_vs_successor": 10.556334151987139, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.9941942673122843, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.0770392749244713, "eligible_nominal_dates": 625 }, { "scenario": "successor", "category": "effect_separation", "events": 676, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 9, "horn_margin_8": 0.15387470687524907, "horn_margin_9": 0.0840767430991256, "horn_margin_10": -0.05845566216270037, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 18.689066772609834, "angle_8_vs_successor": 1.2046990495879039e-13, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 11.784825032329376, "angle_9_vs_successor": 8.35562024247675e-14, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.07752198555521075, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.1797583081570997, "eligible_nominal_dates": 627 } ], "scenario_records": 565, "by_category": { "effect_separation": 5, "weighting": 6, "missingness_subset": 32, "imputation": 6, "omission": 328, "boundary": 152, "linked_program_total_one": 1, "illustrative_upper_bound": 5, "metadata_only": 12, "metadata_only_weighting": 12, "metadata_only_imputation": 6 }, "unique_preprocessed_matrix_cases": 536, "status_counts": { "computed_diagnostic": 565 }, "retention_counts": { "9": 524, "8": 29, "7": 12 }, "limits": [ { "id": "editorial_family_comparisons", "kind": "editorial_only", "reason": "Only editorial mechanism/outcome-label comparisons; retain holds. No score selection, weight, family-derived pseudo-profile or new factor solution." }, { "id": "egypt_642_only_raw_profile", "kind": "unestimable", "reason": "No separately independently coded60-dimensional639/640–642-only alternative exists in the bound accepted Egypt producer; the actual successor includes645–646. Baseline broad parent is supplied separately, not a642-only profile. Metadata phase/start bounds remain available in the main join." }, { "id": "kitakami_internal_phase_raw_profiles", "kind": "unestimable", "reason": "The accepted774–811 profile is not independently coded774–779,780–805,806–811 profiles. No phase scores may be derived from dates or copied from that aggregate. The real older parent swap and three distinct Japanese successor omissions are available." } ], "indicator_overlap": { "baseline": { "status": "computed_diagnostic_not_a_fairness_verdict", "instrument_sha256": "64c6b25776366eef770f9cd1191b4b9d87ad139a36e295dd83596909dfc14c0d", "seed_base": 28082026, "horn_draws": 500, "horn_percentile": 95, "imputation": "full_dataset_global_medians_frozen_within_omission_comparison", "event_weights": "unchanged_equal_event", "scenarios": [ { "omitted_battery": null, "events": 675, "indicators": 60, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 9, "horn_margins": [ 11.30756758283755, 6.314052186023493, 3.1639890471773757, 2.385541258372351, 1.6053790027829626, 0.6846033028513183, 0.19572935435222694, 0.11095718574023739, 0.06487897761572459, -0.05656532384459645, -0.1870502628547095, -0.25183301347361753, -0.4011223122927795, -0.4260948545362834, -0.47242800415171116, -0.4793236244624959, -0.5392319493974351, -0.5225073598970389, -0.5289429001542035, -0.5585404125966206, -0.5725695102037619, -0.5729706283612707, -0.5689177563475152, -0.5825277836720881, -0.5781546358769984, -0.5825544804472542, -0.5821900140769876, -0.5737115319557422, -0.5901125494075063, -0.5856729071337067, -0.5838039480385095, -0.5777263997675501, -0.604203543940538, -0.5974048995828227, -0.5951972091070123, -0.5951355547279847, -0.5902911424402926, -0.5967833956565063, -0.5907672001822144, -0.5871856254852773, -0.5774421913152028, -0.5733482101697684, -0.5803983882565442, -0.5750224917464666, -0.568765020514915, -0.5701444205623956, -0.567432936293653, -0.558865982950081, -0.5616271308833213, -0.5554817334544623, -0.545219563059284, -0.5427921010129503, -0.5304450550968406, -0.5334667738556034, -0.5223293516877008, -0.5121460447324484, -0.5052018917705746, -0.5002972333516833, -0.4941650910907829, -0.47305129515805383 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 8.596074033730606e-14, 5.3777348799661405e-14, 5.0213650235610103e-14, 4.722307969964788e-14, 4.273021122825074e-14, 3.4208479668246505e-14, 1.549822202795145e-14, 9.403730799863604e-15 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 8.596074033730606e-14, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9999999999999999, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 1.0, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 1.2683566617307778e-13, 5.425000943667995e-14, 4.7094809407013387e-14, 4.2729362361599626e-14, 3.5571479151731954e-14, 2.744684702890368e-14, 1.911696851257238e-14, 1.2148393607721594e-14, 8.123803576592149e-15 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 1.2683566617307778e-13, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9999999999999998, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 1.0, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "settler-colonial-studies", "events": 675, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 8, "horn_margins": [ 7.717325188568436, 5.11087823213229, 2.695277289063265, 1.7541468398017002, 1.2719860487619297, 0.3310728619756087, 0.17733241687270285, 0.046980449048868334, -0.1303745358929096, -0.13996677928820378, -0.28392634721870635, -0.26686233490389, -0.4165704530397778, -0.4212996941319558, -0.4383824621421035, -0.4723832431221817, -0.49050672534158424, -0.5039136185345356, -0.5362754824834904, -0.5440459560305418, -0.5573780053747321, -0.5488048921603814, -0.5603856021207418, -0.5542453428884067, -0.5440891377757948, -0.5429778799679466, -0.560570169964457, -0.5574829038130862, -0.5532336599948067, -0.5720471677705119, -0.5626367264725218, -0.5679718547335817, -0.5724131199846085, -0.5757322283192152, -0.5714425762033355, -0.557497236315107, -0.5516405193989149, -0.5482057934695005, -0.5512653035803479, -0.5587197604198357, -0.553999582121447, -0.5409922523865853, -0.5508084282306569, -0.5408967808327894, -0.529432919216937, -0.5308197414188897, -0.5363196832565563, -0.5213483325719445 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 88.23869797120426, 10.581118136338393, 3.4777381357137163, 2.593079385178925, 1.7606024262722326, 0.9646256279966025, 0.7005174413114573, 0.5150144136051955 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 88.23869797120426, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.18026957311303757, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8286036019503413, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 25.499971542482328, 12.947776207583548, 5.545649361494848, 3.1136777410582135, 1.761716641203111, 1.3333948056798186, 0.7596500659787543, 0.6788471006037123, 0.4089965437986445 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 25.499971542482328, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9273251707332896, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9701224167821118, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "political-economy-land-labor", "events": 675, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 7, "horn_margins": [ 9.099523290815926, 5.160998227503406, 2.6867277161096705, 1.756194108436683, 1.217354064278644, 0.25989888693826124, 0.10057424138565496, -0.091317966702686, -0.16099133508452557, -0.2623237559018603, -0.29764363656522563, -0.3871120444068812, -0.40558931369525264, -0.48393309499304593, -0.518303958256108, -0.5348049475361584, -0.5176199930492185, -0.5539020803834561, -0.5500296925883208, -0.5685905968341612, -0.5685487306611301, -0.5715044274126981, -0.5727066779709815, -0.5662269470510921, -0.5693891677013595, -0.5783298275601235, -0.5736617860640307, -0.5930028725264925, -0.5948614123467943, -0.5971453512599482, -0.5915269861176219, -0.585173132038124, -0.5851097735729365, -0.5867945920778761, -0.5865368378305618, -0.5790401510485046, -0.5837117331578647, -0.5882031872393546, -0.5825643719377942, -0.5773057244102755, -0.5661361038520364, -0.5567785665096008, -0.5570806368435278, -0.5556255054175313, -0.5371820619919966, -0.5300762713578295, -0.5213106915531975, -0.5064404986287722 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 32.656295714323626, 8.69685941428991, 5.323220595707481, 2.5481356678645217, 1.5981069436858875, 0.8357810726621345, 0.42969776519589653, 0.29847222902736853 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 32.656295714323626, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9277817084436548, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9792251231773498, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 51.7755279939259, 15.95441268187104, 5.819866277693425, 4.674254305218345, 1.7237144107093205, 1.2375775839193193, 0.8389969431174065, 0.3848561102530647, 0.3035536299395329 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 51.7755279939259, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.5965221540219483, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8444285101370235, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "historical-demography", "events": 675, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 6, "horn_margins": [ 8.408637528253932, 5.734911154665875, 2.476344391694642, 1.7749667189976686, 0.7720804621077892, 0.06841481001745486, -0.03807691745273023, -0.05802144910398188, -0.12419396903352342, -0.14681341744269938, -0.25498858263972424, -0.3756055602454421, -0.4012812018045595, -0.4456380660356447, -0.4693164031367708, -0.46980714841308824, -0.5072862222084384, -0.5497048784780689, -0.5478556137613071, -0.5485432051605765, -0.5548838270510306, -0.5624531941592732, -0.5606192714818987, -0.5545897283306183, -0.555867981391555, -0.5581913014472422, -0.5571599849588993, -0.5508895052810379, -0.5441882183735955, -0.5565393856635473, -0.56990320427221, -0.5632553740165882, -0.5575570599067123, -0.5587441698218545, -0.56156605356633, -0.5541883016310664, -0.5430425213585637, -0.5393981738142153, -0.5466224799268155, -0.5356267291209207, -0.5437811246544608, -0.5426510358038463, -0.5340637402694567, -0.5234697575420516, -0.5264668605648675, -0.5205310381082764, -0.5152819397417566, -0.519556375230847 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 59.832586142242285, 21.28736180236425, 8.334314161207624, 3.145650524686351, 1.9692047741838061, 1.30153393853436, 0.707072050323924, 0.20879285773431355 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 59.832586142242285, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.7564814265963884, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9014338173466856, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 35.30182990034424, 15.253692396380789, 10.756532012396423, 6.784628488816546, 3.070392142455895, 1.7530532564463777, 0.898636941158098, 0.5899478619065389, 0.20859717878717499 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 35.30182990034424, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.7456839373434246, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8960188415377434, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "genocide-forced-migration", "events": 675, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 8, "horn_margins": [ 9.935318944187328, 4.397689593226618, 2.0499404131039647, 1.6341992301314234, 1.2169515846464836, 0.5381706053060493, 0.03500977957358686, 0.01821209570439608, -0.1062510084838213, -0.1803468580552967, -0.19385966061373372, -0.345398458028478, -0.39927843984213895, -0.44444724576883154, -0.45384514336420023, -0.5184878736546115, -0.5272645296385307, -0.5435199123598939, -0.5629782127625729, -0.5624415399797055, -0.5606395740433208, -0.5582550223318407, -0.5652065247647211, -0.5654419954379981, -0.5646865329756781, -0.5685928465305706, -0.5766825540837555, -0.5794367663513142, -0.5817884317058746, -0.6050919806495239, -0.5966685329357558, -0.5989115421488325, -0.588758511088755, -0.587868197982347, -0.5843122811651298, -0.5881131456241437, -0.5854383465282371, -0.5858422269435639, -0.5781548374186828, -0.5708897541360826, -0.5685595320262726, -0.5743332333362678, -0.5706891030031194, -0.5594254131556098, -0.5460549477110027, -0.5403432013200389, -0.5284806112290422, -0.521573623369274 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 83.20158687405319, 9.616692075506059, 4.71140522817903, 3.1367653849307437, 1.5873923208667076, 1.0441095047352977, 0.8696892817599908, 0.22335024250147278 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 83.20158687405319, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.30602592501418635, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.7994264658850063, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 61.036372519911914, 10.458364342683547, 6.948330866287374, 3.7521184333897892, 2.943921916990811, 1.180087365524804, 0.9156160128972826, 0.5949338394853235, 0.1596131618764236 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 61.036372519911914, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.5361063349976529, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.808862385741582, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "state-sovereignty-ideology", "events": 675, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization" ], "horn_factors": 7, "horn_margins": [ 9.64518597350027, 4.2946116489065815, 2.719271153295116, 1.760805855070772, 0.9035787582986337, 0.6445793900930856, 0.12183439249988326, -0.1043241199896352, -0.20851106836039923, -0.19473045138732448, -0.2388251308481797, -0.28621957065583115, -0.4241257669779711, -0.45461052825370163, -0.4568704145179563, -0.5080056485344047, -0.5416862113799891, -0.5425719624150931, -0.5525846511888992, -0.5734334229666596, -0.5596713769115296, -0.5717594373186452, -0.5733431686578108, -0.5771506357353111, -0.5704565629226024, -0.5918369205846448, -0.5797334986076637, -0.5709848618344382, -0.5793906748193622, -0.5970658021010605, -0.5883375508601443, -0.5945975369318467, -0.5835709284670292, -0.5880154628328471, -0.5903335477382029, -0.5874906565046832, -0.5954639723826346, -0.5905903743098924, -0.5816337312158457, -0.5805134974009069, -0.5684929676884232, -0.5590006677952495, -0.5523192976025975, -0.538726200271411, -0.5413239290475018, -0.550279018758187, -0.5318865704024109, -0.5222652811541482 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 76.26462626347507, 12.973158782781493, 3.830267765571924, 2.720007403412324, 1.376954910964493, 0.9843148797585887, 0.6132660926901148, 0.2263795495870709 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 76.26462626347507, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.43577058127306895, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8615321100990723, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 23.57553081824706, 9.173175454234416, 5.35238015409106, 2.43941807641971, 1.9705741616565295, 0.9474023641047083, 0.8706925800887608, 0.435676067482974, 0.14774262396666563 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 23.57553081824706, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9367489562717153, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9817478897419463, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } } ] }, "successor": { "status": "computed_diagnostic_not_a_fairness_verdict", "instrument_sha256": "64c6b25776366eef770f9cd1191b4b9d87ad139a36e295dd83596909dfc14c0d", "seed_base": 28082026, "horn_draws": 500, "horn_percentile": 95, "imputation": "full_dataset_global_medians_frozen_within_omission_comparison", "event_weights": "unchanged_equal_event", "scenarios": [ { "omitted_battery": null, "events": 676, "indicators": 60, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 9, "horn_margins": [ 11.007114941271462, 6.355396035647831, 3.2177992003816054, 2.409744753788631, 1.596383435747368, 0.7111093925275889, 0.16123447546041847, 0.15387470687524907, 0.0840767430991256, -0.05845566216270037, -0.2094949029551607, -0.24838957353080904, -0.39319248670588414, -0.4425671032027463, -0.4863819111769856, -0.49298583453306466, -0.5156442641070947, -0.5212535939651526, -0.5218138857812669, -0.5576540475599657, -0.5500561125222059, -0.5547125182649697, -0.5672330121287679, -0.5767333213285029, -0.5835427837966816, -0.5786425871364299, -0.5883084835511807, -0.5776251556139407, -0.5781565391093613, -0.5779692208061202, -0.568123895283084, -0.5695965014529202, -0.5974557942517493, -0.5886871773709649, -0.590495116326879, -0.5928361602594263, -0.5872371083498618, -0.5937240894335752, -0.5810883074398756, -0.5759988584446065, -0.5756081664868926, -0.5680703493364758, -0.5816181122053117, -0.5726761685559656, -0.5674241150030086, -0.5656304269575206, -0.5688110941577065, -0.5644576991895839, -0.5588795586757057, -0.5525029719368206, -0.5419495892820945, -0.5321500838347671, -0.5216587569630021, -0.529259451988978, -0.5227919871514689, -0.5201905861117737, -0.5068498867831568, -0.49997126745387566, -0.4953984267059718, -0.4728322172410408 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 8.230480201335555e-14, 6.341189714225977e-14, 6.106180624735282e-14, 5.500731976722475e-14, 4.3869316441700535e-14, 3.085403711590809e-14, 2.9021876809273964e-14, 3.806437572803419e-15 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 8.230480201335555e-14, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9999999999999998, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 1.0, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 8.35562024247675e-14, 7.365327457221877e-14, 5.247782333098631e-14, 4.2528855197800726e-14, 3.578290172217702e-14, 3.182358288896256e-14, 1.8902797313069527e-14, 7.189442983363398e-15, 4.687272313157095e-15 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 8.35562024247675e-14, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9999999999999999, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 1.0, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "settler-colonial-studies", "events": 676, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 8, "horn_margins": [ 7.468829874818846, 5.156183933424023, 2.6637834492976618, 1.7809487426067032, 1.2158578371028372, 0.3579839530091229, 0.16710244369872562, 0.05709726487281741, -0.09846541139514708, -0.13859948619154738, -0.2777861402013371, -0.30674960074142366, -0.3920493797651159, -0.42028406219137215, -0.4355059295129948, -0.4570607711270225, -0.4862527082657815, -0.472879179856744, -0.5363197327580818, -0.5401121010503691, -0.5442280309051385, -0.5308247810985396, -0.5451764246973634, -0.5453612291364367, -0.5622062784482269, -0.5499318572508625, -0.5469554552722032, -0.5502493394475698, -0.5517772730785814, -0.5503947148596754, -0.5648058113249186, -0.5639717928524053, -0.558954128124926, -0.562457399621141, -0.5560955785814012, -0.5436245228542119, -0.5428987207545404, -0.5417311400307354, -0.5431686267813951, -0.5518281242170189, -0.5537319886004035, -0.5503579478819713, -0.5382387058255625, -0.5408828737749789, -0.533515925982186, -0.5342473477230346, -0.5323952764240617, -0.5207732448795989 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 70.30661963005717, 10.879070398909835, 2.9104945916059655, 2.3825229312027445, 1.943018774474349, 0.9876752848834606, 0.638515576369673, 0.492612197814858 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 70.30661963005717, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.3166967424345665, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.7473547487179294, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 23.56131027238656, 12.501243963724262, 6.725792655589962, 2.280682291246458, 1.691634933343934, 1.6152660285829197, 0.7387137225104459, 0.658670444203204, 0.4350963709212176 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 23.56131027238656, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.6101629428572, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8799583338215123, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "political-economy-land-labor", "events": 676, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 7, "horn_margins": [ 8.936020788823607, 5.149177326168946, 2.813028075324339, 1.8409412971356955, 1.1393761967592566, 0.2366719614635795, 0.09510872770086864, -0.06842190451499675, -0.14137054624964573, -0.26755259116071817, -0.2902148623069858, -0.3990693697989025, -0.42046675515139775, -0.47517378336873395, -0.512714120563494, -0.5275594593082217, -0.5243683316526313, -0.5578601594866948, -0.5437247244168442, -0.5614316315468383, -0.5807138567305752, -0.5649605878478641, -0.579745948655594, -0.5665605403808167, -0.567758059529206, -0.5744234109414813, -0.5742860176372699, -0.5891132170391182, -0.5803067108064377, -0.5915324228578935, -0.5924711324599978, -0.58134339684385, -0.5725658138385379, -0.5873805436079805, -0.5894754066250756, -0.582682999108645, -0.5790021501814939, -0.5836580028808394, -0.5783334398314428, -0.5733695927344875, -0.5649513314193679, -0.5519229638424752, -0.5508570171956872, -0.5542221159074824, -0.545065029943135, -0.5308337981426825, -0.5265596625126682, -0.5113625090033742 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 24.02704785846838, 10.476241554912038, 4.5122417643381905, 2.149915730175702, 1.0437935280872397, 0.9207215584607, 0.3898720201606174, 0.25311340420380884 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 24.02704785846838, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.7633282753644492, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9140786945197716, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 55.6692663544991, 13.901932303139555, 4.89004568769971, 4.64755348675022, 1.8401452829601144, 0.9641533890437165, 0.9169859636067227, 0.36110137065858394, 0.25922812704796755 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 55.6692663544991, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.4254421302781178, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8378899255685104, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "historical-demography", "events": 676, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 6, "horn_margins": [ 7.982714767788806, 5.841100832416169, 2.513228564423412, 1.8191465397028876, 0.7982490913504157, 0.13636143348977248, -0.022660684213049898, -0.10319330928325443, -0.129646668704831, -0.12120109515097033, -0.26374220089247813, -0.3700886314909535, -0.3836647559810742, -0.45144412866617545, -0.4692558992539778, -0.4525864507279713, -0.509127865768617, -0.5249052968959438, -0.551216966371244, -0.5408631289525035, -0.5368438880960865, -0.5488128703469369, -0.553005094614496, -0.5592297062864797, -0.5481125743508941, -0.5501393668729723, -0.540304091361905, -0.5433152828120886, -0.5584380040248889, -0.5523135164280331, -0.5588406750189252, -0.5555009517913403, -0.5457574206804386, -0.5577043349336681, -0.5498276173835414, -0.5497591486185849, -0.5455747307643788, -0.530552238808527, -0.5510158302993622, -0.539421842055683, -0.545376745325579, -0.5411239775927359, -0.5317972334392513, -0.5231154848128836, -0.5305780014071971, -0.5178789314523423, -0.5167618014247348, -0.5211643304697362 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 64.75269160938205, 15.340821544959578, 6.726444292745521, 3.700012021978794, 2.079028277372538, 0.9657578049117461, 0.7452309031219341, 0.217815165960749 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 64.75269160938205, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.5094787211357116, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8582057785893485, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 35.223543413086205, 11.88849346540521, 7.64749272013219, 5.629706872083158, 3.030373011934428, 1.877668932973861, 0.8569661271009291, 0.5074963083786693, 0.2256139219623415 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 35.223543413086205, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.723561766936509, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9062617124972474, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "genocide-forced-migration", "events": 676, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "ssi_carrier_centralization", "ssi_legal_instrumentation_depth", "ssi_sovereignty_transfer_form", "ssi_displaced_status_trajectory", "ssi_legitimating_doctrine_codification", "ssi_geopolitical_separation", "ssi_legibility_engineering", "ssi_displaced_polity_stateness", "ssi_settler_polity_autonomy", "ssi_boundary_hardening", "ssi_sovereignty_outcome_durability", "ssi_external_contestation_peak" ], "horn_factors": 8, "horn_margins": [ 9.705373714492117, 4.503266540850456, 2.039216926442421, 1.7759379138015512, 1.2092070843319125, 0.47701737284389045, 0.05250049695847725, 0.03760871839693536, -0.08116362683961587, -0.20290751286656405, -0.2174155053574609, -0.31664933781317905, -0.40135928232741735, -0.47042408546694503, -0.48479068844432927, -0.5063813862098134, -0.5295564319002323, -0.5353622125876267, -0.5469276230578151, -0.5622364784629295, -0.5518210595454273, -0.5530116792457018, -0.5612734015687445, -0.5552983967550573, -0.5728810736500806, -0.579303494601412, -0.5719902776460453, -0.5705039432396488, -0.5810307275707282, -0.5870399213479396, -0.5824847758741477, -0.5946305135793546, -0.5897105314712561, -0.5928934518069471, -0.59294096521656, -0.5879893657025367, -0.5889150836342056, -0.5821054978585023, -0.5722387911895194, -0.5646669803153113, -0.5639679953280566, -0.5682423984831884, -0.5709541181516018, -0.561268537125109, -0.5573746621000554, -0.5397555491416887, -0.5309620614807576, -0.5247608878095287 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 82.26532527594402, 9.368278527754157, 3.908878695255792, 3.3362298573894984, 1.5531878854246772, 1.0622114430318856, 0.8791283977223667, 0.21174873874732342 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 82.26532527594402, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.30233633326751475, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8670812233971323, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 58.125268092051364, 9.333248379864528, 5.929875935366668, 3.5766042325755603, 3.144643815921626, 1.2083305338270174, 0.879307642910896, 0.5975535460265156, 0.15821845494887282 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 58.125268092051364, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.40999123793275755, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.8270183269768087, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } }, { "omitted_battery": "state-sovereignty-ideology", "events": 676, "indicators": 48, "kept_dimension_ids": [ "scs_settler_permanence_orientation", "scs_metropole_anchorage", "scs_settler_sovereignty_capture", "scs_native_labor_articulation", "scs_transfer_mode_multiplicity", "scs_land_tenure_extinguishment", "scs_symbolic_indigenization", "scs_settler_agency_locus", "scs_exogenous_labor_triad", "scs_structural_persistence", "scs_demographic_saturation", "scs_prior_polity_recognition", "pel_frontier_land_labor_ratio", "pel_native_labor_incorporation", "pel_unfree_incomer_share", "pel_title_transfer_formalization", "pel_land_commodification", "pel_fixed_capital_intensity", "pel_export_orientation", "pel_organizing_agent_locus", "pel_strategic_position_weight", "pel_incomer_household_composition", "pel_incomer_influx_tempo", "pel_production_regime_conversion", "hdem_prior_population_removal", "hdem_incomer_share_at_consolidation", "hdem_displacement_scale", "hdem_migrant_stream_family_completeness", "hdem_mortality_share_of_prior_decline", "hdem_transformation_tempo", "hdem_settler_reproduction_engine", "hdem_stream_coordination", "hdem_displaced_relocation_distance", "hdem_destination_saturation", "hdem_prior_ancestry_in_successor_population", "hdem_present_day_endpoint", "gfm_coercion_apex", "gfm_lethality_of_process", "gfm_subsistence_destruction", "gfm_perpetrator_state_centrality", "gfm_intent_legibility", "gfm_pattern_imposition", "gfm_survivor_confinement", "gfm_return_foreclosure", "gfm_displacement_tempo", "gfm_category_permeability", "gfm_sex_differential_targeting", "gfm_expropriation_formalization" ], "horn_factors": 7, "horn_margins": [ 9.444721989764124, 4.236377525218991, 2.7663631679975778, 1.8284509449533486, 0.9541082803745484, 0.6432329552587883, 0.13064103725777332, -0.08599434218675839, -0.17005404530124202, -0.20160978258218298, -0.2437101048394934, -0.28827891651238857, -0.41122715174560576, -0.46333878054390376, -0.46895616992322686, -0.5068355467892368, -0.5378800656844407, -0.5511537240751305, -0.5637602465582123, -0.5550193514592908, -0.5600704706872215, -0.5739700450291099, -0.5679536417911262, -0.5741108151172575, -0.572121901611673, -0.5693351280070579, -0.5722470881792046, -0.5638960498813024, -0.5855739472758935, -0.5869698063130234, -0.5886797565398469, -0.5784109210722516, -0.5871263418397665, -0.5939767261225158, -0.5942045202152914, -0.5878852803129997, -0.5909113389850532, -0.5875206770364716, -0.5799481390147181, -0.5744549585559446, -0.5644241236383485, -0.5557372606209685, -0.5488641513034618, -0.5399930856246338, -0.5583926820474577, -0.5471919797900249, -0.5344493951691787, -0.5227189854975084 ], "fits": { "8": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 8, "candidate_rank": 8, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 85.624942185376, 11.41392945947312, 3.504156761890009, 2.828800529308731, 1.3991753309510395, 0.9972414895270508, 0.6697438579049013, 0.2259206389084931 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 85.624942185376, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.33776374780317747, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.7904624396440963, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] }, "9": { "status": "compared", "reference_rank": 9, "candidate_rank": 9, "principal_angles_degrees": [ 16.202246311629203, 8.342802508879728, 6.432037324968254, 2.7370049618458494, 2.396460835232479, 0.9866049872833812, 0.7540674059535242, 0.4286884724116042, 0.13135071599391282 ], "maximum_principal_angle_degrees": 16.202246311629203, "minimum_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.699548600226227, "mean_aligned_axis_tucker": 0.9283006350013463, "reference_warnings": [], "candidate_warnings": [] } } } ] } }, "largest_changes_vs_successor": { "8": [ { "scenario": "baseline/raw_region_string_stress_not_normalized", "category": "weighting", "events": 675, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.04034886616761191, "horn_margin_9": -0.1974075297489093, "horn_margin_10": -0.3179986606076721, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 70.22407444105932, "angle_8_vs_successor": 74.9172619192007, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 68.22091785142514, "angle_9_vs_successor": 64.16420948750631, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": null, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": null, "eligible_nominal_dates": null }, { "scenario": "baseline/maximum_missing_0", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 206, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2630359878873889, "horn_margin_9": -0.29054089157767415, "horn_margin_10": -0.4286014095031536, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 76.97558880243321, "angle_8_vs_successor": 74.62259183617016, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.39352892458477, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.72716861387589, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.05752947248659325, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5097087378640777, "eligible_nominal_dates": 206 }, { "scenario": "baseline/maximum_missing_0/frozen", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 206, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2630359878873889, "horn_margin_9": -0.29054089157767415, "horn_margin_10": -0.4286014095031536, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 76.97558880243321, "angle_8_vs_successor": 74.62259183617016, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.39352892458477, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.72716861387589, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.05752947248659325, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5097087378640777, "eligible_nominal_dates": 206 }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_0", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 204, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2540106451016506, "horn_margin_9": -0.27407158761765027, "horn_margin_10": -0.4244587584558077, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 75.61083639788565, "angle_8_vs_successor": 73.53297526429134, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.15409175140985, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.5333150437028, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.059337100387105296, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5049019607843137, "eligible_nominal_dates": 204 }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_0/frozen", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 204, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2540106451016506, "horn_margin_9": -0.27407158761765027, "horn_margin_10": -0.4244587584558077, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 75.61083639788565, "angle_8_vs_successor": 73.53297526429134, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.15409175140985, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.5333150437028, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.059337100387105296, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5049019607843137, "eligible_nominal_dates": 204 }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_15/frozen", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 411, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.008668074072346155, "horn_margin_9": -0.08506164037885688, "horn_margin_10": -0.16188905152768696, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 85.75312900877452, "angle_8_vs_successor": 71.57253587023396, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 27.369791396934527, "angle_9_vs_successor": 26.354754988348372, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.03275804501316304, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.2944038929440389, "eligible_nominal_dates": 411 }, { "scenario": "successor/raw_region_string_stress_not_normalized", "category": "weighting", "events": 676, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.03916115780833551, "horn_margin_9": -0.1615078328878583, "horn_margin_10": -0.32932044376628977, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 69.1513192147371, "angle_8_vs_successor": 69.76182633919682, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 58.04944906486315, "angle_9_vs_successor": 51.86790923810544, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": null, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": null, "eligible_nominal_dates": null }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_15", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 411, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.033366619657996255, "horn_margin_9": -0.08681984534931897, "horn_margin_10": -0.17360532140465268, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 82.52444646079806, "angle_8_vs_successor": 67.74446636882291, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 26.573917570387472, "angle_9_vs_successor": 25.40675092426528, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.4658366807235613, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.41849148418491483, "eligible_nominal_dates": 411 }, { "scenario": "baseline/structural_zero_upper_bound_NOT_RECODE", "category": "imputation", "events": 675, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.020837473961481612, "horn_margin_9": -0.022783036625068087, "horn_margin_10": -0.1417870923354445, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 77.06210740095173, "angle_8_vs_successor": 65.85662772590524, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 70.63907885824568, "angle_9_vs_successor": 70.12427588210144, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.463060047558113, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.21333333333333335, "eligible_nominal_dates": 628 }, { "scenario": "baseline/maximum_missing_30", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 611, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.07969635830220922, "horn_margin_9": -0.01577319282432388, "horn_margin_10": -0.07088351275449933, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 81.33438686542004, "angle_8_vs_successor": 65.8495476885635, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 18.778626241192644, "angle_9_vs_successor": 16.165544285713008, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.06415962491576038, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.18166939443535188, "eligible_nominal_dates": 588 } ], "9": [ { "scenario": "baseline/maximum_missing_0", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 206, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2630359878873889, "horn_margin_9": -0.29054089157767415, "horn_margin_10": -0.4286014095031536, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 76.97558880243321, "angle_8_vs_successor": 74.62259183617016, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.39352892458477, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.72716861387589, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.05752947248659325, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5097087378640777, "eligible_nominal_dates": 206 }, { "scenario": "baseline/maximum_missing_0/frozen", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 206, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2630359878873889, "horn_margin_9": -0.29054089157767415, "horn_margin_10": -0.4286014095031536, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 76.97558880243321, "angle_8_vs_successor": 74.62259183617016, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.39352892458477, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.72716861387589, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.05752947248659325, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5097087378640777, "eligible_nominal_dates": 206 }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_0", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 204, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2540106451016506, "horn_margin_9": -0.27407158761765027, "horn_margin_10": -0.4244587584558077, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 75.61083639788565, "angle_8_vs_successor": 73.53297526429134, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.15409175140985, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.5333150437028, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.059337100387105296, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5049019607843137, "eligible_nominal_dates": 204 }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_0/frozen", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 204, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.2540106451016506, "horn_margin_9": -0.27407158761765027, "horn_margin_10": -0.4244587584558077, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 75.61083639788565, "angle_8_vs_successor": 73.53297526429134, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 75.15409175140985, "angle_9_vs_successor": 75.5333150437028, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.059337100387105296, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.5049019607843137, "eligible_nominal_dates": 204 }, { "scenario": "baseline/structural_zero_upper_bound_NOT_RECODE", "category": "imputation", "events": 675, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.020837473961481612, "horn_margin_9": -0.022783036625068087, "horn_margin_10": -0.1417870923354445, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 77.06210740095173, "angle_8_vs_successor": 65.85662772590524, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 70.63907885824568, "angle_9_vs_successor": 70.12427588210144, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.463060047558113, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.21333333333333335, "eligible_nominal_dates": 628 }, { "scenario": "successor/structural_zero_upper_bound_NOT_RECODE", "category": "imputation", "events": 676, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.04033015506180848, "horn_margin_9": -0.01999114622730258, "horn_margin_10": -0.11539650207370222, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 56.249963979554856, "angle_8_vs_successor": 48.05500301484884, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 69.36602892686575, "angle_9_vs_successor": 68.28617308537662, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.040820222903316015, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.27794561933534745, "eligible_nominal_dates": 627 }, { "scenario": "baseline/raw_region_string_stress_not_normalized", "category": "weighting", "events": 675, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 7, "horn_margin_8": -0.04034886616761191, "horn_margin_9": -0.1974075297489093, "horn_margin_10": -0.3179986606076721, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 70.22407444105932, "angle_8_vs_successor": 74.9172619192007, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 68.22091785142514, "angle_9_vs_successor": 64.16420948750631, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": null, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": null, "eligible_nominal_dates": null }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_5/frozen", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 267, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.21220193650796149, "horn_margin_9": -0.16425134209640713, "horn_margin_10": -0.2882431292323373, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 63.74662972987301, "angle_8_vs_successor": 59.91737859727209, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 57.77381710201129, "angle_9_vs_successor": 54.73826786849332, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.03375654477391875, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.4044943820224719, "eligible_nominal_dates": 267 }, { "scenario": "successor/maximum_missing_5", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 267, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.1794150358659372, "horn_margin_9": -0.1604548545542943, "horn_margin_10": -0.28737133758513345, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 64.4993879497948, "angle_8_vs_successor": 60.77533793521579, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 57.67648094713253, "angle_9_vs_successor": 54.59365403374104, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.031382393901739754, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.41198501872659177, "eligible_nominal_dates": 267 }, { "scenario": "baseline/maximum_missing_5/frozen", "category": "missingness_subset", "events": 272, "status": "computed_diagnostic", "retained_factors": 8, "horn_margin_8": 0.23578508012925692, "horn_margin_9": -0.17248383797429812, "horn_margin_10": -0.28555728456382057, "fit_8": "computed", "angle_8_vs_baseline": 63.82362788595703, "angle_8_vs_successor": 59.643438965054635, "fit_9": "computed", "angle_9_vs_baseline": 57.185914892549846, "angle_9_vs_successor": 54.02147212328291, "minimum_named_tucker_vs_baseline": 0.04972329584303584, "legacy_k6_changed_share_vs_baseline": 0.41544117647058826, "eligible_nominal_dates": 272 } ] }, "interpretation_limits": [ "Scenario records and cache units are not counts of independent experiments or newly fitted historical events.", "The retained factor count, eight descriptive traits and six editorial families are distinct products.", "Angles and retention changes cannot validate a historical boundary or select the desired result.", "Era/source/missingness contrasts are within-corpus diagnostics, not evidence of worldwide completeness or universal human nature.", "Nominal date sensitivity does not measure historical pace; unknown duration is not zero.", "Illustrative weights and old-parent counterfactuals never change the historical roster." ], "release_authorized": false, "public_refresh_performed": false }